Guevara on law of value and world terms of trade

2002-08-26 Thread Chris Burford
For personal reasons I could not respond to this interesting passage at the time. Nor can I do justice to the enormous subject of the law of value under socialism, without much more preparation. But in connection with the great disparities in the level of the productive forces on a world

Running dry, part 2

2002-08-26 Thread Louis Proyect
NY Times, Aug. 26, 2002 As Multinationals Run the Taps, Anger Rises Over Water for Profit By JOHN TAGLIABUE SAN ISIDRO DE LULES, Argentina When Jorge Abdala's water bill jumped to 59 pesos a month from 24 a few years ago, he went looking for someone to blame. He soon found his villain: a

Re: Re: Russia turns to yuan

2002-08-26 Thread Waistline2
In a message dated 8/25/02 4:58:10 AM Pacific Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: The Infinite War and its Roots by Stan Goff But we must take into account the social relations of energy, and value-theory. It is not the finite physical limit of oil that matters right now. It matters what

Re: Re: Re: Russia turns to yuan

2002-08-26 Thread Louis Proyect
Shortage of oil? Not in this world. The shortage is in our vision and imagination. Melvin P. Even under socialism, there would be dwindling supplies of oil just as there are dwindling supplies of water. Unless Melvin's vision and imagination includes serious and *measurable* proposals for

utopianism??

2002-08-26 Thread Devine, James
Title: utopianism?? [was: RE: [PEN-L:29857] Re: Re: Re: Russia turns to yuan] Shortage of oil? Not in this world. The shortage is in our vision and imagination. Melvin P. Louis P: Even under socialism, there would be dwindling supplies of oil just as there are dwindling supplies of

new subsidies guesstimates

2002-08-26 Thread Ian Murray
Published on Monday, August 26, 2002 by the Guardian of London Ecological Decline 'Far Worse' Than Official Estimates Leaked paper - OECD's grim warning on climate change by John Vidal in Johannesburg The real level of world inequality and environmental degradation may be far worse than

Re: utopianism??

2002-08-26 Thread Louis Proyect
Jim Devine: when you advocate measureable proposals, are you saying that we need to develop recipes for the cook-shops of the future? I thought you were against utopianism. Utopianism means blueprints for how society should be run. Stating that there are 2 billion souls on earth and given 2

the legal war?

2002-08-26 Thread Devine, James
Title: the legal war? From today's SLATE: The [US-based] Washington Post leads with a piece saying that Bush administration lawyers have concluded that the president can legally attack Saddam without prior approval from Congress. The lawyers argue, among other points, that Bush already has

RE: Re: utopianism??

2002-08-26 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:29861] Re: utopianism?? It's a nice academic distinction, but it doesn't work in practice. How one sets up a social organization of production affects how and what is produced. The relations and forces of production are unified, interpenetrate, and determine each others'

Re: RE: Re: utopianism??

2002-08-26 Thread Louis Proyect
Jim Devine: It's a nice academic distinction, but it doesn't work in practice. How one sets up a social organization of production affects how and what is produced. The relations and forces of production are unified, interpenetrate, and determine each others' character. So we can't separate

Re: RE: Re: utopianism??

2002-08-26 Thread Michael Perelman
Would it be fair to say that Lou is saying that we have to take account of technical recipes, but not social recipes? Providing food requires certain minimum amount of water, but not necessarily a specific social form in which society converts water into food. -- Michael Perelman Economics

participatory democracy

2002-08-26 Thread Devine, James
Title: participatory democracy Awhile back, pen-l had a discussion of so-called participatory democracy. FWIW, I found a discussion of this concept in THE NATION [August 5/12, 2002], by Tom Hayden Dick Flacks, two authors of the Port Huron Statement of the Students for a Democratic Society

RE: Re: RE: Re: utopianism??

2002-08-26 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:29864] Re: RE: Re: utopianism?? You don't have to reply. But are you endorsing socialism from above, in which a small minority imposes its predetermined schemes on the majority of the population? Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: utopianism??

2002-08-26 Thread Louis Proyect
Jim Devine wrote: You don't have to reply. But are you endorsing socialism from above, in which a small minority imposes its predetermined schemes on the majority of the population? I advocate the most ruthlessly dictatorial rule from above and over the working class to make sure that they

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: utopianism??

