Re: [meteorite-list] Impact Question

2011-04-26 Thread John Hendry
gt;a long enough railgun, all possible in orbit somewhere, >why not? > >Unless my calculator is confused, that's a kinetic >energy very close to 4,183,999,999,994,176 joules, >or one megaton, stored in a 10 kg slug, a mass which >if it were plutonium (and standing still) could "only" &

Re: [meteorite-list] Impact Question

2011-04-25 Thread tracy latimer
~~snip~~ > We tend to think of nuclear reaction devices as the > ultimate weapons, of course, but imagine if you had > one of those railgun thingees and could speed up a > 10 kilogram steel slug to 920 kilometers per second. > OK, I know that's really fast, but in a vacuum with lots > of energy on

Re: [meteorite-list] Impact Question

2011-04-25 Thread Sterling K. Webb
standing still) could "only" produce an explosion of 0.2 megatons. Potent stuff, kinetic energy. Sterling K. Webb - Original Message - From: "John Hendry" To: "'meteorite list'" Cc: "Sterling K. W

Re: [meteorite-list] Impact Question

2011-04-25 Thread John Hendry
>closing ) >off. NITPICKING huh? >ENTROPY as part of your answer IS incorrect as he asked a SIMPLE question, >not a technical one. I could keep going, but >'Nuff said >-Barrett > > > >-Original Message- >From: Sterling K. Webb [mailto:sterling_k_w

Re: [meteorite-list] Impact Question

2011-04-25 Thread John Hendry
Sterling, On 24/04/2011 23:28, "Sterling K. Webb" wrote: >It takes a little over a joule to melt a gram of rock; that's >the kinetic energy of that gram traveling at the sedate >velocity of a mere 2100 m/s. A good-sized, high-speed >impactor would turn to plasma with close to 100% >efficiency.

Re: [meteorite-list] Impact Question

2011-04-25 Thread actionshooting
ff. NITPICKING huh? ENTROPY as part of your answer IS incorrect as he asked a SIMPLE question, not a technical one. I could keep going, but 'Nuff said -Barrett -Original Message- From: Sterling K. Webb [mailto:sterling_k_w...@sbcglobal.net] Sent: Monday, April 25, 2011 12:28

[meteorite-list] impact question--Barrett who?

2011-04-25 Thread jim_brady611
Well I for one have appreciated Sterlings humorous and thoughtful postings to the list for now on a decade and I have no idea who Barrett is but he seems to have quite a thin skin for starters.Is that the same person who gets in a wrinkle when the subject line doesn't change ;-) Try not to feel

Re: [meteorite-list] Impact Question

2011-04-25 Thread Barrett
LE question, not a technical one. I could keep going, but 'Nuff said -Barrett -Original Message- From: Sterling K. Webb [mailto:sterling_k_w...@sbcglobal.net] Sent: Monday, April 25, 2011 12:28 AM To: Barrett; 'Stuart McDaniel'; 'meteorite list' Subject: Re: [meteori

Re: [meteorite-list] Impact Question

2011-04-24 Thread Sterling K. Webb
r than the clever trick of nuclear reactions. Which is why I find it so strange that some geologists dismiss the life-extincting potential of major impacts. Me? I think we've been dam lucky. Sterling K. Webb ----------- - Original Message - From: "Ba

Re: [meteorite-list] Impact Question

2011-04-24 Thread Stuart McDaniel
A -Original Message- From: Barrett Sent: Sunday, April 24, 2011 10:20 PM To: 'Stuart McDaniel' ; 'meteorite list' Subject: RE: [meteorite-list] Impact Question A very LARGE impact such as the one you are talking about, the "fire" is super heated gases. The

Re: [meteorite-list] Impact Question

2011-04-24 Thread Barrett
:39 PM To: meteorite list Subject: [meteorite-list] Impact Question I am watching "Earth: The Making of a Planet" on Nat Geo right now and they are talking about Chixalub impact and I was wondering, probably something simple,but, If an asteroid the sixe of

[meteorite-list] Impact Question

2011-04-24 Thread Stuart McDaniel
I am watching "Earth: The Making of a Planet" on Nat Geo right now and they are talking about Chixalub impact and I was wondering, probably something simple,but, If an asteroid the sixe of Chixalub hits the Earth where does the "fire" from impact come from?? Is it