Re: [Tango-L] Type A Tango

2010-12-25 Thread Jack Dylan
From: Mario sopel...@yahoo.com I think that 'Salon' is simply the new catch word for covert 'performance' tango. I agree with Mario. In the past, there were 2 types of Tango - Social and Stage. But Stage is beyond anyone but the most athletic and dedicated of dancers. So, for demonstrating

Re: [Tango-L] Type A Tango

2010-12-25 Thread Sergey Kazachenko
 I guess dancing isn't supposed to be fun when one is in training for 'dancing with the stars'. [...]  I think that 'Salon' is simply the new catch word for covert 'performance' tango. I just don't see what is so performance-y in her dancing. She is keeping her feet on the floor, doing

[Tango-L] Type-A Tango

2010-12-25 Thread Mario
Hi David, yes i have lots of opinionsand probably don't 'know' much about classes...but im trying to distiguish between what goes on in a social dance and what goes on in a class..they seem to be different.. like the 'class' is about a different dance. I agree that the leader here

Re: [Tango-L] Type-A Tango

2010-12-25 Thread Gordon Erlebacher
Until last year at least,, Salon was danced (in a mild form, without many of the figures, but with the elegance) at Por Lo Celia, in Bs.As.. The style was more about elegance than frontal connection. One does not need much space to dance salon. Salon was danced more prior to 1980, when posture,

Re: [Tango-L] Type-A Tango Salon or Show ?

2010-12-25 Thread HBBOOGIE1
For those of you that don’t seem to be able to separate salon tango from performance tango here are two videos that clearly show the difference. The first video is Orlando Paiva dancing at Sunderland. Orlando was the master of smooth elegant tango. Balance, axis, timing and connection. The

Re: [Tango-L] Type-A Tango Salon or Show ?

2010-12-25 Thread Gordon Erlebacher
Notice also the following differences between the two videos: in the second, there is the need of cramming in as many different types of steps as possible within the duration of the song. That in itself is not a characteristic of show tango, but is a characteristic of many dancers of the

Re: [Tango-L] Type-A Tango Salon or Show ?

2010-12-25 Thread Jack Dylan
I agree with all that you say. But the point is that almost no one dances or teaches the style of Orlando Paiva anymore. The dance of Murat and Michelle, on the other hand, is the style that is danced by many of today's teachers who describe their style as 'Salon'. You're correct ... It’s

[Tango-L] Salon dancing is NOT Social dancing

2010-12-25 Thread Mario
the video posted as Salon is to me 'performance dance'you may see that at home in North America on the social dance floor only because of the corruption of the social dance there. The video stopped at the 52 second mark, shows a still picture of a performance dance as the woman is held

Re: [Tango-L] Type-A Tango Salon or Show ?

2010-12-25 Thread Gordon Erlebacher
I agree Jack, that almost no one teaches the style of Orlando Paiva anymore, except his sun Orlando Jr. perhaps. However, that style is a very particular type of Salon. I would place the following teachers in the same category: Javier Rodriguez, Jorge Dispari, Mimi Santapa, Ney Melo. While

Re: [Tango-L] Type-A Tango Salon or Show ?

2010-12-25 Thread Trini y Sean (PATangoS)
I propose a different way of classifying salon or show tango - looking at what the woman is doing.  Is she the one being shown off?  Are her ornaments dominating the dance?  I know when I perform, my ornaments are bigger.  My partner allows me to make them bigger or encourages it.  When I'm

Re: [Tango-L] Type-A Tango Salon or Show ?

2010-12-25 Thread Charles Roques
I agree with all that you say. But the point is that almost no one dances or teaches the style of Orlando Paiva anymore. Not true. I do and have for years, as also do others outside of Argentina. Admittedly and sadly in a minority nowadays but it depends on which circle you travel in. That

Re: [Tango-L] Type-A Tango Salon or Show ?

2010-12-25 Thread HBBOOGIE1
Charles Another thing I see is a lack of conviction when it comes to learning tango. They think they can watch you tube or take a group class from a second rate self-proclaimed wannabe “tango teacher” and 10 minutes later hit the floor and bust a move. That’s tango today quick and easy no

Re: [Tango-L] Type-A Tango Salon or Show ?

2010-12-25 Thread Jack Dylan
From: Charles Roques c.roq...@mchsi.com I agree with all that you say. But the point is that almost no one dances or teaches the style of Orlando Paiva anymore. Not true.  I do and have for years, as also do others outside of Argentina.  That's my point. To me, Tango is what is

Re: [Tango-L] Type-A Tango Salon or Show ?

2010-12-25 Thread Gordon Erlebacher
The fact is that before 1980, most people in Bs.As. danced the elegant tango Salon style, although the Milonguero style was danced as well in packed milongas. However, it is unlikely the milongas were as well attended as they are now. The style of Todaro, Mingo Pugliese, Julio Balmaceda and

[Tango-L] What's in a name?

2010-12-25 Thread Michael
Shakespeare answered that question in Romeo and Juliet with Juliet saying That which we call a rose by any other name would smell as sweet. There have been a numerous posts in the thread Tango Salon or Show? Other terms have been thrown into the discussion: milonguero, apilado, performance,

Re: [Tango-L] What's in a name?

2010-12-25 Thread Gordon Erlebacher
You are correct Michael, we like to dissect. By the way, any dance that is not improvised, is by definition, not social. Of course, if improvised, it might be show or social. I like the following from your post: social dancing's objective is pleasing your partner; stage (performance) dancing

Re: [Tango-L] Type-A Tango Salon or Show ?

2010-12-25 Thread Charles Roques
Tango in Bs.As. takes a wide variety of form. For those who know (I do not), how was tango danced in Bs.As. before the arrival of Susanna Miller, who popularized the so-called frontal style (frontal contact), suitable for crowded milongas? It was danced close just as it always was. Susanna

Re: [Tango-L] Type-A Tango Salon or Show ?

2010-12-25 Thread Jack Dylan
From: Charles Roques c.roq...@mchsi.com Susanna MIller is given far too much credit for something she didn't do.  People were dancing that way long before she supposedly popularized it.  Personally, I think Susana Miller deserves all the credit she receives. Of course, she didn't invent