Sala-i-Martin (was Re: Relative Wretchedness

2002-07-25 Thread Keith Hudson
Hi Ed, Ray and Karen, To Ed in particular I must say that I felt a little guilty in my posting of last night in changing the thread from your Relative Wretchedness to Gyres and shooting off tangentially instead of discussing the point you were making. However, in getting rid of gyres for the

Re: Sala-i-Martin (was Re: Relative Wretchedness

2002-07-25 Thread Ed Weick
Keith Hudson: Therefore, quite besides the cultural/conceptual features (which they may share with larger regions or gyres) each country has a unique economic structure, and needs a unique solution if it wants to emerge into reasonable prosperity. But who can supply this? Certainly (in my

Re: Sala-i-Martin (was Re: Relative Wretchedness

2002-07-25 Thread Keith Hudson
Ed, At 08:47 25/07/02 -0400, you wrote: Keith Hudson: Therefore, quite besides the cultural/conceptual features (which they may share with larger regions or gyres) each country has a unique economic structure, and needs a unique solution if it wants to emerge into reasonable prosperity. But

Re: Sala-i-Martin (was Re: Relative Wretchedness

2002-07-25 Thread Harry Pollard
Keith, As exertion is one of the basic Factors of production, one might expect the Classicals to use it in their measure of well-being - and they do. If for the same exertion, one can get a greater return, one is better-off. If less returns, one is worse off. That's all. Harry

RE: Relative Wretchedness

2002-07-24 Thread Karen Watters Cole
Ed, I like your suggested revision of the have vs have not semantics, especially since the old language implies ownership and perhaps one-upsmanship but does not adequately describe the uneven state of infrastructures, health systems and their underlying environmental foundations in many

Re: Relative Wretchedness

2002-07-24 Thread Ray Evans Harrell
Ed, There may be something here if youremember that the US and Canada have been the filters for the "Wretched Refuse" of the world over the last 150 years or so. Perhaps we should demand that Canada once more throw open its border to the poor of the world and lower all immigration quotas

Re: Relative Wretchedness

2002-07-24 Thread Ed Weick
:44 PM Subject: RE: Relative Wretchedness Ed, I like your suggested revision of the have vs have not semantics, especially since the old language implies ownership and perhaps one-upsmanship but does not adequately describe the uneven state of infrastructures, health systems

Re: Relative Wretchedness

2002-07-24 Thread Ed Weick
- Original Message - From: Ray Evans Harrell To: Ed Weick ; [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: Keith Hudson Sent: Wednesday, July 24, 2002 2:45 PM Subject: Re: Relative Wretchedness Ed, There may be something here if youremember that the US and Canada have