Re: FW: Student reprimanded for religious absences

2004-11-24 Thread Steven Jamar
The rule is could be expelled. There is no reason to think that a kid would be expelled only for missing 8 or 10 classes. It seems to me that sending a notice is proper and may even be required and that discretion in enforcement is proper as well. So, how could this rule NOT stand --

Re: FW: Student reprimanded for religious absences

2004-11-23 Thread Paul Finkelman
Factual question: Is travelling out of state necessary for the religious observance? That is, could he have attended religious services and remained in state, and thus not missed so much school? Did the days missed include all the religous holiday, or were there are also travel days or

RE: FW: Student reprimanded for religious absences

2004-11-23 Thread Christopher C. Lund
Putting aside the Indiana Free Exercise Clause, aren't there some serious problems here under the ordinary federal Free Exercise Clause as well? As an initial matter, the principal claims that [s]tudents are allowed [only] five days of excused absences per semester and that