D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

kkoma added a comment. In D18078#398771 , @filipf wrote: > In D18078#398570 , @ngraham wrote: > > > Where are we with replacing one of those flower images with another one? > > > We could add

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

filipf added a comment. Excellent, thanks for the clarification. Next step is basically what @rooty said then, but I'd try to some more in (not just 5-6). REPOSITORY R131 Plasma Wallpapers REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D18078 To: filipf, #plasma, #vdg, ngraham Cc:

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

jriddell added a comment. > We need to ask Unsplash and/or the photographers to release their work into the public domain or if it already is in the public domain to ask for confirmation. Yes the copyright holder needs to give permission to copy it under public domain, CC0, CC-BY-SA or

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

filipf added a comment. Can you confirm this @jriddell? Also, how strong of a document is an email confirmation to rooty or me, shouldn't it be something more formal? REPOSITORY R131 Plasma Wallpapers REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D18078 To: filipf, #plasma, #vdg, ngraham

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

rooty added a comment. In D18078#406392 , @filipf wrote: > What is the final verdict reached in the mailing list discussion? We need to ask Unsplash and/or the photographers to release their work into the public domain or if it already

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

filipf added a comment. What is the final verdict reached in the mailing list discussion? REPOSITORY R131 Plasma Wallpapers REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D18078 To: filipf, #plasma, #vdg, ngraham Cc: jriddell, lydia, davidedmundson, abetts, mart, rooty, plasma-devel,

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

davidedmundson added a comment. Can we keep this discussion of licenses on "Licensing policy change proposal" on the KDE community thread so info is not split. REPOSITORY R131 Plasma Wallpapers REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D18078 To: filipf, #plasma, #vdg, ngraham Cc:

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

jriddell added a comment. > The Unsplash license is CC0 (public domain) with only one exception: the images are not to be used to start or advance that's a competitor of Unsplash. > The Pexels license has more restrictions. These additional restrictions make them non-free. They do

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

rooty added a comment. In D18078#401227 , @jriddell wrote: > Note we cannot ship files under the Pexels License or Unsplash licence as they are non-free and have restrictions. > > We can ship files in the public domain as they are

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

filipf added a comment. Budgie as well: https://github.com/UbuntuBudgie/budgie-wallpapers/blob/master/debian/copyright REPOSITORY R131 Plasma Wallpapers REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D18078 To: filipf, #plasma, #vdg, ngraham Cc: jriddell, lydia, davidedmundson, abetts,

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

filipf added a comment. Those licences are basically CC0 with minor additions. Photos are free to use. Where does the issue lie, that they're formally not listed somewhere as free licences? If they're really non-free, how can they ship them in GNOME and Elementary then?

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

jriddell added a comment. Note we cannot ship files under the Pexels License or Unsplash licence as they are non-free and have restrictions. We can ship files in the public domain as they are unrestricted. REPOSITORY R131 Plasma Wallpapers REVISION DETAIL

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

filipf added a comment. In D18078#398934 , @davidedmundson wrote: > (Though I can't find it here https://spdx.org/licenses/ does it have another name?) Probably not. I can't find any sort of formal licence text for the Pexels and

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

rooty added a comment. Grassland ftw! I'll let the licensing people know what's up and hopefully they'll tell us what's what. REPOSITORY R131 Plasma Wallpapers REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D18078 To: filipf, #plasma, #vdg, ngraham Cc: davidedmundson, abetts, mart,

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

davidedmundson added a comment. Ok, so two important tasks. 1. We need to get this extra license into KCoreAddons::KAboutLicense I think otherwise it won't render properly in the plasma UI. I can take care of that. (Though I can't find it here https://spdx.org/licenses/ does it

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

filipf added a comment. In D18078#398858 , @ngraham wrote: > My vote goes to the grassland. We already have two nice city images, and the desert one looks too much like the default wallpaper in macOS 10.14 Mojave. We might be accused of copying

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

filipf added a comment. In D18078#39 , @davidedmundson wrote: > Can you please confirm the source of these images. > We need to be sure they all fall under: https://community.kde.org/Policies/Licensing_Policy > > If not, we need to

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

ngraham added inline comments. INLINE COMMENTS > davidedmundson wrote in metadata.desktop:7 > License=Unsplash > > What's unsplash? https://unsplash.com/license > License > > All photos published on Unsplash can be used for free. You can use them for > commercial and noncommercial purposes.

