Re: Trimming the CPAN

2010-03-26 Thread Bill Ward
Also, see if the list of big files correlates to old versions when there are newer versions available -- one large distro with a huge archive of back versions could easily tip the scales. On Thu, Mar 25, 2010 at 11:47 PM, Gabor Szabo szab...@gmail.com wrote: Some people are more space conscious

Re: Trimming the CPAN - Automatic Purging

2010-03-26 Thread Graham Barr
On Mar 25, 2010, at 8:42 AM, Barbie wrote: Lastly I would also personnally be annoyed if only the latest versions were available, as I often make great use of the diff tool on search.cpan.org. Having only the latest version renders that great tool redundant :( I use that too :-) and it is

Trimming the CPAN - Automatic Purging

2010-03-26 Thread Tim Bunce
Currently on PAUSE you have to explicitly delete old uploads. How about changing it so you have to explicitly KEEP old uploads that appear to have been superseded? PAUSE already has a mechanism to delete files at some future point in time. That's currently only used as part of a safety/sanity

Re: Trimming the CPAN - Automatic Purging

2010-03-26 Thread Ask Bjørn Hansen
On Mar 25, 2010, at 4:12, Tim Bunce wrote: Currently on PAUSE you have to explicitly delete old uploads. How about changing it so you have to explicitly KEEP old uploads that appear to have been superseded? I like it. I agree with Jarkko that there should be a way to pin some versions and

Re: Trimming the CPAN - Automatic Purging

2010-03-26 Thread Ask Bjørn Hansen
On Mar 25, 2010, at 8:38, Andy Armstrong wrote: I like that solution better [snip] But solution to what? Are we convinced there's actually a problem here? CPAN has almost 200k files. www.cpan.org says there are 17627 modules. rsyncing a gazillion files doesn't work that well (on the

Re: Trimming the CPAN - Automatic Purging

2010-03-26 Thread Chris Nandor
What Jarkko said. On Mar 25, 2010, at 08:00, Jarkko Hietaniemi wrote: I have one case where the v1 and v2 of a module are simply incompatible, but v1 still works, and unless the users have a compelling reason, they won't migrate. Pulling the rug from under them would be quite

Re: Looking for people to take over maintenance of my Perl modules on CPAN

2010-03-26 Thread Curtis Jewell
Because I happen to like (and use) Pod::Readme, I'd like to take over that one. I can also take over File::HomeDir::Win32, as well. --Curtis On Fri, 26 Mar 2010 13:02 +, Robert Rothenberg rob...@gmail.com wrote: Hi All, I've been too busy the last few years working on a PhD, and haven't

Re: Trimming the CPAN - Automatic Purging

2010-03-26 Thread Arthur Corliss
On Fri, 26 Mar 2010, Ask Bj?rn Hansen wrote: I find it curious that everyone who's actually involved in syncing the files or running mirror servers seem to think it generally sounds like a good idea and everyone who doesn't say it's not worth the effort. Sure, I don't run a CPAN mirror, but

Re: Trimming the CPAN - Automatic Purging

2010-03-26 Thread Elaine Ashton
On Mar 26, 2010, at 8:23 PM, Arthur Corliss wrote: Sure, I don't run a CPAN mirror, but I do manage many, many terrabytes of storage as part of my day job. I think it's a tad presumptuous to disregard input just because we're not in your inner sanctum. As I mentioned in a follow up