Re: Is UCLA violating the Establishment Clause?

2004-01-27 Thread Mark Tushnet
The About This Site section of the web page says: The Lesbian Gay Bisexual Transgender Campus Resource Center is a department in Student and Campus Life, a division of the Student Affairs Organization under the direction of Vice Chancellor Winston Doby. The quoted material is the textual

Re: Is UCLA violating the Establishment Clause?

2004-01-27 Thread Andrew Koppelman
On its face it looks like a pretty flagrant Establishment Clause violation, but I'd need to know more about the structure of UCLA in order to be sure. Rosenberger v. Virginia holds that not all speech that the state funds is attributable to the state. The Establishment Clause isn't violated

RE: Is UCLA violating the Establishment Clause?

2004-01-27 Thread Scarberry, Mark
Title: Is UCLA violating the Establishment Clause? This isn't academic freedom, in my view. Rather, this is nearly the opposite of academic freedom. The university is not just allowing teachers to teach what they believe to be the best academic understanding of a subject. Instead the

RE: Is UCLA violating the Establishment Clause?

2004-01-27 Thread Volokh, Eugene
I'm unaware of UCLA providing any preferential support for chaplains or for religious groups (again, perhaps excepting hospital chaplains, but I'm not even sure of that) that it doesn't provide to any other student group or organization. I'm not even aware of any other public universities

RE: Is UCLA violating the Establishment Clause?

2004-01-27 Thread AJCONGRESS
While there have not been challenges to the best of my knowledge to college chaplainries, there have been challenges to police and hospital chaplaincies. By and large, if the chaplaincies are fundamentally non-sectarian and non -coercive they are upheld. However, in these cases there is a