Just an FYI I've made some changes to the script I wrote to generate a
.osm file from the TDX GTFS stops.txt file.
Hot off the press at http://tianjara.net/data/tdx.nsw.gov.au/non-cc-license/
I'm NOT talking about importing, I'm simply posting this update
because it may be useful as a
On 22/01/13 12:18, Michael Gratton wrote:
Has there been any discussion about the Transport NSW TDX program
https://tdx.131500.com.au/? I note they make available a GTFS file
which should include the lat/long of all stops and stations, which would
be nice to have in OSM.
Their licence looks
On 20/02/13 22:24, Andrew Harvey wrote:
Hmm... seems like they changed from CC-BY back to a custom license?
Yeah, there's some onerous clauses for attribution and re-distribution
and what-not. Pity. I notice you have a copy under the CC-BY licence, I
wonder if that would that be suitable for
Hey Ian,
On 22/01/13 14:08, Ian Sergeant wrote:
Andrew made mention of it, and did some experimentation when it was
first available..
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-au/2012-September/009369.html
Didn't provoke much discussion though, probably because of
On 22 January 2013 23:17, Michael Gratton m...@vee.net wrote:
While stop/station locations infrequently change, routes do seem to come
and go more frequently. It wouldn't be too hard for someone to run a
process on a server somewhere to keep tabs on changes in the feed and
update the map as
On 23/01/13 08:43, Ian Sergeant wrote:
It raises the age old question, if we can't edit it, why put it in OSM?
If each set of data is intended to overwrite the last, what do we do
when people change it?
Oh, I thought OSM was aiming for an objectively correct map via user
contributions, is
On 23 January 2013 09:31, Michael Gratton m...@vee.net wrote:
There's no reason why using feeds such as the TDX is incompatible with
individual user editing. From first-hand experience, even the PT
agencies get their data wrong at times, and so the
legion-with-smartphones out there is still
On 23/01/13 09:48, Ian Sergeant wrote:
But the TDX data is updated very regularly, so if I fix a bus stop
today, how do you know whether you should overwrite that with the
next revision of TDX data tomorrow?
Not really. They may regenerate the feed frequently, but the data rarely
changes
Hey all,
Has there been any discussion about the Transport NSW TDX program
https://tdx.131500.com.au/? I note they make available a GTFS file
which should include the lat/long of all stops and stations, which would
be nice to have in OSM.
Their licence looks rather restrictive however
Hi Michael,
Andrew made mention of it, and did some experimentation when it was first
available..
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-au/2012-September/009369.html
Didn't provoke much discussion though, probably because of
licence/volatility issues.
Ian.
On 22 January 2013 12:18,
10 matches
Mail list logo
