What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Sean Donelan
On Tue, 28 Jan 2003, The New York Times wrote: A spokesman for Microsoft, Rick Miller, confirmed that a number of the company's machines had gone unpatched, and that Microsoft Network services, like many others on the Internet, experienced a significant slowdown. We, like the rest of the

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Alex Bligh
Sean, --On 28 January 2003 03:10 -0500 Sean Donelan [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Are there practical answers that actually work in the real world with real users and real business needs? 1. Employ clueful staff 2. Make their operating environment (procedures etc.) best able to exploit their

Re: Level3 routing issues?

2003-01-28 Thread David Howe
at Monday, January 27, 2003 7:50 PM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] [EMAIL PROTECTED] was seen to say: This is not correct. VPN simply extends security policy to a different location. A VPN user must make sure that local security policy prevents other traffic from entering VPN connection. This is nice in

Blocked by msn.com MX, contact for MSN.COM postmaster ?

2003-01-28 Thread Miquel van Smoorenburg
I found out that our outgoing SMTP servers have been blocked by the msn.com MXes. In a nasty way, too -- no SMTP error, the TCP connection is simply closed by them immidiately after establishing it. We're not listed on any RBL/DNSBL and have an active abuse desk. I mailed [EMAIL PROTECTED],

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread E.B. Dreger
ED Date: Tue, 28 Jan 2003 12:42:41 + (GMT) ED From: E.B. Dreger ED Sure, worm authors are to blame for their creations. ED Software developers are to blame for bugs. Admins are to s/Admins/Admins and their management/ Eddy -- Brotsman Dreger, Inc. - EverQuick Internet Division

Re: Level3 routing issues?

2003-01-28 Thread cowie
Wow, for a minute I thought I was looking at one of our old plots, except for the fact that the x-axis says January 2003 and not September 2001 :) :) seeing that the etiology and effects of the two events were quite different, perhaps eyeglasses which make them look the same are not

Re: Level3 routing issues?

2003-01-28 Thread Jack Bates
From: So far it's been visible as an apparently accidental byproduct of an attack with other goals. Are you willing to bet your bifocals that the same mechanism can't be weaponized and used against the routing infrastructure directly in the future? Yet the question becomes the reasoning

Re: Blocked by msn.com MX, contact for MSN.COM postmaster ?

2003-01-28 Thread Karsten W. Rohrbach
Miquel van Smoorenburg([EMAIL PROTECTED])@2003.01.28 11:49:16 +: I found out that our outgoing SMTP servers have been blocked by the msn.com MXes. In a nasty way, too -- no SMTP error, the TCP connection is simply closed by them immidiately after establishing it. We're not listed on any

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Leo Bicknell
In a message written on Tue, Jan 28, 2003 at 03:10:18AM -0500, Sean Donelan wrote: They bought finest firewalls, A firewall is a tool, not a solution. Firewall companies advertise much like Home Depot (Lowes, etc), everything you need to build a house. While anyone with 3 brain cells realizes

RE: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Eric Germann
Not to sound to pro-MS, but if they are going to sue, they should be able to sue ALL software makers. And what does that do to open source? Apache, MySQL, OpenSSH, etc have all had their problems. Should we sue the nail gun vendor because some moron shoots himself in the head with it? No. It

Re: Level3 routing issues?

2003-01-28 Thread cowie
So far it's been visible as an apparently accidental byproduct of an attack with other goals. Are you willing to bet your bifocals that the same mechanism can't be weaponized and used against the routing infrastructure directly in the future? Yet the question becomes the reasoning

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Jack Bates
From: Eric Germann Not to sound to pro-MS, but if they are going to sue, they should be able to sue ALL software makers. And what does that do to open source? Apache, MySQL, OpenSSH, etc have all had their problems. Should we sue the nail gun vendor because some moron shoots himself in

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Ted Fischer
At 11:13 AM 1/28/03 -0200, Rubens Kuhl Jr. et al postulated: | Are there practical answers that actually work in the real world with | real users and real business needs? Yes, the simple ones that are known for decades: - Minimum-privilege networks (access is blocked by default, permitted to

Re: Level3 routing issues?

2003-01-28 Thread Jack Bates
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] snip On the other hand, we also know (from private communications and from other mailing lists.. ahem) that high rate and high src/dst diversity of scans causes some network devices to fail (devices that cache flows, or devices that suffer from cpu overload under such

RE: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Drew Weaver
Would it be that hard to have windows update check to see the version of SQL server? Its sad but I know a lot of MS admins only use windows update to check for updates because awhile ago Microsoft pushed it as the premier method of which to update your systems. Im just saying if they included

Re: Level3 routing issues?

