Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: DefendingChina'sRighttoSelf-Determination (fwd)

2000-05-26 Thread Michael Perelman
Brad, are you suggesting that it is only the pull of the city, and not push of people being dispossessed from the farms? Brad De Long wrote: Mine, I do not disagree that the wages suck. But, are they better than what those workers got on the ejidos? The voting-with-the-feet

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Frankfurters,fascism and ecology (fwd)

2000-05-26 Thread md7148
Around the mid 1920s, with the increasing presence of Nazi political activism, Jews were substantially prohibited from participating in economic, social and political activities such as investing, teaching, working, forming associations and other citizenhip entitlements. Nazis came to power

China -WTO --USA = capital against the workers

2000-05-26 Thread neil
friends; Jim devine quotes the LA Times , W. Greider, etc. Greider has taken leave of his wits as he sows more illusions that the Democrats are/were ever any kind of Party of Labor. The fact that the AF of Hell unions support the DP religiously only helps to show they are as tied to the laws

Re: [PEN-L:100] microsoft

2000-05-26 Thread r-j-k harper
michael wrote: I have posted a copy of Nathan's Microsoft Monitor, because his was rejected. Marx said that concentration of capital would make the transition to socialism easier. The state would have an easier time taking over the few supermarket chains than the motley collection of

Re: [PEN-L:188] RE: pen-l format: removing the prefix from the subjec t line

2000-05-26 Thread Ryan P. Reid
If I remember correctly, the original request was to remove just the message number rather than the whole header. It would seem to be helpful if "[PEN-L]" were prefixed to the subject line without the message number. This would provide an easy method of identifying messages from the list while

Re: Re: Re: Re: Dialectical materialism and ecology

2000-05-26 Thread Chris Burford
At 08:44 25/05/00 -0700, Jim D wrote: I don't want to get into quote-mongering (or to rehearsing old debates from Marxism-thaxis -- BTW, what in 'ell is "thaxis"?) Marxism-thaxis is one of the life forms in virtual marxism-space, which had its own evolutionary history, birth, childhood,

Re: Frankfurters, fascism and ecology

2000-05-26 Thread Dennis R Redmond
On Thu, 25 May 2000, Louis Proyect wrote: Jay points out that the Frankfurters reject the notion that class conflict is the locomotive of history, a basic Marxist theory. Nonsense. Walter Benjamin once wrote that the Revolution is really the emergency handbrake on Progress. The greatness of

Henry Wallace

2000-05-26 Thread Michael Keaney
K Content-type: text/plain; charset="US-ASCII" Content-transfer-encoding: 7bit on 25/5/00 10:39 pm, Nathan Newman at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I just don't see what is gained by the campaign. Third party folks make so many wondrous claims for such third party efforts, yet historically

Re: Henry Wallace

2000-05-26 Thread Michael Hoover
on 25/5/00 10:39 pm, Nathan Newman at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Third party folks make so many wondrous claims for such third party efforts, yet historically Lafayette in 1924 delivered the reactionary era of Coolidge; Wallace the Cold War and McCarthyism; and we can go on. The Cold War

Trespassing in Cyberspace: Corporations Seek Control

2000-05-26 Thread Nathan Newman
I rank this case up as one of the top cases likely to shape property rights in the new Net economy. The judge in the case declared even publicly available web sites to be private property from which any person can be excluded based on "trespass" law. In this case, the goal is to exclude

Gore or Dubya?

2000-05-26 Thread Rob Schaap
Like Michael P., I shudder at the thought of dubya. My speculation from over here, where we too have seen our socdems do all the things to us that a conservative government would find much harder to do, is that the bush baby would indeed be a disaster. Like ol' Raygun, the bloke is too dense

Re: Gore or Dubya?

2000-05-26 Thread Louis Proyect
I know it ain't pretty reading on either side of the ledger, but is it really conceivable Gore would be quite as horrific a prospect? Just wondering - he'll effectively be our president, too, after all. Cheers, Rob. Society is divided into classes. The state is the executive committee of the

Re: Re: Gore or Dubya?

