Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-29 Thread Matthew Petach
On Mon, Dec 28, 2020 at 4:26 PM Niels Bakker wrote: > * mpet...@netflight.com (Matthew Petach) [Tue 29 Dec 2020, 01:08 CET]: > >But as far as the physics goes, the conversion of biomatter into > >petrochemicals in the ground is more "renewable" than the conversion > >of hydrogen into helium in

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-28 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/29/20 02:06, Matthew Petach wrote: Mark, I think you may have misunderstood Keith's comment about it being "all a matter of time-frame." He's right--when the sun consumes all the hydrogen in the hydrogen-to-helium fusion process and begins to expand into a red dwarf, that's it;

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-28 Thread Niels Bakker
* mpet...@netflight.com (Matthew Petach) [Tue 29 Dec 2020, 01:08 CET]: But as far as the physics goes, the conversion of biomatter into petrochemicals in the ground is more "renewable" than the conversion of hydrogen into helium in the sun. It's not. Where did Mr Metcalf think the energy

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-28 Thread Michael Thomas
On 12/28/20 4:06 PM, Matthew Petach wrote: I think you may have misunderstood Keith's comment about it being "all a matter of time-frame." He's right--when the sun consumes all the hydrogen in the hydrogen-to-helium fusion process and begins to expand into a red dwarf, that's it; there's no

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-28 Thread Matthew Petach
On Sun, Dec 27, 2020 at 12:28 PM Mark Tinka wrote: > > > On 12/27/20 21:56, Keith Medcalf wrote: > > > Me too. On top of that, diesel and gasoline are pretty reliable. > Though some people may argue about "renewables" the fact is that it is all > a matter of time-frame. Solar power, for

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-28 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/28/20 16:57, Mel Beckman wrote: It’s not just the lithium load in the environment that is of concern. As early as 2018 the US EPA had collected data on the incidence of so-called “hot fires” caused by lithium batteries in the waste stream. So far, nobody has been killed. But it’s

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-28 Thread Mel Beckman
It’s not just the lithium load in the environment that is of concern. As early as 2018 the US EPA had collected data on the incidence of so-called “hot fires” caused by lithium batteries in the waste stream. So far, nobody has been killed. But it’s only a matter of time before someone is, given

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/28/20 05:29, Brandon Martin wrote: Interestingly, the Lithium content is the, in theory, valuable part of it. There's not actually much Li in a typical Li-Ion rechargeable battery (much less than a Li metal primary cell), but my understanding is that it's enough to have people

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Brandon Martin
On 12/27/20 5:26 AM, Mark Tinka wrote: I'm just not sure where all that Li-Ion will go after 15 - 20 years of use, though... One European manufacturer (the one whose battery I bought) says that as of now, they can only recycle 20% of each battery they sell. To me, that sounds like just the 

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/27/20 21:56, Keith Medcalf wrote: Me too. On top of that, diesel and gasoline are pretty reliable. Though some people may argue about "renewables" the fact is that it is all a matter of time-frame. Solar power, for example, is not renewable. Once it is all used up, it will not

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/27/20 21:51, Sabri Berisha wrote: Netflix has a documentary on it, "Fire In Paradise". Gives me the chills every time I watch it. I'll have a sniff. Thanks! Mark.

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/27/20 19:49, Michael Thomas wrote: We can't get enough solar panels on the roof to charge a battery big enough to handle a multi-day outage, and the battery as quoted is only charged from the panels, not from the mains. It's easy enough to get a transfer switch though for the battery

RE: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Keith Medcalf
On: Sunday, 27 December, 2020 03:26, Mark Tinka wrote: >In the end, and for various reasons, I settled on renewables. Me too. On top of that, diesel and gasoline are pretty reliable. Though some people may argue about "renewables" the fact is that it is all a matter of time-frame. Solar

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Sabri Berisha
- On Dec 27, 2020, at 10:06 AM, Michael Thomas m...@mtcc.com wrote: Hi, > Right and here in California, it was precisely those lines that > incinerated Paradise. And for those lurkers outside of CA, or even the U.S., the small town named "Paradise" was completely wiped off the map a few

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Michael Thomas
On 12/27/20 10:26 AM, Baldur Norddahl wrote: All of the 400V and 10 kV is buried. That means no wires along streets, anywhere. The long haul transmission network consists mostly of 150 kV and 400 kV lines. That has been partly buried, especially near and in cities. There was a project to

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Baldur Norddahl
søn. 27. dec. 2020 19.00 skrev Valdis Klētnieks : > On Sun, 27 Dec 2020 17:57:17 +0100, Baldur Norddahl said: > > > Here in the civilised world we bury the wires ;-) > > Even the long-haul 765kv and up connections across the power grid? > > In the US, they're out on towers for a reason - you can

