[LUTE] Re: Pistoys prone to rot (and string structure) according to Mace?

2012-11-29 Thread Anthony Hind
Dear Jaroslaw Thank you again for raising the discussion. I quite understand and am very happy that you are busy, a very good thing for a musician. It happens that I have to travel for the next few weeks (unfortunately, not on tour as for yourself), so it would be best for

[LUTE] Re: Pistoys prone to rot (and string structure) according to Mace?

2012-11-28 Thread Anthony Hind
Dear Jaroslaw    Unfortunately I don't have time just now to reply in any detail about all these interesting questions you raise, but I will nevertheless do so, as soon as I have enough time to do your analysis justice. Just on this issue of the meaning of rottenness. I find that Martyn did have

[LUTE] Re: Pistoys prone to rot (and string structure) according to Mace?

2012-11-28 Thread jaroslawlipski
Dear Anthony, As I said before, Martyn or Howard may be right, but if one reads the whole context it seems rather unlikely. Mace uses the word „decay” in places where he definitely means decomposition. The quote about an old oak in my previous message maybe a good example. You can’t expect

[LUTE] Re: Pistoys prone to rot (and string structure) according to Mace?

2012-11-28 Thread Shaun Ng
Please look at Samuel Johnson's dictionary published in 1755. It is available online and lists several meanings of 'decay'. There doesn't seem to be a direct reference to decomposition during this time. While this isn't the best source for understanding Mace, Johnson uses earlier sources to