Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread Bronek Kozicki
Digital Image Studio wrote: On 03/01/07, Bronek Kozicki [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Digital Image Studio wrote: factor relative to FF 35mm ;-) keyword underscored. ...and? full frame is not a format name. It can be used as a format name only if supplemented by

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread mike wilson
From: Christian [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: 2007/01/02 Tue PM 10:22:44 GMT To: Pentax-Discuss Mail List pdml@pdml.net Subject: Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D Peter Fairweather wrote: Instead of being cruel about Ken Rockwell, try reading his work

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread Digital Image Studio
On 03/01/07, Bronek Kozicki [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: full frame is not a format name. It can be used as a format name only if supplemented by information which frame ? In citation above it is 35mm, or 135, and the crop factor is relative to full frame of 135 format. It annoys me that you

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread David Savage
On 1/3/07, mike wilson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: Christian [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: 2007/01/02 Tue PM 10:22:44 GMT To: Pentax-Discuss Mail List pdml@pdml.net Subject: Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D Peter Fairweather wrote: Instead of being

RE: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread J. C. O'Connell
Of Bronek Kozicki Sent: Wednesday, January 03, 2007 5:02 AM To: Pentax-Discuss Mail List Subject: Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D Digital Image Studio wrote: On 03/01/07, Bronek Kozicki [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Digital Image Studio wrote: factor relative to FF

RE: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread Bronek Kozicki
24x36mm, 35mm, 135 format, format frame. jco -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Bronek Kozicki Sent: Wednesday, January 03, 2007 5:02 AM To: Pentax-Discuss Mail List Subject: Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread David Savage
Your just arguing nomenclature. The majority of people on this list can't afford the current MF/LF digital bodies/backs, without selling their soul organs. So when someone refers to full frame digital, it's generally understood that they're talking 35mm full frame. Cheers, Dave On 1/3/07,

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread William Robb
- Original Message - From: mike wilson Subject: Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D He links to this http://www.pbase.com/bret/image/71055999 from his site http://www.kenrockwell.com/gallery.htm I can't work out whether he knows it is a joke at his

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread William Robb
- Original Message - From: Bronek Kozicki Subject: Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D full frame is not a format name. I've always wondered what the crop factor was on my Pentax 6x7. Does anyone know what full frame is on 120? Note, I am not trying

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread William Robb
- Original Message - From: David Savage Subject: Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D Your just arguing nomenclature. He's not the only person on list who argues nomenclature. I'd even hazzard a guess, without looking into my filtered emails, that I

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread P. J. Alling
Well, he certainly has an eye for color. mike wilson wrote: From: Christian [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: 2007/01/02 Tue PM 10:22:44 GMT To: Pentax-Discuss Mail List pdml@pdml.net Subject: Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D Peter Fairweather wrote: Instead

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread P. J. Alling
frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D Peter Fairweather wrote: Instead of being cruel about Ken Rockwell, try reading his work. Nowhere also has the basic spec of the new Canon 7d. Not only can he review cameras he hasn't used, he can even do this for cameras which

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread Tom C
Let's not fight over words. Tom C. From: Bronek Kozicki [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: Pentax-Discuss Mail List pdml@pdml.net To: Pentax-Discuss Mail List pdml@pdml.net Subject: Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D Date: Wed, 03 Jan 2007 10:01:50 + Digital

RE: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread J. C. O'Connell
120 is a film size, not a format. jco -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of William Robb Sent: Wednesday, January 03, 2007 11:06 AM To: Pentax-Discuss Mail List Subject: Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread Bronek Kozicki
Quoting William Robb [EMAIL PROTECTED]: - Original Message - From: David Savage Subject: Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D Your just arguing nomenclature. He's not the only person on list who argues nomenclature. I'd even hazzard a guess, without

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread P. J. Alling
Full frame would be Kodaks original format. would be 2 1/4 x 3 1/2 inches. They invented it. William Robb wrote: - Original Message - From: Bronek Kozicki Subject: Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D full frame is not a format name

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread Mark Roberts
William Robb wrote: I'd even hazzard a guess, without looking into my filtered emails, that I know who he is arguing with.. Har! (Just looked at the unread count in my own Deleted bin...) -- PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List PDML@pdml.net http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread Adam Maas
professional help). mike wilson wrote: From: Christian [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: 2007/01/02 Tue PM 10:22:44 GMT To: Pentax-Discuss Mail List pdml@pdml.net Subject: Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D Peter Fairweather wrote: Instead of being cruel about Ken

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread Cotty
On 3/1/07, William Robb, discombobulated, unleashed: Note, I am not trying to add anything useful to this discourse. Mark. -- Cheers, Cotty ___/\__ || (O) | People, Places, Pastiche ||=|http://www.cottysnaps.com _ -- PDML Pentax-Discuss

