Re: [NNagain] Net neutrality and Bufferbloat?

2023-12-18 Thread Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain
Hi Dick, > On Dec 18, 2023, at 21:51, Dick Roy wrote: > > Given that the capacity of a system is in essence a theoretical maximum (in > this case data rates of a communications sytem), I am not sure what "scaling > the capacity to the load" means. Oh this was supposed to mean that the

Re: [NNagain] Net neutrality and Bufferbloat?

2023-12-18 Thread Dick Roy via Nnagain
Given that the capacity of a system is in essence a theoretical maximum (in this case data rates of a communications sytem), I am not sure what "scaling the capacity to the load" means. Throttling the load to the capacity I understand. Hmm RR -Original Message- From: Nnagain

Re: [NNagain] Net neutrality and Bufferbloat?

2023-12-18 Thread Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain
Hi Jason, during the Covid19 era, the EU issued clarifications that even throttling a complete class like streaming video might be within reasonable network management. The only stipulations wer this needs to happen only to allow arguably more important traffic classes (like work-from home

Re: [NNagain] Net neutrality and Bufferbloat?

2023-12-18 Thread Livingood, Jason via Nnagain
> Misapplied concepts of network neutrality is one of the things that killed > fq codel for DOCSIS 3.1 I am not so sure this was the case - I think it was just that a different AQM was selected. DOCSIS 3.1 includes the DOCSIS-PIE AQM - see https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8034.html and

Re: [NNagain] [Starlink] FCC Upholds Denial of Starlink's RDOF Application

2023-12-18 Thread David Lang via Nnagain
The people getting the subsidies would be the subscribers. They wouldn't be paying for rocket launches direction, but for lower subscription prices in some areas. (and indirectly paying for launches) Note that Elon commented on this that it was the competition, not SpaceX that lobbied for

Re: [NNagain] Starlink

2023-12-18 Thread David Lang via Nnagain
I agree with your questions yes, Available bandwidth is shared between users. I don't know what you get if you are the only person there, but I can say that I'm in the LA metro area (far from rural) and I get enough bandwith to work remotely on Starlink. My local makerspace also has Starlink