Re: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up

2009-07-22 Thread P. J. Alling
William Robb wrote: - Original Message - From: Bob W Subject: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/art/news/shot-down--capas-cl assic-image-of-war-1754405.html One wonders if he would have been a famous

Re: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up

2009-07-22 Thread Ken Waller
Kenneth Waller http://www.tinyurl.com/272u2f - Original Message - From: William Robb war...@gmail.com Subject: Re: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up - Original Message - From: Bob W Subject: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up

Re: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up

2009-07-22 Thread William Robb
- Original Message - From: Ken Waller Subject: Re: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up One wonders if he would have been a famous photographer if he hadn't staged that picture. Obviously, his work should speak for itself. I guess the question would he

Re: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up

2009-07-22 Thread William Robb
- Original Message - From: P. J. Alling Subject: Re: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up One wonders if he would have been a famous photographer if he hadn't staged that picture. William Robb It's hard to know. It's also hard to know if he actually staged

Re: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up

2009-07-22 Thread P. J. Alling
William Robb wrote: - Original Message - From: P. J. Alling Subject: Re: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up One wonders if he would have been a famous photographer if he hadn't staged that picture. William Robb It's hard to know. It's also hard to know if he

RE: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up

2009-07-22 Thread Bob W
One wonders if he would have been a famous photographer if he hadn't staged that picture. Obviously, his work should speak for itself. I guess the question would he have polevaulted into being a famous war photographer without that particular image. I suppose it's possible

Re: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up

2009-07-22 Thread William Robb
- Original Message - From: P. J. Alling Subject: Re: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up It looked to me from the article that they had found the exact spot (within a few yards anyway), and that said spot was several miles from the actual fighting. At least

Re: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up

2009-07-22 Thread P. J. Alling
William Robb wrote: - Original Message - From: P. J. Alling Subject: Re: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up It looked to me from the article that they had found the exact spot (within a few yards anyway), and that said spot was several miles from the actual

A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up

2009-07-21 Thread Bob W
http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/art/news/shot-down--capas-cl assic-image-of-war-1754405.html Bob -- PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List PDML@pdml.net http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow the

Re: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up

2009-07-21 Thread Jaume Lahuerta
: Pentax-Discuss Mail List pdml@pdml.net Enviado: martes, 21 de julio, 2009 10:51:26 Asunto: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/art/news/shot-down--capas-cl assic-image-of-war-1754405.html Bob -- PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail

Re: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up

2009-07-21 Thread William Robb
- Original Message - From: Bob W Subject: A new claim that Capa's falling soldier was a set-up http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/art/news/shot-down--capas-cl assic-image-of-war-1754405.html One wonders if he would have been a famous photographer if he hadn't