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread Mark Roberts
Cotty wrote: On 3/1/07, William Robb, discombobulated, unleashed: Note, I am not trying to add anything useful to this discourse. Mark. From the 2005 quotations list: This comment is not designed to add useful discourse. - William Robb -- PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List PDML@pdml.net

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread Tom C
On 3/1/07, William Robb, discombobulated, unleashed: Note, I am not trying to add anything useful to this discourse. Mark. From the 2005 quotations list: This comment is not designed to add useful discourse. - William Robb It appears to be a bit of a habit. ;-) Tom C. -- PDML

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread Cotty
On 3/1/07, Mark Roberts, discombobulated, unleashed: From the 2005 quotations list: This comment is not designed to add useful discourse. - William Robb Smartass ;-) -- Cheers, Cotty ___/\__ || (O) | People, Places, Pastiche ||=|http://www.cottysnaps.com

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread Tom C
This page intentionally left blank Tom C. From: Cotty [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: Pentax-Discuss Mail List pdml@pdml.net To: pentax list PDML@pdml.net Subject: Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread Mark Roberts
Cotty wrote: On 3/1/07, Mark Roberts, discombobulated, unleashed: From the 2005 quotations list: This comment is not designed to add useful discourse. - William Robb Smartass ;-) Isn't he, though? -- PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List PDML@pdml.net

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-03 Thread Cotty
This comment is not designed to add useful discourse. - William Robb Smartass ;-) Isn't he, though? rimshot -- Cheers, Cotty ___/\__ || (O) | People, Places, Pastiche ||=|http://www.cottysnaps.com _ -- PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Digital Image Studio
On 03/01/07, William Robb [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: This arrived in my inbox. I think it was meant to go to the list - Original Message - From: Bronek Kozicki [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D Quoting William Robb [EMAIL

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread David Savage
On 1/2/07, William Robb [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: This arrived in my inbox. I think it was meant to go to the list - Original Message - From: Bronek Kozicki [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D has anyone seen full frame camera

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Bronek Kozicki
Quoting David Savage [EMAIL PROTECTED]: On 1/2/07, William Robb [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I've got some samples I took in store with a Canon 5D and EF 17-40mm f4 L lens. At 17mm 40mm there is vignetting, but it's easily treatable in the RAW converter. I think this says more about the lens

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Bronek Kozicki
Quoting Digital Image Studio [EMAIL PROTECTED]: B obviously hasn't looked at too many big Canon or Leica M8 produced images. http://www.pbase.com/cameras/canon/eos_5d (only currently 281942 sample images) and how many from wide lenses ? B. -- PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List PDML@pdml.net

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Bronek Kozicki
Quoting Digital Image Studio [EMAIL PROTECTED]: B obviously hasn't looked at too many big Canon or Leica M8 produced images. Leica M8 is croppped, although not APS. B. -- PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List PDML@pdml.net http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread David Savage
On 1/2/07, Bronek Kozicki [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Quoting David Savage [EMAIL PROTECTED]: On 1/2/07, William Robb [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I've got some samples I took in store with a Canon 5D and EF 17-40mm f4 L lens. At 17mm 40mm there is vignetting, but it's easily treatable in the

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Digital Image Studio
On 03/01/07, Bronek Kozicki [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Quoting Digital Image Studio [EMAIL PROTECTED]: B obviously hasn't looked at too many big Canon or Leica M8 produced images. http://www.pbase.com/cameras/canon/eos_5d (only currently 281942 sample images) and how many from wide

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread David Savage
On 1/3/07, Digital Image Studio [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On 03/01/07, Bronek Kozicki [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Quoting Digital Image Studio [EMAIL PROTECTED]: B obviously hasn't looked at too many big Canon or Leica M8 produced images. http://www.pbase.com/cameras/canon/eos_5d (only

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Bronek Kozicki
Quoting David Savage [EMAIL PROTECTED]: So I take it your not a fan aft the 35mm full frame DSLR concept. I am not. Or maybe this whole Canon propaganda just started p**ng me off. I came from 6x7 (Pentacon Six) and see nothing special in 135 format, except maybe balance of speed and quality for

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread P. J. Alling
Hell, many Canon WA lenses, (all WA lenses on 35mm to some extent, but Canon has some of the worst, and most expensive), were problematic on film as far as vignetting was concerned. Why would they be better on Digital? I think that Leica partly picked the 1.3x crop Kodak sensor so their

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread K.Takeshita
I am fond of APS-C but not despising FF. I am just satisfied with the current performance and compactness of gears of APS-C DSLR. And of course I have no intention whatsoever to bring out some $3,000 for essentially nothing more than just a camera. This might change if and when the