2003-01-28 Thread Hank Nussbacher
At 09:47 AM 28-01-03 -0600, Jack Bates wrote: From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] snip On the other hand, we also know (from private communications and from other mailing lists.. ahem) that high rate and high src/dst diversity of scans causes some network devices to fail (devices that cache flows, or

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Leo Bicknell
In a message written on Tue, Jan 28, 2003 at 10:23:09AM -0500, Eric Germann wrote: Not to sound to pro-MS, but if they are going to sue, they should be able to sue ALL software makers. And what does that do to open source? Apache, MySQL, OpenSSH, etc have all had their problems. Should we

Re: Banc of America Article

2003-01-28 Thread Roger Marquis
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: It could be that BoA's network wasn't flooded / servers infected, but that the ATM's do not dial BoA directly, and dial somewhere else (ie, maybe some kind of ATM Dial Provider, nationwide wholesale, etc), and then tunnel back to BoA to get the data. Could be

Re: Level3 routing issues?

2003-01-28 Thread Jared Mauch
On Tue, Jan 28, 2003 at 03:34:15PM +, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Some BGP-speaking routers (not all, by any means, but some subpopulation) found themselves pegged at 100% CPU on Saturday. Just one example: http://noc.ilan.net.il/stats/ILAN-CPU/new-gp-cpu.html I wonder how

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Andy Putnins
On Tue, 28 Jan 2003 10:42:05 - Alex Bligh wrote: Sean, --On 28 January 2003 03:10 -0500 Sean Donelan [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Are there practical answers that actually work in the real world with real users and real business needs? 1. Employ clueful staff 2. Make

RE: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Ray Burkholder
The SANS Institute [[EMAIL PROTECTED]] www.sans.org is a well respected collection of individuals who have provided this 'pool' of knowledge and regularly disseminate it to inquiring minds. Ray Burkholder -Original Message- From: Andy Putnins [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent:

VPN clients and security models

2003-01-28 Thread alex
This is not correct. VPN simply extends security policy to a different location. A VPN user must make sure that local security policy prevents other traffic from entering VPN connection. This is nice in theory, but in practice is simply not true. even assuming that the most restrictive

Re: Level3 routing issues?

2003-01-28 Thread Haesu
http://noc.ilan.net.il/stats/ILAN-CPU/new-gp-cpu.html Was it not known that under certain conditions the router would flatline? What percautionary measures were put into place in such an event to limit the damage? scheduler allocate -hc

Re: VPN clients and security models

2003-01-28 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Tue, 28 Jan 2003 11:52:39 EST, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: Welcome to the world of formal security models. If in theory a VPN is nothing more than a tool of extending the security policy of a site to a remote location, then it does not matter what kind of things you try to achieve with it, it

WANAL (Re: What could have been done differently?)

2003-01-28 Thread Paul Vixie
[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Eric Germann) writes: Not to sound to pro-MS, but if they are going to sue, they should be able to sue ALL software makers. And what does that do to open source? Apache, MySQL, OpenSSH, etc have all had their problems. ... Don't forget BIND, we've had our problems as

wrt BofA ATM: is it ATM 'automated' or ATM 'async' ?

2003-01-28 Thread Jeff . Hodges
good question. anyone know the answer? JeffH --- Forwarded Message Date: Tue, 28 Jan 2003 02:29:17 -0500 Subject: [IP] is it ATM or ATM Internet Attack's Disruptions More Serious Than Many Thought Possible From: Dave Farber [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: ip [EMAIL PROTECTED] - --

OT: Re: WANAL (Re: What could have been done differently?)

2003-01-28 Thread Rafi Sadowsky
## On 2003-01-28 17:49 - Paul Vixie typed: PV PV In any case, all of these makers (including Microsoft) seem to make a very PV good faith effort to get patches out when vulnerabilities are uncovered. I PV wish we could have put time bombs in older BINDs to force folks to upgrade, PV but

Re: OT: Re: WANAL (Re: What could have been done differently?)

2003-01-28 Thread Paul Vixie
What do you think of OpenBSD still installing BIND4 as part of the default base system and recommended as secure by the OpenBSD FAQ ? (See Section 6.8.3 in http://www.openbsd.org/faq/faq6.html#DNS ) i think that bind4 was relatively easy for them to do a format string audit on, and that

Re: wrt BofA ATM: is it ATM 'automated' or ATM 'async' ?

2003-01-28 Thread Marshall Eubanks
This makes it pretty clear http://biz.yahoo.com/rb/030125/tech_virus_boa_1.html Reuters Bank of America ATMs Disrupted by Virus Saturday January 25, 5:33 pm ET SEATTLE (Reuters) - Bank of America Corp. (NYSE:BAC - News) said on Saturday that customers at a majority of its 13,000 automatic

RE: Banc of America Article

2003-01-28 Thread alex
I'm familiar with some enforced financial institution requirements, no where did I find transaction data of ATMs on a dedicated network to be _required_. Is this a common industry practice, or a mandatory standard I have not discovered? It is a common practice. Since the alarm line is

Re: Is it time to block all Microsoft protocols in the core?

