Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-10 Thread Boris Liberman
Hi! You donate but then you do not expect anything in return... Rac Tsadaka... If I am not mistaken there Judaic law has very specific rules about that. For instance, one has to give to charity at least a very certain part of their income... Boris P.S. Tsadaka in Hebrew means Charity which

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-10 Thread Boris Liberman
Hi! g Yes, I know many people who have a giving mentality. Quite a few of those are g jews. And yes there are those with a give-me mentality, even to the point they g are taking from the needy. Unfortunately, I know some of those also. The best g kind of people, to my mind, are the ones who give

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-10 Thread John Mustarde
On Tue, 9 Mar 2004 22:09:44 -0500, you wrote: We all have our egos and our outspoken moments, but I think personal attacks are out of place here. Paul Yep, you're right, no need to get personal, I apologize, to Shel, and to and anyone who may have taken offense. I was responding to perceived

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread John Mustarde
On Mon, 08 Mar 2004 20:50:01 -0800, you wrote: ... for a while. I was reluctant to make this photo, as just clicking away at some guy sitting there in despair is kind of a cheap shot, but I saw a context, making him smaller in the scene, shooting contre jour purtting him in shadow, with all the

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread Shel Belinkoff
Spoken like a true Texan ... John Mustarde wrote: http://home.earthlink.net/~scbelinkoff/images/handh.html It brings forth my aversion impulse, if that means anything. I've often wondered why people don't get arrested for theft of the shopping carts... those things cost more than a good

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread William Robb
- Original Message - From: Shel Belinkoff Subject: Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco Spoken like a true Texan ... When every time one of those carts walks off your parking lot you take a $700.00 or so loss, it makes you sit up and pay attention. Would you be happy to have

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread Shel Belinkoff
Y'know, it doesn't bother me a bit ... and it seems to be OK with quite a number of people here, too. Rarely, if ever, do the police bother these poor, unfortunate people, and I have never seen one hassled because they have a cart. Maybe there's just a different sensibility towards this issue

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread mike wilson
Hi, graywolf wrote: Yes we should lock them up. The US already has more people per capita locked up than any other civilized nation in the world. About 1/2 of them not guilty of the crime they were convicted of. My own benefits, Social Security and Assistance, come out to about $10,000 a

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread Boris Liberman
Hi! Tom, Shel, et al, my observation even at my young age is that with time tolerance levels seem to drop. At least so it seems where I am. Tel Aviv second is getting shorter and shorter... In Israel there are huge many people who live beneath minimal level of income set by the state.

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread Shel Belinkoff
Yes, I've seen that here, too ... ;-(( Malcolm Smith wrote: My local Waitrose supermarket has had to put long poles with flags on the little kiddie sized trolleys they have. Is it so that the children can be easily seen in the stores, by the adults shopping? No, it's because before they put

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread Shel Belinkoff
Unfortunately, the American penal system (actually, the penal system of the states, there is no American penal system unless you count Federal prisons) doesn't dole out anything like you've described. mike wilson wrote: If the US penal system is anything like the UK's that will entitle them

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread Shel Belinkoff
It is a long standing Jewish tradition to give and not ask for or expect anything in return. I have to chuckle when a number of my friends rush to make year end contributions of junk and cheap food (food that THEY wouldn't eat) in order to garner tax deductions. Yet the rest of the year they are

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread Shel Belinkoff
Hi Boris, You've got the general neighborhood right ... I think people dislike the homeless and the poor because many are just a few steps away from joining them on life's sidewalk. Or, maybe because these unfortunate people get in the way at times, pose an eyesore to the lovely, tree lined

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread mike wilson
It's a bit of a bone of contention here that those seen to be least deserving (criminals) seem to get the best free medical treatment, whereas those who really need it (homeless) often are the ones who find it hardest. Shel Belinkoff wrote: Unfortunately, the American penal system (actually,

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread graywolf
Well, unfortunately you can not talk about the US Penal System. It depends a lot on the state. Ranges from federal system country clubs for naughty US Senators (those are the places the news media like to show), to chain gang camps in the south. It used to be claimed that the cheapest way to

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread graywolf
Yes, I know many people who have a giving mentality. Quite a few of those are jews. And yes there are those with a give-me mentality, even to the point they are taking from the needy. Unfortunately, I know some of those also. The best kind of people, to my mind, are the ones who give to those

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread John Forbes
Well said. John On Tue, 09 Mar 2004 15:44:38 -0500, graywolf [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Well, unfortunately you can not talk about the US Penal System. It depends a lot on the state. Ranges from federal system country clubs for naughty US Senators (those are the places the news media like to

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread John Forbes
They are often the same people at different stages in the process. John On Tue, 09 Mar 2004 20:39:39 +, mike wilson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: It's a bit of a bone of contention here that those seen to be least deserving (criminals) seem to get the best free medical treatment, whereas those

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread Rfsindg
Graywolf writes: snip I've always have wondered about the intolerance toward the poor that many have. snip But in fact many of the poor work very, very hard. I have known families where the old man works two full time hard-labor jobs, and the old lady works full time as well just to

RE: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread frank theriault
this is the best of all possible worlds. The pessimist fears it is true. -J. Robert Oppenheimer From: Shel Belinkoff [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: PDML [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: PAW: Last one from San Francisco Date: Mon, 08 Mar 2004 20:50:01 -0800 ... for a while. I

Re: Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread Rfsindg
Boris Liberman writes: You donate but then you do not expect anything in return... Tsadaka...

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread frank theriault
yeah, That's what that guy needs. Arrest him. That way he can go to jail (because he won't have money to pay a fine), and have the crap beat out of him. Or, because he has mental/emotional problems, he'll start a fight in jail, and get further charged, and spend even more time there. And,

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread Shel Belinkoff
Well, it's nice to know you've made a contribution to society, John. That's admirable. As for your comments about me ... well, you're entitled to believe what you will. But maybe I should tell you that for a while I was homeless, slept in my car, sometimes stayed with a friend for a night or

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread Brian Dipert
Is it just me, or is anyone else struck by the irony that coincident with the discussions about the destitute population in San Francisco and elsewhere in the world, there's a parallel discussion thread going at PDLM on 'What gear is on your lust list'? Try imagining, sometime, how you might

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread Keith Whaley
Nicely put, Shel. Appropriate, too, truth be known. I have a brother-in-law who had to /chose to/ live that way, once upon a time, when he was attending undergraduate college in Santa Cruz. Did he have to? Who knows. He certainly did, I do know that. I _can_ tell you, unless you've lived that

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread William Robb
- Original Message - From: Brian Dipert Subject: Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco Is it just me, or is anyone else struck by the irony that coincident with the discussions about the destitute population in San Francisco and elsewhere in the world, there's a parallel discussion

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread Rfsindg
John, Thanks for your post. I've been thinking about why I'm uncomfortable with the homeless. I'm not looking down on them, and I'm not disdainful of their poverty or situation. What makes facing these people difficult is seeing them in a life situation that is not good, but also knowing

Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-09 Thread frank theriault
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: PAW: Last one from San Francisco Date: Tue, 09 Mar 2004 16:54:49 -0800 Hi Frank ... I've no compunctions about photographing street people (how I dislike that term), but it's gotta be done a certain way. Usually I've

PAW: Last one from San Francisco

2004-03-08 Thread Shel Belinkoff
... for a while. I was reluctant to make this photo, as just clicking away at some guy sitting there in despair is kind of a cheap shot, but I saw a context, making him smaller in the scene, shooting contre jour purtting him in shadow, with all the people walking away from him, and the skinny