raid5 write performance

2005-11-18 Thread Jure Pečar
Hi all, Currently zfs is a major news in the storage area. It is very interesting to read various details about it on varios blogs of Sun employees. Among the more interesting I found was this: http://blogs.sun.com/roller/page/bonwick?entry=raid_z The point the guy makes is that it is

Re: raid5 write performance

2005-11-18 Thread Dan Stromberg
Would it really be that much slower to have a journal of RAID 5 writes? On Fri, 2005-11-18 at 15:05 +0100, Jure Pečar wrote: Hi all, Currently zfs is a major news in the storage area. It is very interesting to read various details about it on varios blogs of Sun employees. Among the more

Re: raid5 write performance

2005-11-18 Thread Mike Hardy
Moreover, and I'm sure Neil will chime in here, isn't the clean/unclean thing designed to prevent this exact scenario? The array is marked unclean immediately prior to write, then the write and parity write happens, then the array is marked clean. If you crash during the write but before parity

mdadm 2.1: command line option parsing bug?

2005-11-18 Thread Andreas Haumer
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Hi! I just upgraded to mdadm-2.1 from mdadm-1.12.0 and noticed that the following command (which is even mentioned in the manual page) doesn't work anymore: [EMAIL PROTECTED]:~ {838} $ mdadm -Ebsc partitions mdadm: cannot open partitions: No such

RE: raid5 write performance

2005-11-18 Thread Guy
-Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:linux-raid- [EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Mike Hardy Sent: Friday, November 18, 2005 2:24 PM To: Dan Stromberg Cc: Jure Pečar; linux-raid@vger.kernel.org Subject: Re: raid5 write performance Moreover, and I'm sure Neil will

Re: raid5 write performance

2005-11-18 Thread Mike Hardy
Guy wrote: It is not just a parity issue. If you have a 4 disk RAID 5, you can't be sure which if any have written the stripe. Maybe the parity was updated, but nothing else. Maybe the parity and 2 data disks, leaving 1 data disk with old data. Beyond that, md does write caching. I

Re: raid5 write performance

2005-11-18 Thread Neil Brown
On Friday November 18, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: So, I continue to believe silent corruption is mythical. I'm still open to good explanation it's not though. Silent corruption is not mythical, though it is probably talked about more than it actually happens (but then as it is silent, I

RE: raid5 write performance

2005-11-18 Thread Guy
-Original Message- From: Mike Hardy [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Friday, November 18, 2005 11:57 PM To: Guy Cc: 'Dan Stromberg'; 'Jure Pečar'; linux-raid@vger.kernel.org Subject: Re: raid5 write performance Guy wrote: It is not just a parity issue. If you have a 4