Re: On the necessity of socialism and grammar

2002-02-22 Thread Tom Walker
Sabri Oncu wrote, Um, as soon as we can figure out whether God does or does not exist... Ian My dear Ian, This problem is not that difficult. I solved it when I was 14. I realized that there was no difference between believing in the existence or non-existence of God. Sabri has

n the necessity of socialism and grammar

2002-02-22 Thread bantam
G'day Tom'n'Sabri, Sabri has framed the issue correctly. Both are beliefs. For the same reason as Sabri, I believe in God but not in a God or gods. The distinction is crucial. There IS a difference between believing in God and believing in a God or the God. God is a unique part of speech

Re: n the necessity of socialism and grammar

2002-02-22 Thread Tom Walker
Rob wrote, To avoid confusion, though, I'd not call it God -snip- The famous last sentence of the Tractatus - What we cannot speak about we must pass over in silence This suggests to me that as much as I sympathize with the aim of avoiding confusion, confusion cannot be avoided. That

Re: Re: On the necessity of socialism and grammar

2002-02-22 Thread Ian Murray
- Original Message - From: Tom Walker [EMAIL PROTECTED] In fact, one might say that the linguistic function of God is precisely to stand as other to all the common parts of speech and thus to remind us of the incompleteness, the inadequacy of any conceivable utterance. God is the

Re: Re: On the necessity of socialism and grammar

2002-02-22 Thread Ken Hanly
, 2002 8:24 AM Subject: [PEN-L:23057] Re: On the necessity of socialism and grammar Sabri Oncu wrote, Um, as soon as we can figure out whether God does or does not exist... Ian My dear Ian, This problem is not that difficult. I solved it when I was 14. I realized