Re: Verizon has been listening to nanog.

2007-10-24 Thread Hex Star
On 10/23/07, Leo Bicknell [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: http://www.usatoday.com/tech/news/2007-10-23-verizon-fios-plan_N.htm 20 Mbps down, 20 Mbps up, fully symmetrical for $65. That's pretty sweet, now all they have to do is start laying the fiber over here...

Re: Can P2P applications learn to play fair on networks?

2007-10-24 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On 23-okt-2007, at 19:43, Sean Donelan wrote: The problem here is that they seem to be using a sledge hammer: BitTorrent is essentially left dead in the water. And they deny doing anything, to boot. A reasonable approach would be to throttle the offending applications to make them fit

Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Tim Franklin
On Tue, October 23, 2007 5:17 pm, Jack Bates wrote: Sorry, I am the incumbent. ;) I was just thinking of the copper necessary to do such a task on a massive scale. It's definitely not in the ground or on a pole at this point in time. One reason DSL was so desireable for many small ILECs was

Re: Internet access in Japan (was Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets)

2007-10-24 Thread Henry Yen
On Tue, Oct 23, 2007 at 09:20:49AM -0400, Leo Bicknell wrote: Why are no major us builders installing FTTH today? Greenfield should be the easiest, and major builders like Pulte, Centex and the like should be eager to offer it; but don't. Well, Verizon seems to be making heavy bets on

Re: Internet access in Japan (was Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets)

2007-10-24 Thread Joe Greco
I did consulting work for NTT in 2001 and 2002 and visited their Tokyo = headquarters twice. NTT has two ILEC divisions, NTT East and NTT West. = The ILEC management told me in conversations that there was no money in = fiber-to-the-home; the entire rollout was due to government pressure and

Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Joe Greco
I wonder how quickly applications and network gear would implement QoS support if the major ISPs offered their subscribers two queues: a default queue, which handled regular internet traffic but squashed P2P, and then a separate queue that allowed P2P to flow uninhibited for an extra

Re: Verizon has been listening to nanog.

2007-10-24 Thread Joe Maimon
Hex Star wrote: On 10/23/07, Leo Bicknell [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: http://www.usatoday.com/tech/news/2007-10-23-verizon-fios-plan_N.htm 20 Mbps down, 20 Mbps up, fully symmetrical for $65. That's pretty sweet, now all they have to do is start laying the fiber over here... And stop

Re: Internet access in Japan (was Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets)

2007-10-24 Thread Larry Smith
On Wednesday 24 October 2007 05:36, Henry Yen wrote: On Tue, Oct 23, 2007 at 09:20:49AM -0400, Leo Bicknell wrote: Why are no major us builders installing FTTH today? Greenfield should be the easiest, and major builders like Pulte, Centex and the like should be eager to offer it; but

Re: Verizon has been listening to nanog.

2007-10-24 Thread Henry Yen
On Wed, Oct 24, 2007 at 08:29:54AM -0400, Joe Maimon wrote: On 10/23/07, Leo Bicknell [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: http://www.usatoday.com/tech/news/2007-10-23-verizon-fios-plan_N.htm 20 Mbps down, 20 Mbps up, fully symmetrical for $65. That's pretty sweet, now all they have to do is

Re: Internet access in Japan (was Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets)

2007-10-24 Thread Tom Vest
In the future, people are not going to believe that we permitted this to happen. Coming soon: your plumbing will be disconnected. But never fear: an Evian vending machine will delivered to every deserving household... TV On Oct 24, 2007, at 2:39 PM, Larry Smith wrote: On Wednesday 24

Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Dorn Hetzel
How about a system where I tell my customers that for a given plan X at price Y they get U bytes of high priority upload per month (or day or whatever) and after that all their traffic is low priority until the next cycle starts. Now here's the fun part. They can mark the priority on the packets

Re: Internet access in Japan (was Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets)

2007-10-24 Thread Dave Pooser
While probably more good than bad, it is my understanding that when Verizon (and others) provide FTTH (fiber to the home) they cut or physically disconnect all other connections to that residence. so much for any choice... At least around here, if you tell the installer you have an

Re: Can P2P applications learn to play fair on networks?

2007-10-24 Thread Sean Donelan
On Wed, 24 Oct 2007, Iljitsch van Beijnum wrote: There are many reasonable things providers could do. So then why to you stick up for Comcast when they do something unreasonable? Although yesterday there was a little more info and it seems they only stop the affected protocols temporarily,

RE: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Carpenter, Jason
That's a fair plan. Simple me came up with this one, Don't say you offer 3mb if you only offer 20k. Simple enough, I think a big problem is that sales is saying they offer all this bandwidth, but the reality is no one gets it. You can blame P2P all you want, but realistically if users are

RE: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Frank Bulk
The key thing is that it can't be too complicated for the subscriber. What you've described is already too difficult for the masses to consume. The scavenger class, as has been described in other postings, is probably the simplest way to implement things. Let the application developers

RE: Internet access in Japan (was Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets)

2007-10-24 Thread Frank Bulk
Here's timely article: KDDI says 900k target for fibre users 'difficult' http://www.telegeography.com/cu/article.php?article_id=20215email=html Frank -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of David Andersen Sent: Monday, October 22, 2007 9:21 PM

Re: Verizon has been listening to nanog.

