Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-25 Thread gene glick
John Griessen wrote: Bob Paddock wrote: Not sure. I know our CM loves that I put fuducials on the QFN So these footprint fiducials are outboard of the part so they show in a vision system as the part is being placed? Do you put silk outline outside them or some silk circles around each

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-25 Thread John Luciani
Fiducials and Keepouts -- The last mfg I dealt with recommended that the fiducial be a copper circle with a diameter between 0.5mm and 3.5mm and that the solder mask diameter be three times larger than the copper. I made a single 1mm pad footprint with the 3mm clearance. IIRC the

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread David SMITH
On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 10:01:55PM -0500, gene glick wrote: what else? Any suggestions? Check your hole dimensions, especially on connectors - a correctly-routed board is not much use if your connector pins won't fit through the holes... -- David SmithWork Email: dave.sm...@st.com

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Kai-Martin Knaak
On Tue, 23 Feb 2010 22:18:02 -0500, gene glick wrote: I'll have to order up a bunch of parts to make it happen but that's ok. This is an important part of the check. It is too easy to misread some aspect of the physical dimensions in the data sheet. Think SO16 vs SO16- wide. This has hit me

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Bob Paddock
On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 10:01 PM, gene glick carzr...@optonline.net wrote: After a very long time, I am just about ready to send out 3 different boards for fab.  I would appreciate any advice to improve my chances of success. I'm making the assumption you will have a contractor build quantities

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Larry Doolittle
Hi - On Wed, Feb 24, 2010 at 02:40:50PM -0500, Bob Paddock wrote: I'm making the assumption you will have a contractor build quantities someday, in automated equipment. These will (at least should) lower production costs: Although OT, I appreciate and try to learn from discussions like this.

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Bob Paddock
On Wed, Feb 24, 2010 at 3:24 PM, Larry Doolittle ldool...@recycle.lbl.gov wrote: Hi - On Wed, Feb 24, 2010 at 02:40:50PM -0500, Bob Paddock wrote: I'm making the assumption you will have a contractor build quantities someday, in automated equipment.  These will (at least should) lower

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Ben Jackson
On Wed, Feb 24, 2010 at 04:07:13PM -0500, Bob Paddock wrote: I've learned most of this by working at a large CM, and 'The Hard Way' of doing it wrong. For example the job today is 5,000 boards. When you get into quantities, you start to do things differently. See the note at the bottom

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Steven Michalske
On Feb 24, 2010, at 1:07 PM, Bob Paddock wrote: On Wed, Feb 24, 2010 at 3:24 PM, Larry Doolittle ldool...@recycle.lbl.gov wrote: Hi - On Wed, Feb 24, 2010 at 02:40:50PM -0500, Bob Paddock wrote: I'm making the assumption you will have a contractor build quantities someday, in automated

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread John Griessen
Bob Paddock wrote: On Wed, Feb 24, 2010 at 3:24 PM, Larry Doolittle ldool...@recycle.lbl.gov wrote: Have you put Fudicuals on components, such as tiny QFN packages, or even massive TQFP and BGAs. I don't think you said what you wanted to say. Not sure. I know our CM loves that I put

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread DJ Delorie
I would have just ensured that my AVR image didn't contain any sequences that trigger the problem. It might be possible to just modify AVRdude to detect such sequences and modify the programming sequence to avoid them. Sort of like bit stuffing with NRZI. I'm sorry, you cannot program an

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Bob Paddock
I would have just ensured that my AVR image didn't contain any sequences that trigger the problem. How? Its a crap shoot as to know if any particular image will generate the bad sequence. Then you waste time trying to figure out how to get around it. To DJ's comment. We usually do go with

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Ben Jackson
On Wed, Feb 24, 2010 at 04:41:35PM -0500, Bob Paddock wrote: I would have just ensured that my AVR image didn't contain any sequences that trigger the problem. How? Its a crap shoot as to know if any particular image will generate the bad sequence. Then you waste time trying to figure

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Ouabache Designworks
On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 10:01 PM, gene glick [1]carzr...@optonline.net wrote: After a very long time, I am just about ready to send out 3 different boards for fab. ?I would appreciate any advice to improve my chances of success. Don't send all three at once.

