Re: vihuela vs guitar

2004-09-25 Thread Jon Murphy
This isn't an answer to my question, I don't care which is older - that was just a guess. I believe we know that the provenance of the lute was as a melody instrument played with a quill plectrum. I don't know the provenance of the guitar tuning. The question was this, why the difference when they

FW: But (largely OT)

2004-09-25 Thread Ron Fletcher
Many thanks Howard, Hours of research on this one, I'm sure. I was impressed by the paragraph... In Gabrieli's Dulcis Jesu a couple of soloists sing the first four words of the text for rather a while before the choir enters dramatically on and. Trying to imagine a majestic choir in some

Re: vihuela vs guitar

2004-09-25 Thread Roman Turovsky
This isn't an answer to my question, I don't care which is older - that was just a guess. I believe we know that the provenance of the lute was as a melody instrument played with a quill plectrum. I don't know the provenance of the guitar tuning. There is no provenance. Again, it is contained

Re: vihuela vs guitar

2004-09-25 Thread Tony Chalkley
Deat Jon, snip I believe we know that the provenance of the lute was as a melody instrument played with a quill plectrum. I don't know the provenance of the guitar tuning. One of the reasons I have read (can't remember where) for the triumph of the violin family over the gambas is that the

Re: ARCHLUTE CONTEST

2004-09-25 Thread Roman Turovsky
What will it take for lutenists to take contemporary music for their instrument seriously, I wonder: It is a very difficult question. Most contemporary lute music is just plain silly. I make some exception for Alain's and Paulo's stuff, which is of limited modernity. And that is good thing

Re: ARCHLUTE CONTEST

2004-09-25 Thread Roman Turovsky
What will it take for lutenists to take contemporary music for their instrument seriously, I wonder: Should it come from the top - our virtuoso artists, like Ron McFarlane, or from the base? Should it come at all? Who will be our Segovia? Alain We have 3 world class virtuosos, Barto, Egüez

Re: ARCHLUTE CONTEST

2004-09-25 Thread Roman Turovsky
What will it take for lutenists to take contemporary music for their instrument seriously, I wonder: It is a very difficult question. Most contemporary lute music is just plain silly. I make some exception for Alain's and Paulo's stuff, which is of limited modernity. And that is good thing

Viola sine arculo = Vihuela ?

2004-09-25 Thread Daniel F Heiman
Since the May 2004 issue of Early Music has been brought up, I suggest all who have access to it take a look at the article on page 177, The Spanish plucked viola in Renaissance Italy, 1480 – 1530, by Hiroyuki Minamino. He has compiled a remarkable amount of iconographic evidence from all over

Re: Viola sine arculo = Vihuela ?

2004-09-25 Thread Alain Veylit
--- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.769 / Virus Database: 516 - Release Date: 9/24/2004 -- To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html