[swinog] Re: DNSSEC auto-disabled by SWITCH on some .ch domains?

2023-05-01 Diskussionsfäden Benoît Panizzon via swinog
Hi Daniel > The nerd answer is that you can use Automated DNSSEC Provisioning [1] > to enable DNSSEC. This also sends an EPP poll message to your > registrar to update locally cached state information about a domain > name. Yes, trying to understand, how I correctly get rid of my old RRSIG

[swinog] Re: DNSSEC auto-disabled by SWITCH on some .ch domains?

2023-05-01 Diskussionsfäden Franco Hug via swinog
Thanks Daniel for your helpful answers. Yes, CDS is also something I always wanted to try, but as usual: no hard pressure, no time... ;-) Benoît Panizzon wrote: > From their point of view, my 'algo 5' .ch domains have still DNSSEC active Basically the same behavior I had with my 'algo 7'

[swinog] Re: DNSSEC auto-disabled by SWITCH on some .ch domains?

2023-05-01 Diskussionsfäden Daniel Stirnimann via swinog
On 01.05.23 15:48, Benoît Panizzon via swinog wrote: It looks like Gandi at least messed up their Registrar UI. From their point of view, my 'algo 5' .ch domains have still DNSSEC active but deleting DS or disabling DNSSEC hangs forever and upon reloading my old algo 5 keys are back. I guess

[swinog] Re: DNSSEC auto-disabled by SWITCH on some .ch domains?

2023-05-01 Diskussionsfäden Marcus J via swinog
G'day just saw something was missing in my reply. It should say : digest-type 2 and key algorithm 13 should be used. cheers Marcus Monday, May 1, 2023, 11:32:30 AM, you wrote: > Darn, thank you for the hint! I'm also affected and missed the phase out > of those algos. > Guess I have to

[swinog] Re: DNSSEC auto-disabled by SWITCH on some .ch domains?

2023-05-01 Diskussionsfäden Franco Hug via swinog
Hi all, Thanks for your replies, you basically backed my work assumption concerning deprecated algorithms, good to know. However, this raises some questions about the chosen proceeding of "just wiping" algo 5/7 and digest 1 DS records from the .ch zone... Affected domain holders should and

[swinog] Re: DNSSEC auto-disabled by SWITCH on some .ch domains?

2023-05-01 Diskussionsfäden Jeroen Massar via swinog
Alg 7 is ancient and deprecated... When one has DNS issues, especially DNSSEC related, run dnsviz: https://dnsviz.net/d/gkb.ch/ZDeung/dnssec/ as that will show you what is off: ``` • gkb.ch zone: The server(s) were not responsive to queries over UDP. (2001:67c:2350:11::bad:babe) •

[swinog] Re: DNSSEC auto-disabled by SWITCH on some .ch domains?

2023-05-01 Diskussionsfäden Benoît Panizzon via swinog
Hey > To the partners at least, in October 2022 informing them that > anything containing digest-type 1 and/or key algorithm 5 oder 7 are > no longer supported and will be deleted. This was done last week and > digest-type 2 and key algorithm should be used. Since end of January > 2023 you could

[swinog] Re: DNSSEC auto-disabled by SWITCH on some .ch domains?

2023-05-01 Diskussionsfäden Benoît Panizzon via swinog
Some update It looks like Gandi at least messed up their Registrar UI. From their point of view, my 'algo 5' .ch domains have still DNSSEC active but deleting DS or disabling DNSSEC hangs forever and upon reloading my old algo 5 keys are back. I guess they perform some API calls to Switch and

[swinog] Re: DNSSEC auto-disabled by SWITCH on some .ch domains?

2023-05-01 Diskussionsfäden Marcus J via swinog
G'day Franco, To the partners at least, in October 2022 informing them that anything containing digest-type 1 and/or key algorithm 5 oder 7 are no longer supported and will be deleted. This was done last week and digest-type 2 and key algorithm should be used. Since end of January 2023 you

[swinog] Re: DNSSEC auto-disabled by SWITCH on some .ch domains?

2023-05-01 Diskussionsfäden John Howard via swinog
Not sure if/how it relates to this situation, but it’s notable that the DNSSEC key signing ceremony was a couple of days ago? https://www.iana.org/dnssec/ceremonies/49 I don’t see any deprecations but maybe someone needs an update somewhere? BR John

[swinog] Re: DNSSEC auto-disabled by SWITCH on some .ch domains?

2023-05-01 Diskussionsfäden Daniel Stirnimann via swinog
I wasn't a part of this procedure so I cannot answer anything related to that. I can, however, respond to questions for which we make information available online. If you want specific information about the procedure I suggest you ask your registrar or you can contact SWITCH at

[swinog] DNSSEC auto-disabled by SWITCH on some .ch domains?

2023-05-01 Diskussionsfäden Franco Hug via swinog
Hey SWINOGgers, I noticed that DNSSEC was somehow auto-disabled at registry level for some .ch domains I am responsible for. For these domains, no DS records are published anymore in the .ch zone, dnsviz shows a broken chain of trust. However, registrar data still shows that DNSSEC is enabled,