Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-02-02 Thread Fred
On Sun, 2005-01-30 at 14:12 -0500, Jeff Kinz wrote: > On Sun, Jan 30, 2005 at 01:32:49PM -0500, John Abreau wrote: > > On Sat, 2005-01-29 at 08:48, Jerry Feldman wrote: > > > religiously, JABR does not like SuSE, and > > > > have always installed easily on the same machines that SuSE faile

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-30 Thread Jeff Kinz
On Sun, Jan 30, 2005 at 01:32:49PM -0500, John Abreau wrote: > On Sat, 2005-01-29 at 08:48, Jerry Feldman wrote: > > religiously, JABR does not like SuSE, and > > have always installed easily on the same machines that SuSE failed to > install on. Ah, well then, that explains it. You've

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-30 Thread John Abreau
On Sat, 2005-01-29 at 08:48, Jerry Feldman wrote: > religiously, JABR does not like SuSE, and > since he was doing the work... No, it's not a religious issue. I've tried SuSE a number of times, and I've never gotten it to install successfully. Redhat and Fedora have always installed easily on t

Vendors and responsibility (was: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux)

2005-01-29 Thread Benjamin Scott
A reoccuring theme in this and many other forums is that the level of support one gets with a computer really sucks. As I said before, more and more companies (Dell, HP/Compaq, and Gateway for sure) are offering two product lines. One is called the "consumer" product line. They call it th

PC vendor experiences (was: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux)

2005-01-29 Thread Benjamin Scott
Since everyone is voicing their opinions and experiences with vendors, here are some of mine: I work for a systems integration and support company, so in most cases, I *am* technical support for the end-user. While I can do all the work myself, it's far cheaper for me to be able to pick up

Vendor special partitions (was: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux)

2005-01-29 Thread Benjamin Scott
There are two types of "special partitions" one usually sees these days: One is the "system utility" partition, which contains things like BIOS setup, diagnostics, and such. Compaq is famous for using such a partition *instead* of firmware-based utilities, meaning if your hard disk or RAID a

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-29 Thread Jason Stephenson
Jon maddog Hall wrote: It is not just that they want to "save the cost of the CD", but some companies are ordering systems without CD drives because they want a thin client on the desktop...something without floppies and/or a CD...something that could boot over the network and be diskless or be (re

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-29 Thread Bill Sconce
On Sat, 29 Jan 2005 14:50:50 -0500 Jon maddog Hall <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > It is the old story that to throw a pre-pressed CD into a "consumer grade" > computer would probably cost less than $.05. But they are going to make > 100,000 of those "consumer grade" systems, so it is really a cost

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-29 Thread Jon maddog Hall
[EMAIL PROTECTED] said: > but no method of recovering them unless you paid $25 or $50 just seems wrong. (sigh) It is the old story that to throw a pre-pressed CD into a "consumer grade" computer would probably cost less than $.05. But they are going to make 100,000 of those "consumer grade" sys

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-29 Thread Dan Jenkins
Jon maddog Hall wrote: Jason (et. al.), reinstall or repair the OS. The reason for this is that they do not have to provide you with an installation CD. .. Personally, I'd rather have the install media on a bootable DVD and have the full use of my disk, thanks. It is not just

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-29 Thread Dan Jenkins
Jerry Feldman wrote: BTW: most people I know who have IBM thinkpads like them. Additionally, both IBM and HP have very strong Linux programs. I've bought about fifty IBM ThinkPads in the two years. Excellent pieces of equipment in my mind. A number of them are running Linux. No problems at al

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-29 Thread Jerry Feldman
On Sat, 29 Jan 2005 13:47:31 -0500 Dan Jenkins <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I'm also not surprised over the Presario response to Linux. I got a > similar response when a school was donated one and we needed to install > Windows NT on it (the application required it), instead of the XP Home > it

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-29 Thread Jerry Feldman
On Sat, 29 Jan 2005 13:56:58 -0500 Jon maddog Hall <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > It is not just that they want to "save the cost of the CD", but some companies > are ordering systems without CD drives because they want a thin client on the > desktop...something without floppies and/or a CD...someth

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-29 Thread Jon maddog Hall
Jason (et. al.), > reinstall or repair the OS. The reason for this is that they do not have > to provide you with an installation CD. .. >Personally, I'd rather have the install media on a bootable DVD >and have the full use of my disk, thanks. It is not just that they want to "save the c

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-29 Thread Dan Jenkins
Jason Stephenson wrote: Jerry Feldman wrote: In general, I would probably buy a Dell or HP/Compaq depending on the price and features, although I might also buy a system with Linux preinstalled. I don't think Dell does the above, at least not on the Optiplex and PowerEdge lines. I was recently pl

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-29 Thread Jason Stephenson
Jerry Feldman wrote: Most PC vendors today place a hidden partition from which you can reinstall or repair the OS. The reason for this is that they do not have to provide you with an installation CD. Right. I'm aware of that. It's another reason why I don't buy named brand PCs. They advertise an

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-29 Thread Jason Stephenson
Travis Roy wrote: I'll second this. In fact, every Compaq that I've ever seen does this. It's usually the last partition on the disk, is roughly 32MB in size and generally of a type not recognized by Linux fdisk or fips. It was actually the first partition and it was 5 GIGS in size. Guess it var

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-29 Thread Jerry Feldman
On Sat, 29 Jan 2005 01:30:55 -0500 Jason Stephenson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I'll second this. In fact, every Compaq that I've ever seen does this. > It's usually the last partition on the disk, is roughly 32MB in size and > generally of a type not recognized by Linux fdisk or fips. I have 2

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-29 Thread Christopher Schmidt
On Sat, Jan 29, 2005 at 12:07:38AM -0500, Benjamin Scott wrote: > On Fri, 28 Jan 2005, at 9:23pm, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote > > Of course, most Linux users probably don't have use for most of those > > intangibles anyway ... > > It depends. Generally speaking, companies care more if you pay more.

