Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-17 Thread Rodric Rabbah
> like a google.com for example. I meant gmail.com but slack rejects this and others like it (yahoo, hotmail ...). -r

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-17 Thread Rodric Rabbah
On Sun, Jun 16, 2019 at 7:13 PM Justin Mclean wrote: > > This is the link to signup to slack for this project > http://openwhisk.apache.org/slack.html > Yep I noted that in my email, but they would need to search for it. It > would be good if the slack login page linked to that. > I don't see

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-16 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, > This is the link to signup to slack for this project > http://openwhisk.apache.org/slack.html Yep I noted that in my email, but they would need to search for it. It would be good if the slack login page linked to that. Thanks, Justin

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-16 Thread Rodric Rabbah
This is the link to signup to slack for this project http://openwhisk.apache.org/slack.html -r > On Jun 16, 2019, at 6:38 PM, Justin Mclean wrote: > > Hi, > >> There's a bit of discussion that can happen (and sometimes does) on >> the issue trackers which provide a bit more interactive yet

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-16 Thread Rodric Rabbah
The link to slack contains the content I wrote in the issue. We digest the slack conversations every night and email them to the dev list so that I could have used a ponymail permalink instead. Anyone can self signup for slack there are no approvals or prohibitions on who can sign up. We

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-16 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, > There's a bit of discussion that can happen (and sometimes does) on > the issue trackers which provide a bit more interactive yet > asynchronous method of communication. The Slack activity is almost > comparable to general chit chat at ApacheCon hackathons or similar. That may be so but

Re: Re: Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-11 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, > Thanks. The draft at [1] is quite helpful. I've searched for something > like that multiple times over the last year and never found it. Is this > new or is my search karma not good ;) It was discussed at length on this list about 6 month ago (think), people from the legal committee

Re: Re: Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-10 Thread David P Grove
Justin Mclean wrote on 06/10/2019 06:08:34 PM: > > > 1. CI/CD. We have automation (Jenkins/TravisCI) that automatically > > publishes images to dockerhub from the master branch of many of our git > > repos. These images are all tagged with git commit hash style tags. The > > 'latest' tag is

Re: Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-10 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, > 1. CI/CD. We have automation (Jenkins/TravisCI) that automatically > publishes images to dockerhub from the master branch of many of our git > repos. These images are all tagged with git commit hash style tags. The > 'latest' tag is always an alias to the most recent of these CI/CD tags.

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-10 Thread Dave Fisher
Hi - The ASF expects that PMCs will watch out for their project and product brands. The VP, Brand and their committee are available to help with advice and also trademark registrations via the tradema...@apache.org mailing list. My only concern with the README.md files in some Github project

Re: Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-10 Thread David P Grove
Justin Mclean wrote on 06/09/2019 09:37:47 AM: > > Hopefully someone else can provide some insight with what going on > with docker. I can try :) The project's usage pattern has evolved during incubation. Here's what I think OpenWhisk is currently doing with dockerhub. 1. CI/CD. We have

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-10 Thread Matt Rutkowski
For my part (and OBO IBM), have gone out of my way to transfer worldwide trademarks (and domain names, including openwhisk,org) to the ASF working with our IP and legal teams and caused a complete product rename as we entered Incubation. There is no intentional use of OpenWhisk, any that

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-09 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, > I conclude that all are left over from before the project entered the Apache > Incubator and the period of transition that followed. I though that was the case bur was just checking. But beauty IBM need to be respectful of the trademark and the (P)PMC make sure they do that. > The

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-09 Thread Rodric Rabbah
Thanks for these links. I went through many of the links you provided and conducted my own search as well. I conclude that all are left over from before the project entered the Apache Incubator and the period of transition that followed. We addressed the use of IBM OpenWhisk and Bluemix OpenWhisk

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-09 Thread Rodric Rabbah
> I also note that you’ve been given feedback on several releases that have > had mirror issue, but the issues don’t seem to have been fixed. Is there a > plan to do so before graduation? e.g >

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-07 Thread justin
Hi, Some of the answer be be obvious here to someone who works on the project, and already been discussed and sorted on your mailing list. So apologies if that the case, I’m not involved with your project, so I’m just asking to get clarity. A google search turns up mention of “IBM OpenWhisk”

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-07 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, I also note that you’ve been given feedback on several releases that have had mirror issue, but the issues don’t seem to have been fixed. Is there a plan to do so before graduation? e.g [1] Thanks, Justin 1.

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-07 Thread Dave Fisher
I have a question below. Sent from my iPhone > On Jun 7, 2019, at 6:37 PM, Rodric Rabbah wrote: > > The PMC has individuals from 6 unrelated companies. I think committers add > another 2 unrelated companies/entities. We expect to welcome new committers > after graduation. > > -r > >> On

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-07 Thread Rodric Rabbah
The PMC has individuals from 6 unrelated companies. I think committers add another 2 unrelated companies/entities. We expect to welcome new committers after graduation. -r > On Jun 7, 2019, at 8:25 PM, Justin Mclean wrote: > > Hi, > >> I have looked at the contributor distributions as

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-07 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, > I have looked at the contributor distributions as follows: > > - 91 individuals with 1 commit. > - 24 individuals with 2 commits. > - 9 individuals with 3 commits. > - 16 individuals with 4 commits. > - 30 individuals with 5 or more commits (and fewer than 10). > - 22 individuals with 10

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-07 Thread Matt Sicker
There's a bit of discussion that can happen (and sometimes does) on the issue trackers which provide a bit more interactive yet asynchronous method of communication. The Slack activity is almost comparable to general chit chat at ApacheCon hackathons or similar. On Fri, 7 Jun 2019 at 11:36,

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-07 Thread Bertrand Delacretaz
Hi, On Fri, Jun 7, 2019 at 6:36 PM Rodric Rabbah wrote: > ...I don't have a diversity profile per employer. I can try to gather that. Do > you have a suggestion for the easiest way to do this? Maybe infra has some > tools?... Note that the ASF doesn't require people to disclose their company or

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-07 Thread Rodric Rabbah
Hi Justin, thanks for your email. I have looked at the contributor distributions as follows: - 91 individuals with 1 commit. - 24 individuals with 2 commits. - 9 individuals with 3 commits. - 16 individuals with 4 commits. - 30 individuals with 5 or more commits (and fewer than 10). - 22

Re: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-07 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, Congratulations. That’s pne of the most comprehensive maturity reports I’ve seen. I would be interested is seeing some details of: - Diversity of current committers in who they work for - Same for the proposed PMC (if that's been decided?) - There seems to be a heavy reliance on

FWD: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project

2019-06-04 Thread Rodric Rabbah
This email is to notify general@i.a.o that a graduation community [VOTE] is in progress for Apache OpenWhisk (incubating). -r -- Forwarded message - From: Rodric Rabbah Date: Tue, Jun 4, 2019 at 5:25 PM Subject: [VOTE] Apache OpenWhisk graduation to Top Level Project To: Hi