2003-01-28 Thread Joe Abley
On Monday, Jan 27, 2003, at 14:04 Asia/Katmandu, Sean Donelan wrote: Its not just a Microsoft thing. SYSLOG opened the network port by default, and the user has to remember to disable it for only local logging. You're using mixed tense in these sentences, so I can't tell whether you think

RE: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Vadim Antonov
On Tue, 28 Jan 2003, Eric Germann wrote: Not to sound to pro-MS, but if they are going to sue, they should be able to sue ALL software makers. And what does that do to open source? A law can be crafted in such a way so as to create distinction between selling for profit (and assuming

Re: Is it time to block all Microsoft protocols in the core?

2003-01-28 Thread David Charlap
Joe Abley wrote: You're using mixed tense in these sentences, so I can't tell whether you think that syslog's network port is open by default on operating systems today. On FreeBSD, NetBSD, OpenBSD and Darwin/Mac OS X (the only xterms I happen to have open right now) this is not the case,

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
Sean Donelan wrote: Many different companies were hit hard by the Slammer worm, some with better than average reputations for security awareness. They bought finest firewalls, they had two-factor biometric locks on their data centers, they installed anti-virus software, they paid for SAS70

Re: OT: Re: WANAL (Re: What could have been done differently?)

2003-01-28 Thread Mike Lewinski
On 1/28/03 11:57 AM, Paul Vixie [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: What do you think of OpenBSD still installing BIND4 as part of the default base system and recommended as secure by the OpenBSD FAQ ? (See Section 6.8.3 in http://www.openbsd.org/faq/faq6.html#DNS ) i think that bind4 was

Aggregate traffic management

2003-01-28 Thread Stanislav Rost
Dear NANOGers, I have a very hands-on question: Suppose I am a network operator for a decent-sized ISP, and I decide that I want to divide aggregate traffic flowing through a router toward some destination, in order to then send some of it through one route and the remainder through another

Re: Aggregate traffic management

2003-01-28 Thread Jack Bates
From: Stanislav Rost How would I be able to accomplish this division? What technologies (even if vendor-specific) would I use? I can think of some methods like prefix-matching classification and ECMP, but I am still not sure exactly how the latter works in practice (at the router level)

Re: Is it time to block all Microsoft protocols in the core?

2003-01-28 Thread Joe Abley
On Wednesday, Jan 29, 2003, at 01:25 Asia/Katmandu, Joe Abley wrote: On FreeBSD, NetBSD, OpenBSD and Darwin/Mac OS X (the only xterms I happen to have open right now) this is not the case, and has not been for some time. I presume, perhaps naïvely, that other operating systems have done

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Scott Francis
On Tue, Jan 28, 2003 at 03:10:18AM -0500, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: [snip] Many different companies were hit hard by the Slammer worm, some with better than average reputations for security awareness. They bought finest firewalls, they had two-factor biometric locks on their data centers, they

Re: Aggregate traffic management

2003-01-28 Thread John Todd
It can be done several ways, but the question is how are you differentiating? This is an incomplete list of methods for differentiating, each of which is supported by one or more vendors or open-source solutions: - destination address - specific prefix matching - prefix length

Re: Is it time to block all Microsoft protocols in the core?

2003-01-28 Thread Steven M. Bellovin
In message [EMAIL PROTECTED], Barney Wolff writes: On Wed, Jan 29, 2003 at 03:50:34AM +0545, Joe Abley wrote: On Wednesday, Jan 29, 2003, at 01:25 Asia/Katmandu, Joe Abley wrote: On FreeBSD, NetBSD, OpenBSD and Darwin/Mac OS X (the only xterms I happen to have open right now) this is not

wrt BofA ATM: is it ATM 'automated' or ATM 'async' ?

2003-01-28 Thread Stewart, William C (Bill), SALES
Over the last N years, I've often been the (Asynchronous Transfer Mode) ATM specialist for the group I'm in, as well as occasionally doing network designs and proposals for banks. While some banks use ATM to connect the networks that support their ATMs, few if any come close to 1000 Asynchronous

Re: Is it time to block all Microsoft protocols in the core?