2000-05-26 Thread Rob Schaap
Reckon you're making this out to be a little simpler than it is, Lou! The ruling class need not be particularly united on a host of particular policy issues (China's gonna present 'em with some pretty divisive stimuli, I reckon), there are often different ways to do someone's bidding (allocating

Re: Re: Frankfurters, fascism and ecology

2000-05-26 Thread Doug Henwood
Dennis R Redmond wrote: Nonsense. Walter Benjamin once wrote that the Revolution is really the emergency handbrake on Progress. The greatness of the Frankfurt School is that they insist that the objective tide of history is catastrophic, an outrageous violence done to vulnerable bodies, and that

Re: Re: Re: Gore or Dubya?

2000-05-26 Thread Louis Proyect
Rob wrote: Reckon you're making this out to be a little simpler than it is, Lou! The ruling class need not be particularly united on a host of particular policy issues (China's gonna present 'em with some pretty divisive stimuli, I reckon), there are often different ways to do someone's bidding

Re: Gore or Dubya?

2000-05-26 Thread Carrol Cox
Louis Proyect wrote: there's the little matter of the superstructure sometimes preponderating in shaping particular events (as per that famous Bloch letter). Of course there are divisions in the ruling class. . . . Also there is the matter of distinguishing the superstructure (however

from Marx to Brezhnev: Fetishizing American democraticforms

2000-05-26 Thread Charles Brown
"J. Barkley Rosser, Jr." [EMAIL PROTECTED] 05/23/00 06:04PM Charles, Thanks for the response. Clearly we disagree on the nature of democracy. I do think it involves voting with at least more than one candidate. I also think that it should involve some degree of tolerance for dissent,

Re: Re: Re: Marx's life and theory

2000-05-26 Thread Ted Winslow
Louis Proyect wrote: Leibniz and Whitehead are key to Harvey (while obviously having nothing to do with Marx) It's not obvious to me. Leibniz is part of the German idealist tradition sublated by Marx. The dialectical relation of "sublation" is not a relation of identity. That Whitehead's

Re: Re: Gore or Dubya?

2000-05-26 Thread Doug Henwood
Carrol Cox wrote: Also there is the matter of distinguishing the superstructure (however you define that slippery term) from bird shit on the rooftop -- which is more or less what Gore and Bush represent. The most apparent difference between Kennedy and Nixon was that the former preferred haute

Re: Marx's life and theory

2000-05-26 Thread Louis Proyect
Whitehead: "When we think of freedom, we are apt to confine ourselves to freedom of thought, freedom of the press, freedom for religious opinions. Then the limitations to freedom are conceived as wholly arising from the antagonisms of our fellow men. This is a thorough mistake. The massive

Krugman Watch: Workers vs. Workers

2000-05-26 Thread Jim Devine
It's scary when a columnist who practices an anti-working class form of economics writes a column for the most prestigious capitalist newspaper in the US (if not the world) preaching to workers that the only organizations they have -- the trade-unions -- are working against the workers' own

Re: Henry Wallace

2000-05-26 Thread Charles Brown
Michael Hoover [EMAIL PROTECTED] 05/26/00 08:32AM As for 1948, 'first shot' of domestic Cold War was fired by Dems/FDR dropped Wallace as VP in favor of Truman in '44. And Truman would remove Wallace as Commerce Secretary in '46 (and initiate loyalty oaths and Smith Act investigations in

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Dialectical materialism and ecology

2000-05-26 Thread Jim Devine
At 08:05 AM 05/26/2000 +0100, you wrote: At 08:44 25/05/00 -0700, Jim D wrote: I don't want to get into quote-mongering (or to rehearsing old debates from Marxism-thaxis -- BTW, what in 'ell is "thaxis"?) Marxism-thaxis is one of the life forms in virtual marxism-space, which had its own

Re: [[Fwd: [CrashList-talk] re: FT: Israel completes along goodbye]] (fwd)] (fwd)

