Re: Repositories: Institutional or Central?

2009-02-10 Thread Stevan Harnad
On Mon, Feb 9, 2009 at 3:56 PM, Tomasz Neugebauer (Digital Projects Systems Development Librarian, Concordia University) wrote: A granting agency can make open access to the results of the research a condition of funding, but a university mandate that makes the university IR

Re: Repositories: Institutional or Central ? emergent properties and the compulsory open society

2009-02-10 Thread Heather Morrison
On 6-Feb-09, at 10:38 AM, Tomasz Neugebauer wrote: [snip] When a researcher makes the decision to publish/provide access to their work, the emergent properties of the repository are a relevant consideration. Consider the following hypothetical situation: a researcher in Buddhist studies may,

Re: Repositories: Institutional or Central?

2009-02-10 Thread Alma Swan
On 10/02/2009 15:46, Stevan Harnad amscifo...@gmail.com wrote: Tomasz, now that you have voiced your own opinion, it would be a good idea for you to read the background literature on this topic. There you will find the large, multidisciplinary and multinational author

Re: [SOAF] Please Don't Conflate Direct with Harvested CRs (Central Repositories), Or Deposit Locus With Search Locus

2009-02-10 Thread Stevan Harnad
 if a central depository is correlated with a political entity, particularly a national government, then it may be in a position to secure a national mandate in one single move. Indeed. And France's HAL has been correlated with a political entity: the French government.

Re: [SOAF] Please Don't Conflate Direct with Harvested CRs (Central Repositories), Or Deposit Locus With Search Locus

2009-02-10 Thread Jean-Claude Gu�don
[ The following text is in the utf-8 character set. ] [ Your display is set for the iso-8859-1 character set. ] [ Some characters may be displayed incorrectly. ] Consider the logic of Stevan's argument. I gave an example of one central, multi-disciplinary repository, HAL, because

Re: Repositories: Institutional or Central?

2009-02-10 Thread Tomasz Neugebauer
  On Mon, Feb 9, 2009 at 3:56 PM, Tomasz Neugebauer wrote:   A granting agency can make open access to the results of the research a condition of funding, but a university mandate that makes the university IR the compulsory locus of deposit... is not a good idea.