Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-21 Thread Sylwester Pietrzyk
Adam Maas wrote on 21.03.06 2:15: I don't think it will be a huge issue as long as the USM lenses are full-on pro lenses for the first few years. The rate of obsolescence and upgrading with DSLR's is such that most of the current bodies will be out of use in 3-4 years. If I were Pentax, I'd

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Sylwester Pietrzyk
K.Takeshita wrote on 25.02.06 19:44: OTOH, I do not believe Pentax abandoned FF lenses altogether. We still need fast tele (200/2.8, 300/2.8 etc etc) and I just cannot imagine, Pentax being so well recognized as a superb lens maker as well, simply drop out of normal lens biz. I think the

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread K.Takeshita
On 3/20/06 4:09 AM, Sylwester Pietrzyk, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Well Ken, if my (quite reliable) source of Pentax information is right - then new DA f2.8 lenses will have built-in AF motor (I guess ultrasonic one) and that would be a reason to change whole line of long lenses ;-) This would

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread dagt
fra: K.Takeshita [EMAIL PROTECTED] On 3/20/06 4:09 AM, Sylwester Pietrzyk, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Well Ken, if my (quite reliable) source of Pentax information is right - then new DA f2.8 lenses will have built-in AF motor (I guess ultrasonic one) and that would be a reason to change

re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Jens Bladt
:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sendt: 20. marts 2006 10:09 Til: pentax-discuss@pdml.net Emne: Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1? K.Takeshita wrote on 25.02.06 19:44: OTOH, I do not believe Pentax abandoned FF lenses altogether. We still need fast tele (200/2.8, 300/2.8 etc etc) and I just

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Juan Buhler
I hope that doesn't happen. There are a few of us who couldn't care less about auto focus. If I want ultrasonic motors in my lenses I know which brand to buy. If Pentax goes that way, I see it as having yet one less option available. j On 3/20/06, Sylwester Pietrzyk [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Adam Maas
lenses. Perhaps even a fast prime telephoto lens. Full frame or not. Regards Jens Bladt http://www.jensbladt.dk -Oprindelig meddelelse- Fra: Sylwester Pietrzyk [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sendt: 20. marts 2006 10:09 Til: pentax-discuss@pdml.net Emne: Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Adam Maas
Why? If you don't do AF, the AF system is irrelevant to you (Although I generally find the focus rings to be better damped on USM-type lenses tan most screw-drive lenses). And USM is a win for AF users, with faster focus and less hunting. -Adam Juan Buhler wrote: I hope that doesn't

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Godfrey DiGiorgi
How so? If they design the lenses and the new mount to be compatible, it adds an option not subtracts one. Godfrey On Mar 20, 2006, at 10:51 AM, Juan Buhler wrote: I hope that doesn't happen. There are a few of us who couldn't care less about auto focus. If I want ultrasonic motors in my

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Juan Buhler
I might be wrong, but wouldn't an usm motor add to the price, bulk and weight of the lenses? j On 3/20/06, Godfrey DiGiorgi [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: How so? If they design the lenses and the new mount to be compatible, it adds an option not subtracts one. Godfrey On Mar 20, 2006, at 10:51

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Jens Bladt
Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1? K.Takeshita wrote on 25.02.06 19:44: OTOH, I do not believe Pentax abandoned FF lenses altogether. We still need fast tele (200/2.8, 300/2.8 etc etc) and I just cannot imagine, Pentax being so well recognized as a superb lens maker as well, simply drop out

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Adam Maas
Not significantly to either for USM lenses. The motor adds about as much weight as removing the mechanical linkage saves. It's cheaper to manufacture, and adds only slightly to the diameter of the lens for most lenses. -Adam Juan Buhler wrote: I might be wrong, but wouldn't an usm motor

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Mark Roberts
Juan Buhler wrote: I might be wrong, but wouldn't an usm motor add to the price, bulk and weight of the lenses? Yes, but it's probably more than made up for by the cost savings in glass reduction (of a DA lens compared to a full-frame lens).