2000-05-26 Thread md7148
I got it. I was not strongly aware of those divisions before. Thanks for the clarification.. revolutionary greetings! Mine Dear Mine! Actually the Amal movement was formed back during the Lebanese Civil War and is totally independent of Hizb Allah. In fact there are areas in South Lebanon

Dialectical materialism andecology

2000-05-26 Thread Charles Brown
Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] 05/26/00 01:46PM At 08:05 AM 05/26/2000 +0100, you wrote: At 08:44 25/05/00 -0700, Jim D wrote: I don't want to get into quote-mongering (or to rehearsing old debates from Marxism-thaxis -- BTW, what in 'ell is "thaxis"?) Marxism-thaxis is one of the life forms

Re: Re: Marx's life and theory

2000-05-26 Thread Ted Winslow
Louis writes: This sounds like Malthus to me, not Marx. This must be the same hearing problem that led you mistakenly to attribute to Whitehead the Leibnizian theory of the 'best of possible worlds'. "the Malthusian Law, with its sociological consequences, is not an iron necessity. ...

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Dialectical materialism and ecology

2000-05-26 Thread Doug Henwood
Jim Devine wrote: but what is "thaxis"? I know what "praxis" is. Theory + practice = thaxis. No relation to Thurn und Thaxis, or whatever that thing from Pynchon's Lot 49 is. Doug

Re: Gore or Dubya? (fwd)

2000-05-26 Thread md7148
the case. Essentially, the "lesser evil" strategy which helped to facilitate Hitler's rise to power became central to the reformist left. Of course, all of this is immaterial to non-Marxists. Louis Proyect Very true. Actually, if one looks at the party politics of the pre-nazi germany, one

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Defending China's RighttoSelf-Determination (fwd)

2000-05-26 Thread J. Barkley Rosser, Jr.
Mine, So, did these increased jobs replace lost ones in the US? That is the issue. Are you unhappy that this employment has increased in and of itself? These jobs may not be great, but are they not better than the alternatives available to these people in Mexico? Actually the textile

RE: Krugman Watch: Workers vs. Workers

2000-05-26 Thread Max Sawicky
JD: . . . The health care example seems totally off the agenda at present, while the earned income credit (unlike classic income-support measures) make workers more dependent on their employers' good wishes, i.e., hardly helps their bargaining power. . . . What in the world does this mean?

RE: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Dialectical materialism and ecology

2000-05-26 Thread Max Sawicky
Jim Devine wrote: but what is "thaxis"? I know what "praxis" is. Theory + practice = thaxis. No relation to Thurn und Thaxis, or whatever that thing from Pynchon's Lot 49 is. Doug I thought it went back to the old saying, the only certain things are debt and thaxis. Or something like that.

Re: RE: Krugman Watch: Workers vs. Workers

2000-05-26 Thread Doug Henwood
Max Sawicky wrote: What in the world does this mean? How does the EITC make a worker any more dependent on an employer (who else can you work for?) than a wage increase? You only get the EITC if you have a job, so it doesn't reduce the cost of job loss. Wasn't the political point of the EITC

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Defending China'sRighttoSelf-Determination (fwd)

2000-05-26 Thread md7148
I don't disagree about the US part of your post. but my post was about Mexico and the impacts of US-Mexico free trade liberalization on Apparel Industry and labor composition of maquiladoras.. Regarding employment, number seems to increase (as the increasing number of employed workers show), but

RE: Re: RE: Krugman Watch: Workers vs. Workers

2000-05-26 Thread Max Sawicky
Max Sawicky wrote: What in the world does this mean? How does the EITC make a worker any more dependent on an employer (who else can you work for?) than a wage increase? You only get the EITC if you have a job, so it doesn't reduce the cost of job loss. Wasn't the political point of the EITC

Re: Marx's life and theory

2000-05-26 Thread Louis Proyect
Whitehead: "Nature is plastic, although to every prevalent state of mind there corresponds iron nature setting its bounds to life. Modern history begins when Europeans passed into a new phase of understanding which enabled them to introduce new selective agencies, unguessed by the older