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Frank Bergmann
On Wed, 24 Feb 2010 15:22:54 -0600, John Griessen wrote: So these footprint fiducials are outboard of the part so they show in a vision system as the part is being placed? Do you put silk outline outside them or some silk circles around each one to clue the CM about what they are good for,

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Dan McMahill
gene glick wrote: After a very long time, I am just about ready to send out 3 different boards for fab. I would appreciate any advice to improve my chances of success. So far here's what has been done: 1. Run DRC on all PCBs with no issues.. 2. Checked schematics. 3. Checked schematic

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Geoff Swan
don't even consider ordering boards without loading up the photoplot files into something like gerbv and doing some sanity checks. This advice applies to a design done with any layout tool and not just pcb. A minimal list would be: - From 20,000 feet, does each layer look right or are there

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Steven Michalske
On Feb 24, 2010, at 1:41 PM, Bob Paddock wrote: To DJ's comment. We usually do go with pre-programmed parts eventually. Solder jumpers are a really bad idea when doing anything more than few boards. Even zero ohm resisters jumpers cost real money. I believe it was my comment that

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Bob Paddock
So these footprint fiducials are outboard of the part so they show in a vision system as the part is being placed?  Do you put silk outline outside them or some silk circles around each one to clue the CM about what they are good for, or does that just need some notes and documentation and

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Bob Paddock
On Wed, Feb 24, 2010 at 7:47 PM, Steven Michalske smichal...@gmail.com wrote: On Feb 24, 2010, at 1:41 PM, Bob Paddock wrote: To DJ's comment.  We usually do go with pre-programmed parts eventually.  Solder jumpers are a really bad  idea when doing anything more than few boards.  Even zero

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-24 Thread Steven Michalske
On Feb 24, 2010, at 4:59 PM, Bob Paddock wrote: On Wed, Feb 24, 2010 at 7:47 PM, Steven Michalske smichal...@gmail.com wrote: On Feb 24, 2010, at 1:41 PM, Bob Paddock wrote: To DJ's comment. We usually do go with pre-programmed parts eventually. Solder jumpers are a really bad idea

gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-23 Thread gene glick
After a very long time, I am just about ready to send out 3 different boards for fab. I would appreciate any advice to improve my chances of success. So far here's what has been done: 1. Run DRC on all PCBs with no issues.. 2. Checked schematics. 3. Checked schematic matches layout. 4. In

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-23 Thread DJ Delorie
Print out your surface copper layers and put the parts on the printout to make sure they match. ___ geda-user mailing list geda-user@moria.seul.org http://www.seul.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/geda-user

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-23 Thread gene glick
DJ Delorie wrote: Print out your surface copper layers and put the parts on the printout to make sure they match. that's a really good idea, thanks! It'll delay things some, but yeah, sounds like the conservative way to go. I'll have to order up a bunch of parts to make it happen but that's

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-23 Thread John Luciani
Check the gerbers and drill files using gerbv. I use a script that zips and renames all the files for the fab house. I take the zip file that is created, unzip it and check those files with gerbv. For a system of boards that plug into each I might panelize them so that they all

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-23 Thread gene glick
John Luciani wrote: Check the gerbers and drill files using gerbv. I use a script that zips and renames all the files for the fab house. I take the zip file that is created, unzip it and check those files with gerbv. For a system of boards that plug into each I might panelize them

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-23 Thread Mark Rages
On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 8:01 PM, gene glick carzr...@optonline.net wrote: After a very long time, I am just about ready to send out 3 different boards for fab.  I would appreciate any advice to improve my chances of success.  So far here's what has been done: 1. Run DRC on all PCBs with no

Re: gEDA-user: any last minute advice prior to sending out for PCB fab

2010-02-23 Thread Vanessa Ezekowitz
On Tue, 23 Feb 2010 22:18:02 -0500 gene glick carzr...@optonline.net wrote: DJ Delorie wrote: Print out your surface copper layers and put the parts on the printout to make sure they match. that's a really good idea, thanks! It'll delay things some, but yeah, sounds like the