Re: Re: Re: A reply to Ellen Meiksins Wood

2001-05-24 Thread Stephen E Philion
On Thu, 24 May 2001, Doug Henwood wrote: Yoshie Furuhashi wrote: Ricardo is implying that if you are born rich in the Third World, you are of necessity forever trapped in the aristocratic ideology of enjoying leisure dependence upon servants, moreover endorsing the social relations that

Re: Re: Re: Ellen Meiksins Woody Allen

2001-05-24 Thread Stephen E Philion
Well no, but since you characterize Wood's students in such a sneering fashion, I was just wondering if you characterize Comninel in that fashion. After all, he was Wood's student and had a good working relationship with her. Steve On Thu, 24 May 2001, Louis Proyect wrote: I dunno, I seem to

Petras on WST, Dependency Theory

2001-05-23 Thread Stephen E Philion
From James Petras and Kent Trachte, Liberal, Structural and Radical Approaches to Political Economy, in Petras, *Critical Perspectives on Imperialism and Social Classes in the Third World*, To conceptualize the issues of the Third World in terms of dependency or as part of a world system is to

Re: forwarded from Ellen Wood Regarding her ATC article

2001-05-21 Thread Stephen E Philion
Michael, Thanks for forwarding that note. It clarifies quite a bit in light of some of the nastier accusations made against Wood, which don't seem to based on much in the way of facts. Hopefully the discussion of Wood's article will return to Wood's article and not the person. Steve On Mon, 21