Re: Horizontal spacing algorithm

2019-08-26 Thread Simon Albrecht
On 26.08.19 09:56, Michael Gerdau wrote: Find attached my tests with the current (2 weeks old) git version. IMO the current version of Lilypond does not have most (if at all!) of the mentioned shortcomings, at least not at first glance. LOL ;-) Best, Simon

Re: Horizontal spacing algorithm

2019-08-26 Thread Andrew Bernard
Looks good to me in 2.19.83 [current highest dev release not from git.] Andrew On 26/8/19 5:56 pm, Michael Gerdau wrote: Find attached my tests with the current (2 weeks old) git version. IMO the current version of Lilypond does not have most (if at all!) of the mentioned shortcomings, at

Re: Horizontal spacing algorithm

2019-08-26 Thread Malte Meyn
Am 26.08.19 um 09:56 schrieb Michael Gerdau: Anyway, have you actualliy tried the provided spacing examples given in the (old?) article with a current version of lilypond? Find attached my tests with the current (2 weeks old) git version. For those who don’t want to compile from git

Re: Horizontal spacing algorithm

2019-08-26 Thread Michael Gerdau
Hi Chad, FWIW I also had assumed you claimed such a change would be simple. Anyway, have you actualliy tried the provided spacing examples given in the (old?) article with a current version of lilypond? Find attached my tests with the current (2 weeks old) git version. IMO the current version

Re: Horizontal spacing algorithm

2019-08-25 Thread Chad Linsley
ery > many other factors influencing spacing. > > Best, Simon > > On 25.08.19 22:46, Chad Linsley wrote: > > Dear all, > > > > Would anyone be interested in implementing this (simple?) improvement > > to Lilypond’s horizontal spacing algorithm? The math is a

Re: Horizontal spacing algorithm

2019-08-25 Thread Simon Albrecht
this (simple?) improvement to Lilypond’s horizontal spacing algorithm? The math is all here: https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/p/pod/dod-idx/improved-algorithm-for-spacing-a-line-of-music.pdf?c=icmc;idno=bbp2372.2002.097;format=pdf I wish I had the programming chops! C

Horizontal spacing algorithm

2019-08-25 Thread Chad Linsley
Dear all, Would anyone be interested in implementing this (simple?) improvement to Lilypond’s horizontal spacing algorithm? The math is all here: https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/p/pod/dod-idx/improved-algorithm-for-spacing-a-line-of-music.pdf?c=icmc;idno=bbp2372.2002.097;format=pdf I wish I had