RE: More on chaplains

2006-05-12 Thread Newsom Michael
It seems that the question on the table is the rights of military chaplains, especially evangelical Protestant ones who seem to be at the forefront of the agitation here. But their rights have to be understood in context. The military chaplaincies were not established in order to

RE: Early dismissal for Muslims on Friday

2006-05-12 Thread Volokh, Eugene
Title: Message I would think that there's a difference -- the sort of difference in quantity that becomes a difference in quality -- between skipping a couple of days and skipping every Friday afternoon. It may be worth accommodating students even in the latter instance, but I'm not sure

Re: Early dismissal for Muslims on Friday

2006-05-12 Thread David E. Guinn
Title: Message This is a difficult answer to parse down to a principle. I am most familiar with Islamic practice in the Middle East (Iraq, Jordan and Egypt). While Friday is usually taken as part of the weekend in those counties, Friday is not considered the Sabbath -- so there is no

RE: More on chaplains

2006-05-12 Thread Gordon James Klingenschmitt
"Agitator" Chaplain Klingenschmitt's comments on the "new" House legislation...1) THE FIRST AMENDMENT ALREADY ALLOWSCHAPLAINS FREEDOM "TO PRAY ACCORDING TO THE DICTATES OF THEIR CONSCIENCE." (Is any phrase more distinctlyAmerican than this? Even Congressman Israel voted for this, he just