China 'Short-term pain, long-term gain'

2000-05-26 Thread Stephen E Philion
SCMP Friday, May 26, 2000 PNTR VOTE 'Short-term pain, long-term gain' WILLIAM KAZER in Shanghai While Beijing has applauded its likely entry into the World Trade Organisation (WTO), joining the global body could contribute to slower economic growth, more job losses and a weaker trade

Re: Re: Marx's life and theory

2000-05-26 Thread Ted Winslow
Louis writes: This sounds like Will and Ariel Durant. This sounds like Louis Proyect. Ted -- Ted WinslowE-MAIL: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Division of Social Science VOICE: (416) 736-5054 York UniversityFAX: (416) 736-5615 4700 Keele

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Defending China'sRighttoSelf-Determination (fwd)

2000-05-26 Thread J. Barkley Rosser, Jr.
Mine, I do not disagree that the wages suck. But, are they better than what those workers got on the ejidos? Your post was in response to mine noting that the forecast of various folks that NAFTA would lead to job losses in the US was wrong. I am not going to defend all aspects of NAFTA

Re: Re: Re: Re: Lukacs versus Frankfurt School (fwd)

2000-05-26 Thread George Pennefather
Mine: I did not doubt about it. Adorno's _Aesthetic Theory_ offers morepossibilities to conceive art as a "praxis making" human enterprise,whereas _Dialectic Of Enlightenment_ ,seems to me, a more pessimistic textreflecting the circumstanes of declining liberal democracy and rise

David Barkin on Globalization

2000-05-26 Thread Michael Perelman
Too bad David is not still on pen-l Date: Wed, 24 May 2000 19:24:51 -0500 (CDT) From: David Barkin [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Globalization E-Conference [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [globalization] A time for reflection. I am a Mexican economist teaching the theories of development and working with

Re: Re: Re: Re: Lukacs versus Frankfurt School (fwd)

2000-05-26 Thread md7148
Mine: I did not doubt about it. Adorno's _Aesthetic Theory_ offers more possibilities to conceive art as a "praxis making" human enterprise, whereas _Dialectic Of Enlightenment_ ,seems to me, a more pessimistic text reflecting the circumstanes of declining liberal democracy and rise of organized

Re: Dialectical materialism andecology

2000-05-26 Thread Jim Devine
I asked: but what is "thaxis"? I know what "praxis" is. CB: I've always thought it was sort of thaxis is to theory as praxis is to practice. but praxis is supposed to be the unity of theory and practice, no? Doug writes: Theory + practice = thaxis. but practice + theory = praxis. Which by

Re: RE: Re: RE: Krugman Watch: Workers vs. Workers

2000-05-26 Thread Jim Devine
At 03:52 PM 5/26/00 -0400, you wrote: Max Sawicky wrote: How does the EITC [earned income tax credit] make a worker any more dependent on an employer (who else can you work for?) than a wage increase? Doug writes: You only get the EITC if you have a job, so it doesn't reduce the cost of job

Re: RE: Krugman Watch: Workers vs. Workers

2000-05-26 Thread Jim Devine
mbs writes: The problem w/direct aid for trade adjustment is the problem of narrow entitlements -- they fail to excite mass support and without elite backing, tend to wither on the vine. that's right. But economists who are pushing free trade as the solution to the world's ills should be

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Lukacs versus Frankfurt School (fwd)

2000-05-26 Thread Dennis R Redmond
On Fri, 26 May 2000 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: "high" art and "low" art, Wagner versus "mass music". I never see jazz in the way that Adorno sees. What about the aesthetic beauty of Moroccon jazz? or Cuban jazz? or Jamaican jazz? Adorno is useless vis-a-vis jazz. He didn't know the great jazz

Re: Re: Dialectical materialism andecology

2000-05-26 Thread J. Barkley Rosser, Jr.
Jim, "Thaxis" was neologized by somebody (don't remember who) involved with what was once called the marxism-2 list. This was the original spinoff, although perhaps preceded by the OPE list crowd, from the old marxism list that had everybody and their whole families, tribes, cliques, and

anthropology question

2000-05-26 Thread Michael Perelman
I have a question for anyone with a passing knowledge of anthropology. The speaker on our campus made these two statements that some very interesting. Are they true? cuneiform was only used for business transactions 800 years before people realized that it could be used for other purposes.