2002-08-26 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:29868] Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: utopianism?? Louis Proyect of www.marxmail.org writes: I advocate the most ruthlessly dictatorial rule from above and over the working class to make sure that they follow the dictates of the central presidium. Any workers found reading Hal

Bushies say NAIRU is 4.9

2002-08-26 Thread Max B. Sawicky
. . . but it will take five years to get there. (p. 15, Mid-Session Review, OMB) mbs

Re: participatory democracy

2002-08-26 Thread Michael Perelman
Jim's reference to Kaufman and the SDS suggests why this debate will be much like our earlier experiences with market socialism. Kaufman's idea is fine in principle. How the hell you actually do it is terribly difficult. Are we to work out a Devine/Proyect rules of order to make sure that

Oz anti-adultery association

2002-08-26 Thread Devine, James
Title: Oz anti-adultery association [I thought politics was strange in the US... Also, it seems that the article uses the word vigilante differently thatn in the US.] Cuckolds take their rage to the streets Australian vigilantes picket homes and call for death to adulterers David Fickling

Re: Bushies say NAIRU is 4.9

2002-08-26 Thread Michael Perelman
Are they just trying to lower expectations in anticipation of poor economic performance? On Mon, Aug 26, 2002 at 12:22:35PM -0400, Max B. Sawicky wrote: . . . but it will take five years to get there. (p. 15, Mid-Session Review, OMB) mbs -- Michael Perelman Economics Department

RE: Re: Bushies say NAIRU is 4.9

2002-08-26 Thread Max B. Sawicky
They forecast real GDP growth of 3.7 for CY2002 and '03, which looks to be on the rosy side. mbs -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]On Behalf Of Michael Perelman Sent: Monday, August 26, 2002 12:59 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [PEN-L:29873] Re:

Economic Reporting Review, Dean Baker, 8/26/02

2002-08-26 Thread Robert Naiman
Economic Reporting Review By Dean Baker August 26, 2002 You can sign up to receive ERR every week by sending a subscribe ERR email request with your address in the body of the email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] You can find the latest ERR at http://www.cepr.net/Economic_Reporting_Review/inde x.htm.

Re: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: utopianism??

2002-08-26 Thread Carl Remick
From: Louis Proyect [EMAIL PROTECTED] Any workers found reading Hal Draper will be buried up to their necks and a workers militia under the leadership of a tested commissar will drive over their heads with power lawnmowers. But what kind of lawnmowers, reel or rotary? Reels provide a better

Future Criminals

2002-08-26 Thread Eric Nilsson
Philip Dick's Minority Report (recently made into movie with many changes) was based on something similar to the following: Controversial Police Database Lists 'Future Criminals' Names, Addresses Of Potential Suspects Listed Posted: 12:02 p.m. EDT August 26, 2002 WILMINGTON, Del. -- Defense

dead economists

2002-08-26 Thread Ellen Frank
Anybody have handy the famous Keynes quote about dead economists? Ellen

Re: Guevara on law of value and world terms of trade

2002-08-26 Thread Louis Proyect
For personal reasons I could not respond to this interesting passage at the time. Nor can I do justice to the enormous subject of the law of value under socialism, without much more preparation. But in connection with the great disparities in the level of the productive forces on a world

RE: Re: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: utopianism??

2002-08-26 Thread Brown, Martin - ARP (NCI)
No comrade, this is obscurantist thinking designed to distract us from stalinist mis-leadership of Proyect. Notice that he has told us to use power mowers, contributing to capitalist and state-socialist abuse of the natural environment. No mention of the merits of electric vs gasoline powered

Re: dead economists

2002-08-26 Thread Gil Skillman
Ellen, here you go: The ideas of economists and political philosophers, both when they are right and when they are wrong, are more powerful than is commonly understood. Indeed the world is ruled by little else. Practical men, who believe themselves to be quite exempt from any intellectual

Re: Re: dead economists

2002-08-26 Thread Ellen Frank
Thanks Gil! [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Ellen, here you go: The ideas of economists and political philosophers, both when they are right and when they are wrong, are more powerful than is commonly understood. Indeed the world is ruled by little else. Practical men, who believe themselves to

