Hi Nathan
I'm not saying you're wrong - but could you explain why it would be a pain for
FOAF terms to return 200? Which kinds of application are dereferencing those
terms and relying on a 303 response?
eg http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Person currently 303s to
http://xmlns.com/foaf/spec/
What
Hi Nathan - thanks for clear answer. I see the point and also the argument for
using hash URIs with ontologies.
In practice how I get round this prob is to preload my triple store with the
handful of common ontologies I know I'm going to use, so don't need to deref
them as I go along.
Cheers
Nathan
One practical downside of hash URIs that I've come across is this:
Suppose I have a resource http://example.com#foo
I can provide a description of it at http://example.com - so far so good.
If someone then asks me about http://example.com#bar - for whatever reason -
but in fact I don't
and to ensure I've got it..
essentially I could write the following sentence in a document
'Kingsley Idehen' wrote a post entitled 'name of post'; where the
'name of post' is automatically injected at render time directly from
the rdf title of your post; so if you change the title, my
Hugh - I understand your point about different provenance and maintenance
issues with linkage vs substantive knowledge, but if you dereference a URI,
don't you want to also get the linkage information at that point? Of course
you could do that while still keeping the two knowledge bases
Hi Eric
Regarding your first point - yes, your two options are equivalent and the
second one is neater, so go for that.
Regarding linking to external resources, what it seems you want to do is to
identify the dc:creator of the book, hence say that the creator is the person
whose name was
Nice work!
Ivan
Thanks very much. I'll take a look at your python scripts, which should be
very useful.
Cheers
Bill
Van: Ivan Herman [mailto:i...@w3.org]
Verzonden: wo 24-6-2009 9:14
Aan: Bill Roberts
CC: public-lod@w3.org
Onderwerp: Re: RDFa vs RDF/XML and
I've been trying to weigh up the pros and cons of these two approaches to
understand more clearly when you might want to use each. I hope that the list
members will be able to provide me with the benefit of their experience and
insight!
So the situation is that I have some information on a
