Re: Recommendation...

2006-09-02 Thread Stephen R. Prescott, Esq.
Prior to the post by the distinguished list custodian, I had noted yesterday that since the discussion was drifting off topic, it was probably time to move from Biblical interpretation back to law. However, based upon the tone of Professor Finkleman’s post, I feel compelled to respond. I do know

Re: Recommendation...

2006-09-01 Thread Stephen R. Prescott, Esq.
Basically a lurker on this list, wisdom would no doubt be for me to remain silent. Yet, "fools rush in where angels fail to trod." I have no idea who Mr. Lofton is or the nature of the group with which he is associated. However, acknowledging the stellar credentials of his critics, its seems to

Re: Recommendation...

2006-09-01 Thread Stephen R. Prescott, Esq.
A valid point, the Bible does condemn certain items, so we do not have to infer the Biblical view from circumstanial evidence. However, that cuts both ways. The Bible condemns drunkness. Yet, Noah is in no way criticized in the Biblical text for his intoxication. Rather, a son Ham is condemned

Re: Recommendation...

2006-09-01 Thread Stephen R. Prescott, Esq.
Ed Brayton wrote: I don't think it's true to say we can be absolutely certain that God does anything. I would call this evidence of incoherence within the Bible, owing to multiple writers and their own views, not as evidence of what God actually said or did. Fair enough, this goes to one’s

RE: Kermit Hall

2006-08-14 Thread Stephen R. Prescott, Esq.
Sorry, I should read what I write before hitting send. It is the first day of classes. It should read "Kermit flew back at his own expense." From: "Stephen R. Prescott, Esq." [EMAIL PROTECTED]Reply-To: Law Religion issues for Law Academics religionlaw@lists.ucl

RE: Kermit Hall

2006-08-14 Thread Stephen R. Prescott, Esq.
As Kermit's student at the University of Florida, I add my sadness at learning of Dr. Hall's untimely death. Although I have not seen him much since he supervised my M.A. thesis in my J.D./M.A. program, I was greatly enriched both intellectually and personally by him. One example of his

Re: Locke v. Davey Question

2006-01-11 Thread Stephen R. Prescott, Esq.
I would like to inject my situation in North Carolina into the picture. The North Carolina statute looks at the institution, not what the student is studying. Originally, "pervasively sectarian" institutions were prohibited from participating by court decree. Accounting majors at sectarian

RE: Bible study ban for RA's in UW-Eau Claire dorms

2005-11-08 Thread Stephen R. Prescott, Esq.
I think Steve Sanders for his post. I agree that the fact that the RA is an employee complicates this situation a little. However, it seems to me that this is just the type of discrimination that the Free Exercise Clause is designed to prevent. It is, of course, true that no one is required to

RE: Free Exercise Clause and government employees

2005-11-08 Thread Stephen R. Prescott, Esq.
I composed my response before the question of the extent and exact nature of the UW policy had been raised based on my (perhaps mistaken) reading of a news report. I accept Steve Sanders point that I need to know the specifics of the policy prior to declaring it to be religious discrimination. If

Re: Air Force sued over religious intolerance

2005-10-07 Thread Stephen R. Prescott, Esq.
It seems to me that the suit seeks far more than a ban on "involuntary" conversion. It seeks to ban attempts to convert or prostylize OR attempting "to involuntarily convert . . ." It looks like the plaintiffcontents that any attempt to convert or prostylize (I think that is what chaplains do) is

Re: Regulations for non-professional Biblical counselors

2004-10-13 Thread Stephen R. Prescott, Esq.
My understanding of Nally is the same as that of Professor Laycock. That is certainly what I teach the M.Div. students when I teach my course on Legal Issues for the Minister once a year. At one time our degree was in counseling, the nomenclature was changed to Biblical counseling to make clear

Regulations for non-professional Biblical counselors

2004-10-12 Thread Stephen R. Prescott, Esq.
Like many seminaries, the seminary division of the school where I teach offers an M.A. in Biblical counseling requiring about 1 year of graduate work in religion and one year of graduate work in counseling. The degree is not designed to prepare graduate for licensure or professional practice