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Godfrey DiGiorgi
If we look at Canon lenses as an example and consider equivalent pairs of lenses, the USM ring servos do add some increment of bulk and weight in many cases (not all). Pricing is higher for some equivalents and not for others. The fact that the majority of their quality lenses are designed

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Sylwester Pietrzyk
On Mar 20, 2006, at 8:06 PM, Adam Maas wrote: Why? If you don't do AF, the AF system is irrelevant to you (Although I generally find the focus rings to be better damped on USM-type lenses tan most screw-drive lenses). Adam, you should try Ltd and FA* lenses then. They usually have

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread John Francis
I doubt if the mechanical linkage would go away; after all, if any new lenses I buy for a new body won't auto-focus on my *ist-D, then there's far less incentive for me to stick with Pentax. But on the (very few) USM lenses I've seen in pieces, the motor looks as though it adds significantly

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread jtainter
Well Ken, if my (quite reliable) source of Pentax information is right - then new DA f2.8 lenses will have built-in AF motor (I guess ultrasonic one) and that would be a reason to change whole line of long lenses ;-) This would be great! With my wishful thinking, this has always long been

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread K.Takeshita
On 3/20/06 3:17 PM, jtainter, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Will the new lenses still have the AF drive shaft so that they can be used on older cameras? Nikon Ken

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Aaron Reynolds
On Mar 20, 2006, at 3:17 PM, jtainter wrote: Even if the new lenses do have the drive shaft, for how long will this be the case? Will Pentax eventually drop the AF drive shaft, just as they dropped the mechanical aperture linkage from many recent lenses? How many years did they support the

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread jtainter
Will the new lenses still have the AF drive shaft so that they can be used on older cameras? Nikon Ken - Ken, what about Nikon? I haven't looked into their system. Thanks, Joe -- How many years did they support the mechanical aperture linkage even though the cameras and

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread K.Takeshita
On 3/20/06 3:38 PM, K.Takeshita, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Will the new lenses still have the AF drive shaft so that they can be used on older cameras? Nikon Sorry, what I meant is that it depends on the mount contacts. Motorized AF lenses won't have a drive shaft, but driven by the power

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Jens Bladt
: pentax-discuss@pdml.net Emne: Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1? On Mar 20, 2006, at 3:17 PM, jtainter wrote: Even if the new lenses do have the drive shaft, for how long will this be the case? Will Pentax eventually drop the AF drive shaft, just as they dropped the mechanical

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread John Francis
On Mon, Mar 20, 2006 at 03:41:36PM -0500, Aaron Reynolds wrote: On Mar 20, 2006, at 3:17 PM, jtainter wrote: Even if the new lenses do have the drive shaft, for how long will this be the case? Will Pentax eventually drop the AF drive shaft, just as they dropped the mechanical aperture

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Sylwester Pietrzyk
On Mar 20, 2006, at 9:15 PM, John Francis wrote: I doubt if the mechanical linkage would go away; after all, if any new lenses I buy for a new body won't auto-focus on my *ist-D, then there's far less incentive for me to stick with Pentax. I doubt if they leave mechanical linkage. Nikon

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Kostas Kavoussanakis
On Mon, 20 Mar 2006, Adam Maas wrote: The roadmap lists a 16-50 f2.8 DA and a 50-135 f2.8 DA as coming this year. Tokina's also announced identical lenses for other mounts. Modulo SMC ;-) Kostas

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Rob Studdert
On 20 Mar 2006 at 20:50, Sylwester Pietrzyk wrote: Adam, you should try Ltd and FA* lenses then. They usually have focussing rings at least as well damped as the ones in ring-USM driven lenses. Hmm, my LTD lenses feel very under-damped (if damped at all) compared to all of my A primes.

