[FRIAM] Uncertainty vs Information - redux and resolution

2011-07-20 Thread Grant Holland
In a thread early last month I was doing my thing of stirring the pot by making noise about the equivalence of 'information' and 'uncertainty' - and I was quoting Shannon to back me up. We all know that the two concepts are ultimately semantically opposed - if for no other reason than

Re: [FRIAM] Uncertainty vs Information - redux and resolution

2011-07-20 Thread ERIC P. CHARLES
That is potentially fascinating. However, it is not terribly interesting to state that we can establish a conservation principle merely by giving a name to the absence of something, and then pointing out that if we start with a set amount of that something, and take it away in chunks, then the

Re: [FRIAM] Uncertainty vs Information - redux and resolution

2011-07-20 Thread Grant Holland
Eric, True enough. And yet, this is what Information Theory has decided to do: treat the amount of _information_ that gets realized by performing an experiment as the same as the amount of _uncertainty_ from which it was liberated. That way, they can use entropy as the measure of both. I'm