RE: [Syslog] timeline

2006-08-15 Thread Miao Fuyou
Rainer, Stunnel is a secure wrapper for TCP stream. Actually delimiting Syslog is done in the TCP part rather than TLS (or stunnel) part in Syslog-ng with stunnel. One can use stunnel to secure any Syslog TCP transport, such as rsyslog and kiwisyslog, and kiwisyslog does use CRLF for delimiting

RE: [Syslog] timeline

2006-08-15 Thread Andrew Ross
Just to clarify, Kiwi Syslog V8 currently sends CRLF as the TCP delimiter, but will accept LF, CR, CRLF, LFCR and NULL as valid delimiters on the incoming stream. We will be changing our sending delimiter to LF in the near future to make it more compatible with syslog-ng etc. Cheers Andrew

Re: [Syslog] timeline

2006-08-15 Thread Balazs Scheidler
On Mon, 2006-08-14 at 12:20 +0200, tom.petch wrote: - Original Message - From: David Harrington [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, August 10, 2006 7:33 PM Subject: [Syslog] timeline 1) whether draft-ietf-syslog-transport-tls should use byte-counting,

RE: [Syslog] timeline

2006-08-15 Thread John Calcote
I vote for byte counting an no magic character. I'm sorry for the backward compatibility problems this may introduce, but things should move ahead, and providing a solid standard is one of the best ways to do this. John Anton Okmianski (aokmians) [EMAIL PROTECTED] 8/11/2006 9:26 AM Here

RE: [Syslog] byte-counting vs special character

2006-08-15 Thread Carson Gaspar
I've been mostly lurking lately, but I would like to re-iterate my support for byte counting. It's the Right Thing To Do, and theoretical backwards compatibility with existing non-standard non-widely-deployed syslog over TCP solutions isn't a good enough reason to put bad ideas in the standard.

[Syslog] WGLC: protocol

2006-08-15 Thread David Harrington
Hi, Here is my review of the protocol-17 document. Let me apologize (slightly) for such a thorough review, late in the process, but as co-chair I need to say I reviewed this thoroughly and that I agree it is ready to be published as a standard. I am much pickier about a document I will sign-off