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Sylwester Pietrzyk
On Mar 21, 2006, at 12:51 AM, Rob Studdert wrote: Hmm, my LTD lenses feel very under-damped (if damped at all) compared to all of my A primes. We are comparing Ltds to Nikon's or Canon's lenses with ultrasonic motor and FTM ;-) A, M or K lenses have and will always have the best manual

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Adam Maas
All FA-J lenses lack an aperture ring. There's 3-4 of that type, some really low-end zooms and the 18-35. I'm expecting the Nikon solution. AF-I and AF-S lenses are fully compatible, they just don't AF on a body that lacks the extra contacts necessary (Which means all the early AF bodies

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Shel Belinkoff
I agree, although if pentax made optics of comparable image quality, both with and without motors, that might be a good thing. Shel [Original Message] From: Juan Buhler I hope that doesn't happen. There are a few of us who couldn't care less about auto focus. If I want ultrasonic

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread John Francis
Thanks - I forgot about the FA-Js. I think Pentax have more to lose by introducing lenses that don't auto-focus with old bodies (especially since I doubt if we'll ever see another film body from Pentax). But we'll see - we don't even *know* that the new lenses have USM. On Mon, Mar 20, 2006 at

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-03-20 Thread Adam Maas
I don't think it will be a huge issue as long as the USM lenses are full-on pro lenses for the first few years. The rate of obsolescence and upgrading with DSLR's is such that most of the current bodies will be out of use in 3-4 years. If I were Pentax, I'd bring out the f2.8 zooms first, then

10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-02-25 Thread Colin J
I use the *ist D and like it very much; my only significant complaints about the camera are the APS-C size sensor with only 6 MP. So I was intrigued to learn about the D2, which would give me more pixels. Of course I accept that Pentax will never give me a full frame sensor. ;-) But I was also

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-02-25 Thread Adam Maas
Why? 1. Because you want a bigger buffer than 2 RAW files (Showstopper for me considering the D's 4 RAW files was a limit I bumped into regularly) 2. You want to shoot with fast glass. The f2.8-4 lens isn't fast enough for much of my work (I shoot a lot with a 50 at f2 or f1.8) 3. You need

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-02-25 Thread Aaron Reynolds
On Feb 25, 2006, at 12:48 PM, Colin J wrote: So can someone tell me, why do I need to spend more money on a 10 MP Pentax D2 when I can sell my Pentax *ist D and Sigma 15-30mm and 24-70mm EX lenses on eBay and buy a 10 MP Sony DSC-R1 plus a couple of 1 GB memory sticks with the money? We can't

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-02-25 Thread Boris Liberman
Hi! I use the *ist D and like it very much; my only significant complaints about the camera are the APS-C size sensor with only 6 MP. So I was intrigued to learn about the D2, which would give me more pixels. Of course I accept that Pentax will never give me a full frame sensor. ;-) I'd

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-02-25 Thread Paul Stenquist
On Feb 25, 2006, at 1:07 PM, Boris Liberman wrote: I'd say Pentax might give you and us too the full frame sensor once Pentax decides it is good for Pentax. Which I think will eventually happen, yet Pentax will probably be the last one to adopt Full Frame. I doubt that Pentax will ever go

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-02-25 Thread Mark Roberts
Boris Liberman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'd say Pentax might give you and us too the full frame sensor once Pentax decides it is good for Pentax. Which I think will eventually happen, yet Pentax will probably be the last one to adopt Full Frame. They will go full frame when full frame sensors

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-02-25 Thread K.Takeshita
On 2/25/06 1:17 PM, Paul Stenquist, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I doubt that Pentax will ever go full frame. The continued development of DA lenses seems to suggest that APS-C will be the largest sensor unless you go medium format. I'm not complaining. I'm good with that, and expect that

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-02-25 Thread Godfrey DiGiorgi
Colin, I own the Sony R1 now in addition to my Pentax DSLR kit. This question will likely set off Yet Another PDML Flame War but, frankly, I don't give a damn about that. I'll expand on my previous comments from more first hand experience with the camera. - For me, the buffer issue isn't

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-02-25 Thread Colin J
@pdml.net Subject: Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1? Message-Id: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Content-Type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII; delsp=yes; format=flowed Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Colin, I own the Sony R1 now in addition to my Pentax DSLR kit. This question will likely

Re: 10 MP Pentax D2 versus 10 MP Sony DCS-R1?

2006-02-25 Thread Cotty
On 25/2/06, Colin J, discombobulated, unleashed: It seems to me that the bridge or ZLR camera has finally come of age. No sensor cleaning or dust problems. No time wasted changing lenses. You are the perfect ZLR buyer, you should go buy one. Cheers, Cotty ___/\__ || (O) | People,