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

davidedmundson added a comment. Can you please confirm the source of these images. We need to be sure they all fall under: https://community.kde.org/Policies/Licensing_Policy If not, we need to take it up with people who care about this legal stuff. INLINE COMMENTS >

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

ngraham added a comment. My vote goes to the grassland. We already have two nice city images, and the desert one looks too much like the default wallpaper in macOS 10.14 Mojave. We might be accused of copying them. > As for implementation, I take it we should wait until 5.17 since there

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

filipf added a comment. In D18078#398570 , @ngraham wrote: > Where are we with replacing one of those flower images with another one? We could add one more cityscape instead: F6563983: image.png

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

ngraham added a comment. Where are we with replacing one of those flower images with another one? REPOSITORY R131 Plasma Wallpapers REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D18078 To: filipf, #plasma, #vdg, ngraham Cc: abetts, mart, rooty, plasma-devel, jraleigh, GB_2, ragreen,

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

ngraham added a comment. In D18078#389037 , @filipf wrote: > As a further step I suggest to remove the yellow tulips (Blooming Flowers) wallpaper because we have enough flowers. That wallpaper is also somewhat busy in the bottom part. > >

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

ngraham added a comment. > +100 > (and we should push more on distros to have this installed by default Indeed! Manjaro already does. See also: - T10219: Ship the plasma-workspace-wallpapers package by default in Neon - T10218: Ship

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

abetts added a comment. +1 I like the selection so far. Just ping me when you need an official approval. Thank you for your work! REPOSITORY R131 Plasma Wallpapers REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D18078 To: filipf, #plasma, #vdg, ngraham Cc: abetts, mart, rooty,

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

filipf added a comment. Note: scaling **Almond Blossom** and **Two Labrador Retriever Puppies** made no sense, these pics have great compression & turned out bigger when shrunk. As a further step I suggest to remove the yellow tulips wallpaper because we have enough flowers.

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

filipf updated this revision to Diff 48962. filipf added a comment. Scale oversized wallpapers to 5K; crop the NASA wallpaper in order to remove a visual annoyance REPOSITORY R131 Plasma Wallpapers CHANGES SINCE LAST UPDATE https://phabricator.kde.org/D18078?vs=48929=48962 BRANCH

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

rooty added a comment. wow scrolling down took a while haha sure fine with me, crop em (except for Lake Bled?) REPOSITORY R131 Plasma Wallpapers REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D18078 To: filipf, #plasma, #vdg, ngraham Cc: mart, rooty, plasma-devel, kvanton, jraleigh,

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

filipf added a comment. Thanks :) Trying to have more distros include the package is the plan. + I have some good news, by scaling down the really big wallpapers added here to 5K we save 10 MiB. @rooty, that okay? REPOSITORY R131 Plasma Wallpapers REVISION DETAIL

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

mart added a comment. +100 (and we should push more on distros to have this installed by default, they often don't to save space on the iso :/ REPOSITORY R131 Plasma Wallpapers REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D18078 To: filipf, #plasma, #vdg, ngraham Cc: mart, rooty,

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

filipf added a comment. Here's some raw numbers listed: - plasma-workspace-wallpapers prior to D17780 : about 42 MB - plasma-workspace-wallpapers after D17780 : about 152 MB - plasma-workspace-wallpapers

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

filipf added a comment. Ah we only ship the biggest size for our additions now. It's the only thing that makes sense for this package IMO, among other things distros will really think twice about shipping it if it's big, like you said. Heck, if someone asked **me** if they could put

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

ngraham added a comment. Lovely. Good call including all size and aspect ratio variants for now in case we don't opt to go with D18005: Include only the largest size for each wallpaper . Dare I ask how big all of this on disk? You can find out with

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

rooty added a comment. Still not sure if we should have also included the grassland F6507127: jean-pierre-brungs-103087-unsplash.jpg REPOSITORY R131 Plasma Wallpapers REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D18078 To: filipf, #plasma,

D18078: [plasma-workspace-wallpapers] Improve wallpaper selection

filipf created this revision. Herald added a project: Plasma. Herald added a subscriber: plasma-devel. filipf requested review of this revision. REVISION SUMMARY This patch improves the plasma-workspace-wallpapers package by offering cleaner, more modern photographic wallpapers. It also