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Michael Thomas
On 12/27/20 10:00 AM, Valdis Klētnieks wrote: On Sun, 27 Dec 2020 17:57:17 +0100, Baldur Norddahl said: Here in the civilised world we bury the wires ;-) Even the long-haul 765kv and up connections across the power grid? In the US, they're out on towers for a reason - you can fly along

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Valdis Klētnieks
On Sun, 27 Dec 2020 17:57:17 +0100, Baldur Norddahl said: > Here in the civilised world we bury the wires ;-) Even the long-haul 765kv and up connections across the power grid? In the US, they're out on towers for a reason - you can fly along them in a helicopter and easily spot parts of cable

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Michael Thomas
On 12/27/20 9:38 AM, Mark Tinka wrote: On 12/27/20 18:14, Michael Thomas wrote: We have both, and are going to get a battery. But the battery would probably only be good for about a day which is not enough, especially with these planned shutoffs because they have to inspect their wire

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/27/20 18:57, Baldur Norddahl wrote: Here in the civilised world we bury the wires ;-) I'm certain every country has a combination of both... one of those more than the other in some places, but a combo nonetheless. Ultimately, it's most unlikely that any utility company is going

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/27/20 18:14, Michael Thomas wrote: We have both, and are going to get a battery. But the battery would probably only be good for about a day which is not enough, especially with these planned shutoffs because they have to inspect their wire plant in daylight. If you can add some

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Baldur Norddahl
søn. 27. dec. 2020 17.14 skrev Michael Thomas : > > > We have both, and are going to get a battery. But the battery would > probably only be good for about a day which is not enough, especially > with these planned shutoffs because they have to inspect their wire > plant in daylight. There has to

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Michael Thomas
On 12/27/20 2:26 AM, Mark Tinka wrote: On 12/26/20 23:57, Michael Thomas wrote: Yeah, it burned somebody's house to a crisp here last year around here. It certainly makes the case why leaving professionals in charge of power issues is the better idea. although with pg it's a tough

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/26/20 23:57, Michael Thomas wrote: Yeah, it burned somebody's house to a crisp here last year around here. It certainly makes the case why leaving professionals in charge of power issues is the better idea. although with pg it's a tough call, my telco not so much. I considered a

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-27 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/26/20 22:58, Michael Thomas wrote: Here in California the new reality is that multi-day outages are now common. The first few planned outages were 3-4 days, so that would be on the edge, especially if it's for gabby granny on the phone for hours.This all depends on the weather, and

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-26 Thread Jared Geiger
ww.youtube.com/channel/UCXSdfxQv7SpoRQYNyLwntZg> > ---------- > *From: *"Mark Tinka" > *To: *nanog@nanog.org > *Sent: *Friday, December 25, 2020 11:44:00 PM > > *Subject: *Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE > > > > On 12/25/20 23:04,

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-26 Thread Mike Hammett
Tinka" To: nanog@nanog.org Sent: Friday, December 25, 2020 11:44:00 PM Subject: Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE On 12/25/20 23:04, Michael Thomas wrote: > > I mean, i understand the arm's race, but now it seems to be an arms > race for its own sake. It is,

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-26 Thread Michael Thomas
w.facebook.com/thebrotherswisp><https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXSdfxQv7SpoRQYNyLwntZg> *From: *"Michael Thomas" *To: *nanog@nanog.org *Sent: *Friday, December 25, 2020 1:27:39 PM *Subject: *Re: [External] Re: 10g

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-26 Thread Mike Hammett
homas" To: nanog@nanog.org Sent: Friday, December 25, 2020 1:27:39 PM Subject: Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE On 12/25/20 11:04 AM, Mark Tinka wrote: On 12/25/20 20:10, Hunter Fuller via NANOG wrote: It would meet some customers’ needs because multiple people co

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-26 Thread Mike Hammett
homas" To: nanog@nanog.org Sent: Friday, December 25, 2020 1:27:39 PM Subject: Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE On 12/25/20 11:04 AM, Mark Tinka wrote: On 12/25/20 20:10, Hunter Fuller via NANOG wrote: It would meet some customers’ needs because multiple people co

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-26 Thread Mike Hammett
Ego. Ignorance. - Mike Hammett Intelligent Computing Solutions Midwest Internet Exchange The Brothers WISP - Original Message - From: "Michael Thomas" To: nanog@nanog.org Sent: Friday, December 25, 2020 1:27:39 PM Subject: Re: [External] Re: 10g resid

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-26 Thread Michael Thomas
On 12/26/20 1:13 PM, Valdis Klētnieks wrote: On Sat, 26 Dec 2020 12:58:42 -0800, Michael Thomas said: can go on for days. We have a generator because of this, but everybody getting a generator in the middle of the Berkeley Hills would be something of its own horror show, but it will probably