2007-10-24 Thread Jared Mauch
On Wed, Oct 24, 2007 at 08:58:13AM -0400, Henry Yen wrote: On Wed, Oct 24, 2007 at 08:29:54AM -0400, Joe Maimon wrote: On 10/23/07, Leo Bicknell [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: http://www.usatoday.com/tech/news/2007-10-23-verizon-fios-plan_N.htm 20 Mbps down, 20 Mbps up, fully

RE: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Rod Beck
The vast bulk of users have no idea how many bytes they consume each month or the bytes generated by different applications. The schemes being advocated in this discussion require that the end users be Layer 3 engineers. That might dramatically shrink you 'addressable market', not to mention

RE: Internet access in Japan (was Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets)

2007-10-24 Thread Rod Beck
On Wednesday 24 October 2007 05:36, Henry Yen wrote: On Tue, Oct 23, 2007 at 09:20:49AM -0400, Leo Bicknell wrote: Why are no major us builders installing FTTH today? Greenfield should be the easiest, and major builders like Pulte, Centex and the like should be eager to offer it; but

Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Adrian Chadd
On Wed, Oct 24, 2007, Rod Beck wrote: The vast bulk of users have no idea how many bytes they consume each month or the bytes generated by different applications. The schemes being advocated in this discussion require that the end users be Layer 3 engineers. You'd be surprised; users in

Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Adrian Chadd
On Wed, Oct 24, 2007, Rod Beck wrote: That misses the point. They are probably being forced to adapt by a monopoly or a quasi-monopoly or by the fact that transport into Australia is extremely expensive. The situation outside of Australia is quite different. A DS3 from Sydney to LA is

RE: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Rod Beck
That misses the point. They are probably being forced to adapt by a monopoly or a quasi-monopoly or by the fact that transport into Australia is extremely expensive. The situation outside of Australia is quite different. A DS3 from Sydney to LA is worth about 10 DS3s NYC/London. It is not

Re: Internet access in Japan (was Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets)

2007-10-24 Thread Joel Jaeggli
Frank Bulk wrote: Here's timely article: KDDI says 900k target for fibre users 'difficult' http://www.telegeography.com/cu/article.php?article_id=20215email=html KDDI isn't the only ftfth provider... NTT east/west (flets), usen, softbank/yahooBB and others all play in that space. 100/100 from

Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Dorn Hetzel
people manage to count stuff they use when they pay for it. minutes(cell), kwh(electricity), gallons(gas), etc. people have managed to figure out cell phone plans where they get N minutes included and then pay extra over that. the only users this would affect are those that upload a lot,

Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Sean Donelan
On Wed, 24 Oct 2007, Adrian Chadd wrote: You'd be surprised; users in the Australian market have had to get used to knowing how much bandwidth they use. People are adaptable. Get used to it. :) Likewise, people seem to complain about anything. Even Australians seem to like to complain.

Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Wed, 24 Oct 2007 15:44:53 BST, Rod Beck said: The vast bulk of users have no idea how many bytes they consume each month or the bytes generated by different applications. Note that in many/most cases, the person signing the agreement and paying the bill (the parental units) are not the ones

RE: Internet access in Japan (was Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets)

2007-10-24 Thread Steve Gibbard
On Wed, 24 Oct 2007, Rod Beck wrote: On Wednesday 24 October 2007 05:36, Henry Yen wrote: On Tue, Oct 23, 2007 at 09:20:49AM -0400, Leo Bicknell wrote: Why are no major us builders installing FTTH today? Greenfield should be the easiest, and major builders like Pulte, Centex and the like

Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Sean Donelan
The problem isn't a particular type of traffic in isolation, its usually the impact of one network user's traffic on all the other network user's traffic sharing the same network. Network Quotas for Individuals - A better answer to the P2P bandwidth problem?

RE: Internet access in Japan (was Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets)

2007-10-24 Thread Rod Beck
Exactly. And because they installed fiber, the FCC has ruled that they do not have to provide unbundled network elements to competitors. It's this last bit that seems to be leading to lots of complaints, and it's the earlier pricing of unbundled network elements at or above the cost of

Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Bruce Curtis
On Oct 24, 2007, at 1:28 PM, Sean Donelan wrote: The problem isn't a particular type of traffic in isolation, its usually the impact of one network user's traffic on all the other network user's traffic sharing the same network. Network Quotas for Individuals - A better answer to the

Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Adrian Chadd
On Wed, Oct 24, 2007, Sean Donelan wrote: Again, is there no alternative between such extremely low data caps on everyone and extreme usage by a a few? Sure, I'll sell you a 1:1 pipe that you can use 100%. AUD $400 a megabit. No worries. :) Adrian

RE: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread michael.dillon
The vast bulk of users have no idea how many bytes they consume each month or the bytes generated by different applications. The schemes being advocated in this discussion require that the end users be Layer 3 engineers. Actually, it sounds a lot like the Electric7 tariffs found in the UK

Re: BitTorrent swarms have a deadly bite on broadband nets

2007-10-24 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Thu, 25 Oct 2007 02:33:35 BST, [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: I really think that a two-tiered QOS system such as the scavenger suggestion is workable if the applications can do the marking. Has anyone done any testing to see if DSCP bits are able to travel unscathed through the public Internet?

OT: Choice Resale

2007-10-24 Thread Sherry Ollins
I would like to apologize to anyone who received an unwanted email from Choice Resale over the last few days. We have a new salesperson who did not realize that this type of email was not appropriate to send to list members. Choice Resale prides itself on being an important and valuable