[meteorite-list] Dr. Bunch's Latest on NWA 1839/3133

2006-10-15 Thread Adam Hupe
My last post on the subject, I just had a lengthy conversation with Dr. Bunch just as few minutes ago about the non-paired stones NWA 1839/3133. Some statements made by Dr. Bunch: He absolutely and unequivocally disagrees with David Weir's last post the List. He has access to the latest

Re: [meteorite-list] Dr. Bunch's Latest on NWA 1839/3133

2006-10-15 Thread David Weir
Adam Hupe wrote: My last post on the subject, I just had a lengthy conversation with Dr. Bunch just as few minutes ago about the non-paired stones NWA 1839/3133. Some statements made by Dr. Bunch: He absolutely and unequivocally disagrees with David Weir's last post the List. He has

RE: [meteorite-list] Dr. Bunch's Latest on NWA 1839/3133

2006-10-15 Thread stan .
Dr Bunch's exact quote The petrography, mineral chemistry and OXYGEN ISOTOPSE clearly indicate that NWA 1839 and NWA 3133 are NOT paired, period! bingo! *all caps mine* Adam,as i recall when we had discussed this matter previously you had said that further testing of 1839 - specifically