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-26 Thread Valdis Klētnieks
On Sat, 26 Dec 2020 12:58:42 -0800, Michael Thomas said: > can go on for days. We have a generator because of this, but everybody > getting a generator in the middle of the Berkeley Hills would be > something of its own horror show, but it will probably come down to that. Egads. Especially if a

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-26 Thread Michael Thomas
On 12/26/20 12:44 PM, John Levine wrote: In the 25 years since I've lived here the power has never been out as long as a day so I think a four day battery will give me pretty good reliability. I know my fiber is a straight shot to the CO since I'm only four blocks away but as far as I can

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-26 Thread John Levine
In article <653758700.2275.1608968920711.javamail.zim...@baylink.com>, Jay R. Ashworth wrote: >- Original Message - >> From: "John Levine" > >> They sure seem ready to take down the oopper. The installer was sad >> when I told him to leave my six-pair copper cable alone even though >>

RE: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-26 Thread Keith Medcalf
>If the operator wants to keep bufferbloat low you will not be able to >utilise your 1 Gbps to that speed when downloading from distant servers. >But with the same bufferbloat measured in milliseconds you will still >have a 10x bigger buffer and thus 10x bigger bandwidth delay product. >That

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-26 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/26/20 13:41, Nuno Vieira wrote: Once upon a time a wise main said “Who in their right mind would ever need more than 640k of ram?” While everyone will take a chance at using this line at some point in a computing career, it's somewhat disingenuous to compare (or equate) the 640KB

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-26 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/26/20 13:41, Nuno Vieira wrote: Once upon a time a wise main said “Who in their right mind would ever need more than 640k of ram?” While everyone will take a chance at using this line at some point in a computing career, it's somewhat disingenuous to compare (or equate) the 640KB

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-26 Thread Mikael Abrahamsson via NANOG
On Fri, 25 Dec 2020, Chris Adams wrote: Queueing doesn't get me my next game in time to play it tonight. I've always seen general queueing as a work-around for "not enough bandwidth and can't add more"... but when more is available, why not just use more? I de-bloat my 1000/1000 with

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-26 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/26/20 09:44, Jay R. Ashworth wrote: By which you mean that they can safely afford to bandwidth-surf again because the average usage is so much lower than the peak? Unless you are providing some kind of service from your home, yes. Mark.

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Jay R. Ashworth
- Original Message - > From: "John Levine" > They sure seem ready to take down the oopper. The installer was sad > when I told him to leave my six-pair copper cable alone even though > nothing is using it now. Sure; ILECs would *love* to deprovision their copper end networks. But

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Jay R. Ashworth
- Original Message - > From: "Mark Tinka" > On 12/25/20 22:49, Michael Thomas wrote: >> But using the right queuing disciplines it a lot cheaper than the >> brute force and ignorance of just upping the bandwidth, right? > > Consumer ISP's have realized that they can make money selling

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/26/20 00:32, John Levine wrote: I agree it is odd to make 100/100 the top speed. The fiber service I have from my local non-Bell telco offers 100/100, 500/500, and 1000/1000. FiOS where you can get it goes to 940/880. The obvious guess is that their upstream bandwidth is

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/25/20 23:04, Michael Thomas wrote: I mean, i understand the arm's race, but now it seems to be an arms race for its own sake. It is, because it is hard to be different when all you know is to sell bandwidth. The next level of differentiation is being a fibre provider, and

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/25/20 22:49, Michael Thomas wrote: But using the right queuing disciplines it a lot cheaper than the brute force and ignorance of just upping the bandwidth, right? Consumer ISP's have realized that they can make money selling Gigabit services, because the ones who really know how

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/25/20 22:40, Chris Adams wrote: Bandwidth is like disk space - you think "I'll never use all of this", and then the availability changes behavior. Having ability to do more means your behavior changes to utilize more. We don't NEED high speed Internet to download games - we could

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread John Levine
In article <5f11bc55-e3d1-006d-c4c4-0703ff63c...@mtcc.com> you write: >> The obvious guess is that their upstream bandwidth is >> underprovisioned, or maybe they figure 100/100 is all they need to >> compete in that particular market. > >What's weirder is that it's most likely not going to allow

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Michael Thomas
On 12/25/20 2:32 PM, John Levine wrote: In article <3b0bc95b-c741-7561-1692-75fac74d5...@mtcc.com> you write: I'd definitely appreciate symmetric, or at least better in upstream. Obviously zoom and all of that has made a lie of us not needing upstream. It would make cloud based "filesystems"

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread John Levine
In article <3b0bc95b-c741-7561-1692-75fac74d5...@mtcc.com> you write: >I'd definitely appreciate symmetric, or at least better in upstream. >Obviously zoom and all of that has made a lie of us not needing >upstream. It would make cloud based "filesystems" more feasible too. > >But the larger