Re: Re: Re: Frankfurters, fascism and ecology

2000-05-26 Thread Dennis R Redmond
On Fri, 26 May 2000, Doug Henwood wrote: Dennis, what do you make of the post-WW II Adorno, who took CIA money to rebuild the Frankfurt School, and refused to republish Neumann's Behemoth because it was too Marxist? The Institute was originally financed by a wealthy Dutch rentier, proving

Rock and roll rebels

2000-05-26 Thread Louis Proyect
From Metallica's "...And Justice for All" Halls of Justice Painted Green Money Talking Power Wolves Beset Your Door Hear Them Stalking Soon You'll Please Their Appetite They Devour Hammer of Justice Crushes You Overpower = From an interview with Metallica at slashdot.org: Question:

Re: Re: Marx's life and theory

2000-05-26 Thread Carrol Cox
Louis Proyect wrote: Whitehead: "Nature is plastic, although to every prevalent state of mind there corresponds iron nature setting its bounds to life. [snip] It is a false dichotomy to think of Nature and Man. Mankind is that factor *in* Nature which exhibits in its most intense

Re: Re: Re: Re: Frankfurters, fascism and ecology

2000-05-26 Thread Jim Devine
At 03:15 PM 5/26/00 -0700, you wrote: The Institute was originally financed by a wealthy Dutch rentier, proving that one should never be afraid of reappropriating The Man's capital flow to fight oppression. for better or for worse, almost all leftist organizations have relied on funds from

Re: Re: Re: Re: Frankfurters, fascism and ecology

2000-05-26 Thread Doug Henwood
Dennis R Redmond wrote: On Fri, 26 May 2000, Doug Henwood wrote: Dennis, what do you make of the post-WW II Adorno, who took CIA money to rebuild the Frankfurt School, and refused to republish Neumann's Behemoth because it was too Marxist? The Institute was originally financed by a

Re: R Dialectical materialism andecology

2000-05-26 Thread Carrol Cox
Doug Henwood wrote: Jim Devine wrote: but what is "thaxis"? I know what "praxis" is. Theory + practice = thaxis. No relation to Thurn und Thaxis, or whatever that thing from Pynchon's Lot 49 is. Are you sure -- it has the aroma of coming out of the same bottle as lipoleum and

Re: Re marxism-thaxis

2000-05-26 Thread Chris Burford
At 10:46 26/05/00 -0700, you wrote: At 08:05 AM 05/26/2000 +0100, you wrote: At 08:44 25/05/00 -0700, Jim D wrote: I don't want to get into quote-mongering (or to rehearsing old debates from Marxism-thaxis -- BTW, what in 'ell is "thaxis"?) Marxism-thaxis is one of the life forms in virtual

Re: anthropology question

2000-05-26 Thread Carrol Cox
Michael Perelman wrote: I have a question for anyone with a passing knowledge of anthropology. The speaker on our campus made these two statements that some very interesting. Are they true? cuneiform was only used for business transactions 800 years before people realized that it

Re: Re: Marx's life and theory

2000-05-26 Thread Louis Proyect
I'm convinced that Ted is wrong in some ways -- but he sure as hell is not wrong in ways that can be thrown off this simply. Carrol The problem with Whitehead (and Leibniz) and Harvey's appropriation of both thinkers is that there is no concept of contradiction, struggle,

Re: Re: Re: Marx's life and theory

2000-05-26 Thread Carrol Cox
Louis Proyect wrote: For example, when Whitehead writes, "Nature is always about the perpetual exploration of novelty," you lose the other side of the equation which is about crisis and destruction. Agreed -- this fits my memory of Whitehead, whom I haven't read in almost 40 years.

