Another Catholic Charities Issue

2006-03-22 Thread Marty Lederman
Interesting Op-Ed in today's Times by the Cardinal Arhcbishop of Los Angeles, who apparently plans to instruct the priests of his archdiocese to disobey a proposed law that would subject them, as well as other church and humanitarian workers, to criminal penalties for "assisting"

RE: Another Catholic Charities Issue

2006-03-22 Thread Stuart BUCK
I don't know immigration law well enough to answer this: Is there any reason to believe that the law would actually have the feared result? As I read the bill, it wouldn't even be possible for Church workers to disobey the law unless they actively assist illegal aliens TO remain in the United

Re: Another Catholic Charities Issue

2006-03-22 Thread marty . lederman
I hope my posts were not understood to be beating up on [the Catholic Church] thinking that homosexual conduct is sinful. Although I think that religious perspective is very unfortunate, I do not for a second question the sincerity or legitimacy of the Church's views (even if, on the question

RE: Catholic Charities Issue

2006-03-22 Thread Nathan Oman
I am not sure that we have a mirror here. Gay people are trying to get out from under an oppressive regime the likes of which conservative believers have not had to endure - nor are likely to. This just seems to muddy the issue to me. Doug's claim is not that gays and conservative Christians

RE: Catholic Charities Issue

2006-03-22 Thread Newsom Michael
I don't understand your point about free passes. -Original Message- From: Nathan Oman [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, March 22, 2006 6:28 PM To: Law Religion issues for Law Academics Subject: RE: Catholic Charities Issue I am not sure that we have a mirror here. Gay people

Re: Catholic Charities Issue

2006-03-22 Thread Ed Brayton
Newsom Michael wrote: I am not sure that we have a mirror here. Gay people are trying to get out from under an oppressive regime the likes of which conservative believers have not had to endure nor are likely to. While I agree with this, I don't think it