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Baldur Norddahl
fre. 25. dec. 2020 21.49 skrev Michael Thomas : > > On 12/25/20 12:40 PM, Chris Adams wrote: > > > > The other aspect of it is that we're doing these downloads while > > continuing to play other games and chat (both things sensitive to > > latency). Some have family/roommates in the home, so

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Michael Thomas
On 12/25/20 1:25 PM, John Levine wrote: In article you write: I'm fine with "free stuff". But it seems we've hit saturation on a number of front like camera and screen pixels, ghz of cpu, TB's of disk, Gb's of netio for residential stuff. My provider on the other (Volcano Internet) doesn't

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread John Levine
In article you write: >I'm fine with "free stuff". But it seems we've hit saturation on a >number of front like camera and screen pixels, ghz of cpu, TB's of disk, >Gb's of netio for residential stuff. > >My provider on the other (Volcano Internet) doesn't seem to have got >this memo though.

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Michael Thomas
On 12/25/20 12:53 PM, Chris Adams wrote: Once upon a time, Michael Thomas said: On 12/25/20 12:40 PM, Chris Adams wrote: The other aspect of it is that we're doing these downloads while continuing to play other games and chat (both things sensitive to latency). Some have family/roommates

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Chris Adams
Once upon a time, Michael Thomas said: > On 12/25/20 12:40 PM, Chris Adams wrote: > >The other aspect of it is that we're doing these downloads while > >continuing to play other games and chat (both things sensitive to > >latency). Some have family/roommates in the home, so they may be >

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Michael Thomas
On 12/25/20 12:40 PM, Chris Adams wrote: The other aspect of it is that we're doing these downloads while continuing to play other games and chat (both things sensitive to latency). Some have family/roommates in the home, so they may be streaming audio and/or video at the same time. Do we

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Chris Adams
Once upon a time, Michael Thomas said: > On 12/25/20 11:39 AM, Cory Sell wrote: > >I saturate my 1G connection most during game downloads, file > >downloads/uploads, full backup uploads, etc. > > > >I also self-host a lot of services for personal use and having > >that peak speed is really nice

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/25/20 21:45, Michael Thomas wrote: Obviously for downloads it's nice, but how often is that happening? A time or two a month max? It seems sort of strange the providers would build out infrastructure for such a niche activity. Haha, that's the trick; they don't. Because the logic

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/25/20 21:39, Cory Sell via NANOG wrote: I saturate my 1G connection most during game downloads, file downloads/uploads, full backup uploads, etc. Same here, but how often does this happen? I upload my videos to Youtube once a week, if not less, at the most. The kids, more

RE: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Tony Wicks
in the house is a sweet spot, it is easily/cheaply retrofitted into any workstation with a free USB3 port and run’s on any existing cat5. From: NANOG On Behalf Of Michael Thomas Sent: Saturday, 26 December 2020 8:28 am To: nanog@nanog.org Subject: Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Michael Thomas
On 12/25/20 11:39 AM, Cory Sell wrote: I saturate my 1G connection most during game downloads, file downloads/uploads, full backup uploads, etc. I also self-host a lot of services for personal use and having that peak speed is really nice when you need it. It also had no traffic limit per

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Cory Sell via NANOG
I saturate my 1G connection most during game downloads, file downloads/uploads, full backup uploads, etc. I also self-host a lot of services for personal use and having that peak speed is really nice when you need it. It also had no traffic limit per month which is my biggest complaint about

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Michael Thomas
On 12/25/20 11:04 AM, Mark Tinka wrote: On 12/25/20 20:10, Hunter Fuller via NANOG wrote: It would meet some customers’ needs because multiple people could use 1G of service at a time. I think it is interesting to distinguish “>1G CPE” from “true 10G CPE” and I suspect many / most

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Mark Tinka
On 12/25/20 20:10, Hunter Fuller via NANOG wrote: It would meet some customers’ needs because multiple people could use 1G of service at a time. I think it is interesting to distinguish “>1G CPE” from “true 10G CPE” and I suspect many / most customers are looking for the former. Large

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Hunter Fuller via NANOG
On Fri, Dec 25, 2020 at 12:07 Cory Sell via NANOG wrote: > Just because nobody is mentioning it - you can always build a > pfSense/VyOS/Vyatta box in whatever form factor you’d prefer. Even can run > within a VM if you really want to. > For a CPE, openwrt would also work well. It runs well on a

Re: [External] Re: 10g residential CPE

2020-12-25 Thread Hunter Fuller via NANOG
On Fri, Dec 25, 2020 at 11:46 Bryan Fields wrote: > On 12/25/20 4:52 AM, Mark Tinka wrote: > > For the home, if you're looking at shipping 10Gbps-based CPE's for under > > US$200, I can't think of anything other than the Tik: > > > > https://mikrotik.com/product/rb4011igs_rm > > That has 1