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread P. J. Alling
Listen to the new guy lecturing us. Interesting but we've been over this umpteen thousand times. Most of what you're saying is known to even the most technically obtuse on this list. Very good 35mm lenses work well on the Canon FF digital cameras. This is testified to by the number of

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Bronek Kozicki
P. J. Alling wrote: Your arguments are known. Your conclusions are suspect, and your mother dresses you funny. she does not ;-P and I'm not going to argue with you other points, as they might be true indeed. The fact is I'm just losing patience seeing discussion that could end up like

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Adam Maas
Bronek Kozicki wrote: Quoting Digital Image Studio [EMAIL PROTECTED]: B obviously hasn't looked at too many big Canon or Leica M8 produced images. Leica M8 is croppped, although not APS. B. Close to APS-H actually. About as close to that as DX format is to APS-C. -Adam -- PDML

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread P. J. Alling
That's not true, the Kodak chip is the same ratio as APS-C ~ 35mm ~ 6x9cm (2:3). APS-H (16:9) isn't even close. Geeze these numbers are published everywhere. Adam Maas wrote: Bronek Kozicki wrote: Quoting Digital Image Studio [EMAIL PROTECTED]: B obviously hasn't looked at too

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Digital Image Studio
On 03/01/07, K.Takeshita [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: What they call blind test is rampant. They exhibit images taken by various cameras including 5D (usually more than 5 images taken by different cameras) and see if anyone can tell the difference. This of course is more for an entertainment

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Adam Maas
Yes, but the size is similar. -Adam P. J. Alling wrote: That's not true, the Kodak chip is the same ratio as APS-C ~ 35mm ~ 6x9cm (2:3). APS-H (16:9) isn't even close. Geeze these numbers are published everywhere. Adam Maas wrote: Bronek Kozicki wrote: Quoting Digital Image

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Digital Image Studio
On 03/01/07, Bronek Kozicki [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: she does not ;-P and I'm not going to argue with you other points, as they might be true indeed. The fact is I'm just losing patience seeing discussion that could end up like whinning when Pentax will finally release full frame camera?!.

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread P. J. Alling
Width maybe, but height is, (well at the sizes we're considering), much greater in the Kodak chip than in APS-H format. Adam Maas wrote: Yes, but the size is similar. -Adam P. J. Alling wrote: That's not true, the Kodak chip is the same ratio as APS-C ~ 35mm ~ 6x9cm (2:3). APS-H

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Bronek Kozicki
Digital Image Studio wrote: factor relative to FF 35mm ;-) keyword underscored. B. -- PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List PDML@pdml.net http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Digital Image Studio
On 03/01/07, Bronek Kozicki [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Digital Image Studio wrote: factor relative to FF 35mm ;-) keyword underscored. ...and? -- Rob Studdert HURSTVILLE AUSTRALIA Tel +61-2-9554-4110 UTC(GMT) +10 Hours [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Peter Fairweather
Instead of being cruel about Ken Rockwell, try reading his work. Nowhere also has the basic spec of the new Canon 7d. Not only can he review cameras he hasn't used, he can even do this for cameras which don't yet exist. 24 meg sensor, 3.1 frames per second continuous he informs us. What a guy!!

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Christian
Peter Fairweather wrote: Instead of being cruel about Ken Rockwell, try reading his work. Nowhere also has the basic spec of the new Canon 7d. Not only can he review cameras he hasn't used, he can even do this for cameras which don't yet exist. 24 meg sensor, 3.1 frames per second continuous

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread P. J. Alling
I don't have to be cruel to or about Ken Rockwell, he has himself for that. Peter Fairweather wrote: Instead of being cruel about Ken Rockwell, try reading his work. Nowhere also has the basic spec of the new Canon 7d. Not only can he review cameras he hasn't used, he can even do this for

RE: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Bob W
-Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Peter Fairweather Sent: 02 January 2007 22:04 To: Pentax-Discuss Mail List Subject: Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D Instead of being cruel about Ken Rockwell

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Digital Image Studio
On 03/01/07, Bob W [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I've always thought of him as a kind of super-charged version of Ace Smoke me a kipper, I'll be home for breakfast! Rimmer, with bigger balls and a better tan. That's ridiculously complimentary... for Ken ;-) -- Rob Studdert HURSTVILLE AUSTRALIA

Re: Fw: Full frame vs APS-C was: Re: PESO - Hertzlia Marina vs K10D

2007-01-02 Thread Scott Loveless
On 1/2/07, Peter Fairweather [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Instead of being cruel about Ken Rockwell, try reading his work. Nowhere also has the basic spec of the new Canon 7d. Not only can he review cameras he hasn't used, he can even do this for cameras which don't yet exist. 24 meg sensor, 3.1