Re: Re: Henry Wallace

2000-05-26 Thread Michael Hoover
CB: Yes, I often think that the Wallace would have been president without the switch. Was Wallace for real ? A red ? Well, he would have been prez if he'd still been vice-prez when FDR died at beginning of fourth term in 1945... Wallace came from Iowa Republican family, father was

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: DefendingChina'sRighttoSelf-Determination (fwd)

2000-05-26 Thread Brad De Long
Mine, I do not disagree that the wages suck. But, are they better than what those workers got on the ejidos? The voting-with-the-feet pattern suggests an answer...

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Frankfurters, fascism andecology

2000-05-26 Thread Brad De Long
Not republishing Behemoth because it was too Marxist is kind of icky, no? Doug Well, it's also substantially wrong... especially those parts where Neumann says that the Nazis have to keep the Jews around or else the people will turn on the bosses and the rulers... Brad DeLong --

Re: Re: Gore or Dubya? (fwd)

2000-05-26 Thread Brad De Long
the case. Essentially, the "lesser evil" strategy which helped to facilitate Hitler's rise to power became central to the reformist left. Of course, all of this is immaterial to non-Marxists. Louis Proyect Very true. Actually, if one looks at the party politics of the pre-nazi germany, one

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: DefendingChina'sRighttoSelf-Determination (fwd)

2000-05-26 Thread md7148
sure, with $1.80 hourly wage, *and* mostly non-unionized, as of 1996 figures! Mine Barkley asked: Mine, I do not disagree that the wages suck. But, are they better than what those workers got on the ejidos? Brad replied: The voting-with-the-feet pattern suggests an answer...

question about academic secrecy

2000-05-26 Thread Michael Perelman
Noam Chomsky has recently written: There was an article in the Wall Street Journal last summer, you may have seen, about MIT, my place. What had happened was that a student in a computer science class had refused to answer a question on an exam. When he was asked why by the professor, he said

Re: Re: Political Constraints,was:Re:MarxandMalleability (fwd)

2000-05-26 Thread Carrol Cox
"J. Barkley Rosser, Jr." wrote: MIne, That old reactionary Churchill once remarked that "democracy is the worst of all political systems except for all the rest," or words to that effect. It seems that my original point got lost in a hassle over the use/legitimacy/etc of elections as

Re: voting with the feet

2000-05-26 Thread Jim Devine
I think it was Barkley who wrote: Mine, I do not disagree that the wages suck. But, are they better than what those workers got on the ejidos? now Brad writes: The voting-with-the-feet pattern suggests an answer... As Michael suggests, we should look for push factors rather than blithely

Re: Re: voting with the feet

2000-05-26 Thread Brad De Long
I think it was Barkley who wrote: Mine, I do not disagree that the wages suck. But, are they better than what those workers got on the ejidos? now Brad writes: The voting-with-the-feet pattern suggests an answer... As Michael suggests, we should look for push factors rather than blithely

Re: Re: Gore or Dubya? (fwd)

2000-05-26 Thread md7148
My reading of Neumann is that both Thaelmann and Hilferding refused to go to a coalition. It was a strategic mistake on both parts, especially when Hitler lost some seats in *second* Reichtag elections, and was in a relatively weaker position to be ousted by a united majority. it did not happen

Re: Re: Dialectical materialism andecology

2000-05-26 Thread Rob Schaap
all of this is getting nowhere. Did someone simply make the word up? Yep. I think it was Lisa Rogers, a shining character who found absolutely everything interesting and was instrumental back in '94 and '95 in trying to restructure Marxism space (back at Virginia U's Spoons list server) to

RE: question about academic secrecy

2000-05-26 Thread Lisa Ian Murray
Michael, There was an article in the July 20, 1999 WSJ about Vanu Bose [the loudspeaker designer]and a patent dispute that involved him and his son. The article does not mention the test, but there were several articles over the summer investigating the Technology Licensing Office at MIT by the