I'm not insulting anyone. These are facts.
I don't agree. Of course if you modify certain scheme files and remove the
parts that concern hel-arabic,
it may not work. I challenge you,my initial version which did not depend
at all on Lilypond worked very well without modifying anything.
Initial
Good morning
Before offering hel-arabic.ly, I tested it for 4 years,
it worked with all versions of lilypond. I have the impression that individuals
have sabotaged my work or they are going to sabotage it in the latest version
of lilypond 2.25.13,
I know that lilypond depends on volunteers, of
Hello
Initially hel-arabic.ly is autonomous,
I see that you deleted in define-note-names.scm
;; Language: Arabic ;
;; Hassan El fatihi ,
;;
;; bb = flat (bemol)
;; bb = double-flat
;; db = quarter-tone flat
I installed lilypond-2.23.6-1 ,lilypond-2.24.3 and lilypond-2.25.13:
for each version I do : LilyPond rast.ly
for the unstable version it's normal hel-arabic has been truncated.
I would like to point out that my initial version of hel-arabic.ly that I am
using is functional.
I tested them
hello again
I did some tests on version 2.24.3, 2.21.0-1 , 2.23.6-1
it doesn't work either.
hassan
for rast.ly
\include "hel-arabic.ly"
\version "2.25.13"
\relative {
\key c \rast
c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
}
Tmust give rast.pdf , But that's not the case
rast.pdf
Description: Adobe PDF document
lilypond rast.ly =>
GNU LilyPond 2.25.13 (running Guile 3.0)
Traitement de « rast.ly »
Analyse...
rast.ly:5:8: Erreur : « edb » n'est pas un nom de note
c' d
edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
rast.ly:5:20: Erreur : « bdb » n'est pas un nom de note
c' d edb f | g a
I have this :
lilypond rast.ly
=>
GNU LilyPond 2.25.13 (running Guile 3.0)
Traitement de « rast.ly »
Analyse...
rast.ly:1:10: Erreur : fichier non trouvé : « hel_arabic.ly »
(chemin de recherche : «
hello again
\include "hel_arabic_initial.ly"
\relative {
\key c \rast
c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
}
This should ensure full backward compatibility if you process your old
files with `convert-ly`.
Which file?
This file: \include "hel_arabic.ly" \relative { \key c \rast
Hello again
In fact it no longer works, I gave the operational version of hel-arabic.ly and
by trying
to make hel-arabic.ly dependent on arabic.ly without consulting me,
you screwed up the hel-arabic.ly file. I can still repair the damage
if you give me the opportunity to do that.Indeed edb
Hi
I am the author of hel-arabic.ly
Initially this file is sufficient in itself to write all Arabic music.
I note with regret and bitterness that hel-arabic.ly was truncated.
for example the makam rast, an important maqam of Arabic music, was removed
hel-arabic.ly does not depend in any way
Hello
I just answered the questions
I have no problem with including arabic.ly in hel-arabic.ly.
For me the subject can be closed
Best regard
Hassan EL FATIHI
Hello
Answers to questions
Question : while hel-arabic.ly has this line that
includes arabic.ly , what are they getting out of this? Some more
key signatures and keyAlterationOrder?
answer: normally hel-arabic.ly doesn't need arabic.ly (if not modified, as
recently proposed)
Question:
Hello
I am okay
Thank you for your sense of dialogue
Hassan EL FATIHI
Hello
Al the proposed changes are not justified.
Until now hel-arabic is a standalone file.
except élimination of 7/2 and 5/2 The other modifications are useless
The other modifications are useless, they simply make hel-arabic dependent on
arabic.ly.
But hel-arabic.ly is supposed to be
Hello
5/2 and 7/2 are not being used, You can delete them.
Removing nakriz, farahfaza, nawaatar, kurd, is not a good idea
The file hel-arabic.ly is complete and self-sufficient
best regard
Hassan EL FATIHI
Hello
First of all, I don't have a problem with English, it's just not my childhood
language.
I didn't say keep 5/2 and 7/2 alterations.
5/2 and 7/2 are practically not used in Arabic music.
Before the changes you suggest, the hel-arabic.ly file was complete, and it
doesn't need another
file to
Hello
I believe you are changing everything ,if I understood correctly.
it was necessary to delete 7/2 and 5/2 and we are tempted to compare arablic.ly
and hel-arabic.ly which aren't the same.
I absolutely do not agree all your modifications but do what you want.
To say for example that nahawand
Hello
You are right in practice 7/2 tone is not used. You can delete.
I personally don't use it.
Here are the files I modified in 2017 : lily-library.scm and
define-note-names.scm
The hel-arabic.ly file must be modified =>
You must remove:
(5/2 .
Hello
Don't remove 7/2 , and don't replace it with 7/4,
It is nonsense
why you want to delete 7/2 , I don't understand
Best regard
Hassan EL FATIHI
Hello
I am hassan EL FATIHI author of hel-arabic.ly,
if you have questions or changes to propose I am at your disposal.
I have been practicing Arabic music for more than thirty years,
in addition I am a computer scientist which pushed me to program hel-arabic.ly
Best regard
Hello James,
Here's the equivalent of the example with do, re , misb , etc.
@lilypond[quote,verbatim]
\include "hel-arabic.ly"
\score {
\relative {
\set Staff.extraNatural = ##f
\set Staff.autoBeaming = ##f
\key d \bayati
\time 10/8
d'4 d'8 d16 [edb d c] bdb [a bdb c] d4 r8
d16
Hello everyone
About hel-arabic.ly
It seems to me that the example given is incomplete
You must write
\include "hel-arabic.ly"
\relative {
\key c \rast
c' d edb f | g a bdb c | c bb a g | f d c
}
Best regards
hassan el fatihi
___
Hello James
What are the questions posed by Malt.
I want to answer it.
Best regards
Hassan
___
lilypond-devel mailing list
lilypond-devel@gnu.org
https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-devel
Hello
I am hassan el fatihi author of hel-arabic.ly.
I corrected some minimal errors.
20 makams are working properly. I can give you examples if you wish.
I use the hel-arabic.ly file since 2009.
Makam sajkar is from the rast family, with slight modifications
The makam irak notes can be
Hello James
Exploring the modes of the file hel-arabic.ly, I found a small mistake.
At line 69, you must delete this line% (6., SEMI-FLAT) or relocate % by;
It's a misplaced comment
Before :
%% Souznak: c' d' edb' f'
Hello everybody
I installed lilypond-git and I made changes to the files
Lily-library.scm and define-note-names.scm. In addition I have added a file
Hel_arabic_makam.ly an altenative to arabic.ly.
I tested these files and it works very well.
I would like to know how to make changes
To those
27 matches
Mail list logo
