Re: [FRIAM] Calling all cladisticists

2009-01-05 Thread Phil Henshaw
Jack, Nice comments on the history of science and the issue. I'd agree with the cladists that design does not reveal its provenance, but with the evolutionists that most differences in design arise from their provenance. So to me, looking at your evidence to see a) how to distinguish one pattern

Re: [FRIAM] Calling all cladisticists

2009-01-04 Thread Jack K. Horner
Here's my ruble's worth on the cladistics and related questions: 1. For at least 30 years, there has been a feud in the biological cladistics community about whether cladistics should or does concern itself with history/evolution. If you enjoy a good shouting match, peruse the