Re: [RRG] Renumbering...

2008-09-05 Thread Scott Brim
Excerpts from Noel Chiappa on Fri, Sep 05, 2008 10:57:42AM -0400: - a) stop accepting/advertising PI addresses - b) charge for accepting/advertising PI addresses - c) deploy some sort of jack-up system outside the customer-owned/managed part of the network - d) buy stock in

RE: [RRG] Renumbering...

2008-09-05 Thread Tony Li
Hi Noel, | part of our recommendation will likely be to cease the |current practice | of disseminating PI addresses ... we can phase out PI. | |That's just not going to be accepted, IMO. The users leaned on |the RIRs to do |PI, and any attempt to get rid of PI would take even more

Re: [RRG] Renumbering...

2008-09-05 Thread Stephen Sprunk
Noel Chiappa wrote: From: Tony Li [EMAIL PROTECTED] As long as the registries continue to hand out PI space, and as long as the ISP's continue to accept and advertise them part of our recommendation will likely be to cease the current practice of disseminating PI

Re: [RRG] Renumbering...

2008-09-05 Thread Stephen Sprunk
[Edited and resent due to nutty email filters on the list] Dino Farinacci wrote: SHIM6, HIP, and multiple PA blocks were not, and are still not, considered viable options; my understanding of this RRG was to come up with something that the un-stoppable force would find acceptable so that it