Re: [Openstack] Nova-core membership request

2011-02-23 Thread Soren Hansen
This is now done. Den 21/02/2011 08.46 skrev Soren Hansen so...@ubuntu.com: 2011/2/19 Rick Harris rick.har...@rackspace.com: Throwing my hat into the ring for nova-core membership. Eager to help knock down that merge-prop backlog we have at the moment :-) +1 The 5 day grace period expires

Re: [Openstack] documentation of flags, introducing of a naming convention for flags

2011-02-23 Thread Diego Parrilla SantamarĂ­a
I forgot to add something to my 'wishlist' ;-) Changing the way we configure Nova should be a process announced in advanced. One or two releases in advance, to give enough time to teams doing deployments and upgrades of Nova to be prepared. Changes that can impact in the upgrade of the product

[Openstack] Decoupling of Network and Compute services for the new Network Service design

2011-02-23 Thread Ishimoto, Ryu
Hi everyone, I have been following the discussion regarding the new 'pluggable' network service design, and wanted to drop in my 2 cents ;-) Looking at the current implementation of Nova, there seems to be a very strong coupling between compute and network services. That is, tasks that are done

Re: [Openstack] Decoupling of Network and Compute services for the new Network Service design

2011-02-23 Thread Dan Wendlandt
I think this is very much inline with what we've been thinking. To me, providing a clean and generic programming interface that decouples the network functionality from the existing nova stack is a first step in creating a standalone network service. Also, I am not sure if this is implied by

Re: [Openstack] Proposal to be a member of Nova Core ...

2011-02-23 Thread Matt Dietz
+1 to this! On 2/17/11 3:28 PM, Soren Hansen so...@ubuntu.com wrote: +1! (Yup, that was +factorial(1), for those keeping score at home) 2011/2/17 Sandy Walsh sandy.wa...@rackspace.com: I'd like to help out on the review process as per

Re: [Openstack] Decoupling of Network and Compute services for the new Network Service design

2011-02-23 Thread John Purrier
I agree, this is exactly where we want to take the network services for OpenStack. The goal should be to decouple Compute from Network, with an eye toward a project separation post-Cactus (this should have a lot of discussion at the next design summit). For Cactus we have explicitly kept the

Re: [Openstack] Instances lost after reboot

2011-02-23 Thread Brian Schott
How did you install and launch OpenStack? The instances are stored in a sqllite or mysql table depending on how things are configured. Brian Brian Schott bfsch...@gmail.com On Feb 23, 2011, at 1:53 PM, George Argyrides wrote: Why do i lose instances after reboot? How can they remain

Re: [Openstack] Decoupling of Network and Compute services for the new Network Service design

2011-02-23 Thread John Purrier
And we are back to the discussion about orchestration... Given the flexibility of the OpenStack system and the goals of independently horizontally scaling services I think we will need to address this head on. #3 is the most difficult, but is also the right answer for the project as we look

Re: [Openstack] Instances lost after reboot

2011-02-23 Thread George Argyrides
Yes i have Ubuntu 10.04 LTS and installed from pkg Well in my scenario i need to have a powerful server(physical machine) that hosts VMs so i considered cloud to be any time able to scale that and even for redundancy.(starting from 1 server expanding to more possible) Can i do it with nova with

[Openstack] Should the OpenStack API re-use the EC2 credentials?

2011-02-23 Thread Justin Santa Barbara
I previously fixed OpenStack authentication so it would use the same credentials as EC2. This bugfix was just reverted, because it caused OpenStack API users to have to enter in different credentials (sorry!), but primarily because it hadn't been discussed on the mailing list. So here goes!

Re: [Openstack] Should the OpenStack API re-use the EC2 credentials?

2011-02-23 Thread Vishvananda Ishaya
Hey Justin, Does it make any difference that the way the auth is (theoretically) supposed to work with the os api is that the user gets an auth token from an external auth server and then uses username / authtoken to actually contact the api? I think it is just faked out right now to use the

Re: [Openstack] Should the OpenStack API re-use the EC2 credentials?

2011-02-23 Thread Justin Santa Barbara
When the authentication protocol changes, then OpenStack wrapper libraries will need to change - good point. So there's even less reason to treat OpenStack as if it were a stable API. However, we can't expect people using those libraries to change their credentials - there was enough kicking and

Re: [Openstack] Should the OpenStack API re-use the EC2 credentials?

2011-02-23 Thread Josh Kearney
Two people may have come into the channel and brought it to our attention today, but this was a very recent change. I can assure you there are many more OS API consumers out there already. It's likely that most just haven't pulled trunk since it landed. I think we all agree that a decision on a

Re: [Openstack] Should the OpenStack API re-use the EC2 credentials?

2011-02-23 Thread Paul Voccio
Justin, I think you hit upon the reason of why I think it was approved and reverted. Because it hadn't been talked about in a blueprint or a mail sent to the list (I think I'm up to date on the threads) and a patch landed means other alternatives weren't considered before pushing it through to

Re: [Openstack] Should the OpenStack API re-use the EC2 credentials?

2011-02-23 Thread Justin Santa Barbara
Hi Josh - I didn't think your Python API bindings were in particularly widespread use yet because they were so new. But I'm a big fan and love how they are moving so quickly. I think I hit some bugs in them one day and then when I pulled the next day you'd fixed them all. Perhaps there was some

Re: [Openstack] Should the OpenStack API re-use the EC2 credentials?

2011-02-23 Thread Josh Kearney
No hard feelings or anything like that. :) We actually did just have a talk about the possibility of merging it in with Nova (or perhaps combining them with other toolsets). I imagine it will hit the ML soon for further discussion once we get the kinks worked out. On Wed, Feb 23, 2011 at 9:11 PM,

Re: [Openstack] Instances lost after reboot

2011-02-23 Thread Thierry Carrez
Brian Schott wrote: How did you install and launch OpenStack? The instances are stored in a sqllite or mysql table depending on how things are configured. I think George's point is that if you reboot the compute node, you lose the instances that were running on it. I don't really know if