Re: Silly DNS question

2010-01-22 Thread Brian Chabot
Thomas Charron wrote: > On Fri, Jan 22, 2010 at 1:39 PM, Ben Scott wrote: >> That would generally be considered non-compliant with the >> requirements for Internet hosts, even though DNS can handle it. > Interesting. My nameserver at home ends up telling me to bugger > off. :-D Not sure

Re: MerriLUG or Manchester meets planned? + Twitter

2010-01-22 Thread Susan Cragin
I'd probably come. I live in Concord. ___ gnhlug-discuss mailing list gnhlug-discuss@mail.gnhlug.org http://mail.gnhlug.org/mailman/listinfo/gnhlug-discuss/

Re: MerriLUG or Manchester meets planned? + Twitter

2010-01-22 Thread Jon 'maddog' Hall
It is easier and faster for me to get to Manchester from Amherst over Rt 101 than it is to get to Nashua over Rt 101A, particularly around rush hour. md ___ gnhlug-discuss mailing list gnhlug-discuss@mail.gnhlug.org http://mail.gnhlug.org/mailman/listin

Re: Silly DNS question (underscore in hostname)

2010-01-22 Thread Joshua Judson Rosen
"Michael ODonnell" writes: > > > (I detest FUD, even if it's aimed at a target I also dislike.) > > (sigh) You're right. I could swear that just before I posted my comment I > had read (parts of) a rant (with examples) about how Microsoft disregards > the DNS hostname rules on the Internet, but

Re: Silly DNS question (underscore in hostname)

2010-01-22 Thread Michael ODonnell
> (I detest FUD, even if it's aimed at a target I also dislike.) (sigh) You're right. I could swear that just before I posted my comment I had read (parts of) a rant (with examples) about how Microsoft disregards the DNS hostname rules on the Internet, but maybe I was hallucinating - I now ca

Re: Silly DNS question

2010-01-22 Thread Ben Scott
On Fri, Jan 22, 2010 at 2:39 PM, Thomas Charron wrote: >  Interesting.  My nameserver at home ends up telling me to bugger > off.  :-D  Not sure which one, either our DNS forwarder, or the TDS > nameservers.  Will have to take a look. Some DNS software definitely has the option to fail queries

Re: MerriLUG or Manchester meets planned? + Twitter

2010-01-22 Thread Cole Tuininga
Chip Marshall wrote: > So, with that out there, are there people interested in a > Manchester meeting who wouldn't be interested in reviving the > Nashua group? I'd certainly be interested. I work in Manchester, but live up near the lakes region so going down to Nashua is the wrong direction for

Re: Silly DNS question

2010-01-22 Thread Thomas Charron
On Fri, Jan 22, 2010 at 1:39 PM, Ben Scott wrote: >  That would generally be considered non-compliant with the > requirements for Internet hosts, even though DNS can handle it.  Some > software attempts to enforce the former despite the later.  It's a > matter of opinion who is "right". Interes

Re: Silly DNS question (underscore in hostname)

2010-01-22 Thread Ben Scott
On Fri, Jan 22, 2010 at 12:15 PM, Michael ODonnell wrote: > ... and instances of blatant [cough]Microsoft[cough] disregard ... Not sure what you're after there. Windows allows underscores in the hostname. Linux also allows underscores in the hostname. There is no rule that says your hostna

Re: Silly DNS question

2010-01-22 Thread Ben Scott
On Fri, Jan 22, 2010 at 11:50 AM, Thomas Charron wrote: >  Is an _ allowed in a DNS name? As usual, the real world is complicated. DNS != Internet The protocol part of DNS can handle an underscore just fine. Labels can include any character except a dot (.) or ASCII NUL. Underscores a

Re: Silly DNS question

2010-01-22 Thread Joshua Judson Rosen
Thomas Charron writes: > > Is an _ allowed in a DNS name? DNS-SD, DKIM, ADSP, and a whole bunch of other parts of the greater internet infrastructure think so--actually, they depend on it. But "allowed" is a long way away from "in general good taste". I take "_" in domains as being sort-of li

Re: Silly DNS question (underscore in hostname)

2010-01-22 Thread Michael ODonnell
After refreshing my memory here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hostname ...which references (what appear to be) the relevant RFCs, I recall that underscores are definitely not legal, but the corner cases (and instances of blatant [cough]Microsoft[cough] disregard) are interesting... ___

Re: Silly DNS question

2010-01-22 Thread Ted Roche
On 01/22/2010 11:50 AM, Thomas Charron wrote: Is an _ allowed in a DNS name? I didn't think so, and my home DNS proxy doesn't think so, but other networks seem fine with it. http://www.thingiverse.com/image:8662 Above is an example, where the image is stored by amazon at http://thingi

Re: Silly DNS question

2010-01-22 Thread Star
On Fri, Jan 22, 2010 at 11:50 AM, Thomas Charron wrote: >  Is an _ allowed in a DNS name? > >  I didn't think so, and my home DNS proxy doesn't think so, but other > networks seem fine with it. > > http://www.thingiverse.com/image:8662 > >  Above is an example, where the image is stored by amazon

Silly DNS question

2010-01-22 Thread Thomas Charron
Is an _ allowed in a DNS name? I didn't think so, and my home DNS proxy doesn't think so, but other networks seem fine with it. http://www.thingiverse.com/image:8662 Above is an example, where the image is stored by amazon at http://thingiverse_beta.s3.amazonaws.com/renders/fe/2a/15/49/75/