RE: Re: Bushies say NAIRU is 4.9

2002-08-26 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:29873] Re: Bushies say NAIRU is 4.9 according to one estimate appearing in THE ROARING NINETIES, edited by Alan Kreuger and Robert Solow, the US NAIRU is about 5.1 % of the civilian labor force. Of course, the concept is very, very weak. The standard error of estimate is

Re: Bushies say NAIRU is 4.9

2002-08-26 Thread Sabri Oncu
Friends, Do you mind telling us what the heck this NAIRU is? Or should we ask Ravi to help us break this code too? Sabri

Iraq: Cheney's case for preemptive doctrine

2002-08-26 Thread Sabri Oncu
Top World News 08/26 15:12 U.S. Action Against Iraq Is 'Imperative,' Cheney Says (Update3) By Ryan J. Donmoyer Nashville, Tennessee, Aug. 26 (Bloomberg) -- Vice President Dick Cheney rejected criticism of possible military action against Iraq, saying the Middle East nation probably possesses

Re: Re: Bushies say NAIRU is 4.9

2002-08-26 Thread Carl Remick
Friends, Do you mind telling us what the heck this NAIRU is? Or should we ask Ravi to help us break this code too? Sabri Non-Accelerating Inflation Rate of Unemployment. Carl _ MSN Photos is the easiest way to share and print

RE: Re: Bushies say NAIRU is 4.9

2002-08-26 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:29884] Re: Bushies say NAIRU is 4.9 Friends, Do you mind telling us what the heck this NAIRU is? Or should we ask Ravi to help us break this code too? Sabri the NAIRU is a hypothetical rate of unemployment. If the actual rate of unemployment goes below it, the

post bankruptcy self-dealing

2002-08-26 Thread Michael Perelman
ROBERT X. CRINGELY(R): Notes from the Field InfoWorld.com Monday, August 26, 2002 Speaking of wanting it all, a spy reports that the individual entrusted with handling the estate

Re: Bushies say NAIRU is 4.9

2002-08-26 Thread Tom Walker
I'll admit as much as more coherent or more systematic but more scientific? That's like saying one astrologer is more scientific than another. Jim Devine wrote, The NAIRU is a more-scientific way to describe what Milton Friedman calls the natural rate of unemployment. His idea is that the

Re: Re: Bushies say NAIRU is 4.9

2002-08-26 Thread Eugene Coyle
Arguing about whether the right number is 8.5% or 4.9% or 0.5% is a trap. The figure for the NAIRU should not be a discussion we enter into. Gene Coyle Tom Walker wrote: I'll admit as much as more coherent or more systematic but more scientific? That's like saying one astrologer is more

A Mesopotamian Stalingrad?

2002-08-26 Thread Louis Proyect
NY Times, Aug. 26, 2002 Iraq Said to Plan Tangling the U.S. in Street Fighting By MICHAEL R. GORDON WASHINGTON, Aug. 25 — President Saddam Hussein of Iraq will try to compensate for his armed forces' glaring weaknesses by raising the specter of urban warfare if the Bush administration moves

art and the commodity form

2002-08-26 Thread Michael Perelman
I found this article interesting because it suggests the way that these pictures seem to represent a clear vision of capitalist production where, as Marx said, the worker [is reduced to] nothing more than personified labour-time [and where all] individual distinctions are obliterated (Marx 1977,

Re: Re: dead economists

2002-08-26 Thread Ben Day
At 03:44 PM 8/26/2002 -0400, Gil Skillman wrote: The ideas of economists and political philosophers, both when they are right and when they are wrong, are more powerful than is commonly understood. Indeed the world is ruled by little else. Practical men, who believe themselves to be quite

and when we're all rich, then what?

2002-08-26 Thread Ian Murray
What do we really want? Economic growth is seen as good, yet it makes many in the rich world miserable George Monbiot Tuesday August 27, 2002 The Guardian There is scarcely a discussion of climate change on the radio or television that does not involve a climate sceptic - someone who believes

dead economists

2002-08-26 Thread Michael Perelman
Ben was on target. Keynes was an elitist snob, surely expecting that he and people like him control the world. It is more likely that the economists merely say what is useful to those in power -- at last those economists who get listened to more widely. Stiglitz is saying some good stuff now.