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-29 Thread Travis Roy
> I'll second this. In fact, every Compaq that I've ever seen does > this. It's usually the last partition on the disk, is roughly 32MB > in size and generally of a type not recognized by Linux fdisk or fips. It was actually the first partition and it was 5 GIGS in size. > If you do manage to

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-28 Thread Jason Stephenson
Benjamin Scott wrote: Keep in mind that many Compaq's keep the "BIOS setup" program on disk, where just about everything else keeps it in firmware. That means that if you blow away the utility partition, you can no longer do anything useful to configure the BIOS. I'll second this. In fact, every

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-28 Thread Benjamin Scott
On Fri, 28 Jan 2005, at 9:23pm, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > From the consumer standpoint, I can attest to this: my boss was recently > buying a new laptop, and had the choice in front of him to choose two > mostly identical laptops. When he asked the difference, this was basically > their answer: "O

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-28 Thread Christopher Schmidt
On Fri, Jan 28, 2005 at 08:36:29PM -0500, Benjamin Scott wrote: > On Fri, 28 Jan 2005, at 7:55am, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > > AFAIK, the DeskPro line was killed several years ago. > > FWIW, Dell and Gateway do this, too, to different extends, and I imagine > other vendors do, too. With Dell, y

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-28 Thread Benjamin Scott
On Fri, 28 Jan 2005, at 7:55am, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > AFAIK, the DeskPro line was killed several years ago. Well, the DeskPro *brand* was retired, but I'm pretty sure the part of HP that was Compaq still offers a line of "business class" desktop computers, or whatever you want to call them.

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-28 Thread Jerry Feldman
On Thu, 27 Jan 2005 21:06:47 -0500 (EST) Benjamin Scott <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > They don't care. Indeed, they want it that way. Presario PCs are > as-cheap-as-possible junk desktops. Their sole purpose is to keep money > from going to the Dells and Gateways of the world. They don't want

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-27 Thread Benjamin Scott
On Thu, 27 Jan 2005, at 11:43am, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > Well, IIRC there's that loadlinux.exe (or whatever > it's called) LOADLIN.EXE (FYI) > ... that boots Linux directly from Windows. To the best of my knowledge, it can only boot Linux from DOS. It needs the system in real mode (circa

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-27 Thread Benjamin Scott
On Thu, 27 Jan 2005, at 11:19am, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > I've encountered similar things before. In my cases, I found it was a boot > partition, not the BIOS, which was enforcing the "repair." I just deleted > the small boot partition, and rewrote the boot sector, and the problem > went away. YM

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-27 Thread Benjamin Scott
On Thu, 27 Jan 2005, at 11:15am, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: >> Just tell a friend and don't buy anymore. It's all you can do. :-) > >I disagree. True, word of mouth is great, but a pointed letter to > HP/Compaq would definitely be in order. They don't care. Indeed, they want it that way.

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-27 Thread Bill Sconce
On Thu, 27 Jan 2005 10:35:35 -0500 Travis Roy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Here was the response I got from HP/Compaq about the issue: > Dear Travs, > > Thank you for contacting HP Total Care. > > I see that you installed Linux in Presario and partition forces to > re-install. > > This is beca

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-27 Thread Michael ODonnell
> So I repartition the drive, reboot and it detected a "partition > corruption" and it -FORCED- me, from the BIOS to re-install WinXP > home from the rescue partition. (sigh) A middle-finger once again lifted in Linux's general direction. This sort of dainbramage is still too common... Well,

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-27 Thread Dan Jenkins
On Thursday 27 January 2005 10:35 am, Travis Roy wrote: I see that you installed Linux in Presario and partition forces to re-install. This is because that the Presario product line was developed for home users utilizing Windows 95, 98, Me, 2000, and Windows XP Home operating systems. Linux is prim

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-27 Thread Randy Edwards
> Just tell a friend and don't buy anymore. It's all you can do. :-) I disagree. True, word of mouth is great, but a pointed letter to HP/Compaq would definitely be in order. Regards, . Randy -- "This [the Bush regime] is the worst government the US has ever had in its more than 200

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-27 Thread Neil Joseph Schelly
On Thursday 27 January 2005 10:35 am, Travis Roy wrote: > I see that you installed Linux in Presario and partition forces to > re-install. > > This is because that the Presario product line was developed for home > users utilizing Windows 95, 98, Me, 2000, and Windows XP Home operating > systems. >

Re: HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-27 Thread Charles Farinella
On Thu, 2005-01-27 at 10:35, Travis Roy wrote: > Here was the response I got from HP/Compaq about the issue: Don't feel bad, I got very much the same response from them when I put Win2k on one of their computers that had been 'designed' to run Win98. Just tell a friend and don't buy anymore. It

HP/Compaq Presario and Linux

2005-01-27 Thread Travis Roy
My workplace got a workstation machine for our Manchester datacenter. Just a computer for people that come to work in the facility to use if they don't have a laptop or for testing and whatnot. Anyway, I decided to dual boot the box with WinXP/Linux. After trying 3 different distributions of Linux