2003-01-28 Thread Joe Abley
On Wednesday, Jan 29, 2003, at 04:56 Asia/Katmandu, Steven M. Bellovin wrote: In message [EMAIL PROTECTED], Barney Wolff writes: On Wed, Jan 29, 2003 at 03:50:34AM +0545, Joe Abley wrote: On Wednesday, Jan 29, 2003, at 01:25 Asia/Katmandu, Joe Abley wrote: On FreeBSD, NetBSD, OpenBSD and

Re: Aggregate traffic management

2003-01-28 Thread Kyle C. Bacon
Take a look at a product called Path Control by RouteScience. http://www.routescience.com/ I have seen their product in action and it is very slick. Does exactly what you want, plus a whole lot more and does it transparently (so if it fails you aren't SOL) via manipulating BGP tables and

RE: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Eric Germann
XP has autoupdate notifications that nag you. They could make it automatic, but then everyone would sue them if it mucked up their system. And, MS has their HFCHECK program which checks which hotfixes should be installed. Again, not automatic because they would like the USER to sign off on

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Scott Francis
On Tue, Jan 28, 2003 at 07:10:52PM -0500, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: [snip] As has been said, no one writes perfect software. And again, sometime, the user has to share some responsibility. Maybe if the users get burned enough, the problem will get solved. Either they will get fired, the

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Scott Francis
On Tue, Jan 28, 2003 at 11:22:13AM -0500, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: [snip] That is, I think there is a big difference between a company the size of Microsoft saying we've known about this problem for 6 months but didn't consider it serious so we didn't do anything about it, and an open source

Re: OT: Re: WANAL (Re: What could have been done differently?)

2003-01-28 Thread Scott Francis
On Tue, Jan 28, 2003 at 08:53:59PM +0200, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: [snip] Hi Paul, What do you think of OpenBSD still installing BIND4 as part of the default base system and recommended as secure by the OpenBSD FAQ ? (See Section 6.8.3 in http://www.openbsd.org/faq/faq6.html#DNS ) OpenBSD

Re: Banc of America Article

2003-01-28 Thread Leo Bicknell
FWIW: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A57550-2003Jan28.html About 13,000 Bank of America cash machines had to be shut down. The bank's ATMs sent encrypted information through the Internet, and when the data slowed to a crawl, it stymied transactions, according to a source, who

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread David Lesher
Somewhere in the equation, the sysadmin/enduser, whether Unix or Windows, has to take some responsibility. Hence I loved this: http://www.nytimes.com/2003/01/28/technology/28SOFT.html Worm Hits Microsoft, Which Ignored Own Advice By JOHN SCHWARTZ Among the

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Mike Lewinski
On Tue, 28 Jan 2003, Andy Putnins wrote: This is therefore a request for all of those who possess this clue to write down their wisdom and share it with the rest of us I can't tell you what clue is, but I know when I don't see it. In some cases our clients have had Code Red, Nimda, and

Re: Banc of America Article

2003-01-28 Thread Steven M. Bellovin
In message [EMAIL PROTECTED], Leo Bicknell writes: FWIW: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A57550-2003Jan28.html About 13,000 Bank of America cash machines had to be shut down. The bank's ATMs sent encrypted information through the Internet, and when the data slowed to a crawl,

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Scott Francis
On Tue, Jan 28, 2003 at 08:14:17PM +0100, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: [snip] restrictive measures that operate with sufficient granularity. In Unix, traditionally this is done per-user. Regular users can do a few things, but the super-user can do everything. If a user must do something that

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Scott Francis
On Tue, Jan 28, 2003 at 09:00:48PM -0500, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: In message [EMAIL PROTECTED], Scott Francis writes: There's a difference between having the occasional bug in one's software (Apache, OpenSSH) and having a track record of remotely exploitable vulnerabilities in virtually

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Brian Wallingford
On Tue, 28 Jan 2003, Steven M. Bellovin wrote: :They do have a lousy track record. I'm convinced, though, that :they're sincere about wanting to improve, and they're really trying :very hard. In fact, I hope that some other vendors follow their :lead. My big worry isn't the micro-issues like

Re: What could have been done differently?

2003-01-28 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Tue, 28 Jan 2003 19:10:52 EST, Eric Germann [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: Sort of like the person who sued McD's when they dumped their own coffee in their lap because it was too hot. Somewhere in the equation, the sysadmin/enduser, whether Unix or Windows, has to take some responsibility. Bad

Dropouts since Saturday 1/25/03 only affecting web traffic?

2003-01-28 Thread Sean Donelan
According to Matrix Systems (http://average.miq.net/Weekly/markR.html) there have been two additional dropouts of global Web reachability on January 26 and January 28. These dropouts have been for few hours or so, but nearly as large as we saw from the SQL worm. However it doesn't seem to

Re: Aggregate traffic management

2003-01-28 Thread Serge Maskalik
Stanislav, It depends what control mechanism you are using: o routes learned via an IGP - ECMP would work and if it's a single destination host, per-packet loadbalancing between the outgoing links is your only practical choice; rest of ECMP schemes work by