Re: VIRGIL: spelling: Virgil or Vergil?

1998-04-28 Thread Laura
Brescia, Italy 28.4.98 Here in Italy in high school education is prefered the Scholastic pronunciation (Cicero), in Univeristy it depends on the professor. I had 4 differents latin professor when I did University and three of them used the scholastic pronunciations, while the fourth loved and

Re: VIRGIL: spelling: Virgil or Vergil?

1998-04-25 Thread David Wilson-Okamura
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Sat, 25 Apr 1998 09:58:51 + As I understand it, 'Virgil' (or French 'Virgile', etc.) is the traditional spelling in modern languages. 'Vergil' is preferred by some (a minority) on the ground that in Latin the name is 'Vergilius', 'Vergilii', etc.. The 'Virgil'

Re: VIRGIL: spelling: Virgil or Vergil?

1998-04-25 Thread Nancy Charlton
At 09:22 a.m. 4/25/98 -0500, Alice Conrad O'Briain wrote: From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Simon Cauchi wrote I once knew a learned autodidact who habitually spoke of 'Kikero'. And Alice wrote: Either spelling is viable and the kikero pronunciation comes from the Roman adoption of the greek letter kappa

Re: VIRGIL: spelling: Virgil or Vergil?

1998-04-25 Thread Leofranc Holford-Strevens
In message [EMAIL PROTECTED], Simon Cauchi [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes As I understand it, 'Virgil' (or French 'Virgile', etc.) is the traditional spelling in modern languages. 'Vergil' (despite Heinze) is normal in modern German. 'Vergil' is preferred by some (a minority) on the ground that in

Re: VIRGIL: spelling: Virgil or Vergil?

1998-04-25 Thread Simon Cauchi
I wrote: I once knew a learned autodidact who habitually spoke of 'Kikero'. Alice Conrad-O'Briain responded: Either spelling is viable and the kikero pronunciation comes from the Roman adoption of the greek letter kappa so when reading classical latin witht he correct pronunctiation rather than

Re: VIRGIL: spelling: Virgil or Vergil?

1998-04-25 Thread Philip Thibodeau
Personally I spell Vergil 'Vergil' because I like the way the e looks on the page. Perhaps we could agree that this is a matter of aesthetics and save the disputation about tastes? There is a minor textual matter in the Georgics which bears an odd resemblance to this debate. At Geo. 1.25, the