Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-29 Thread Attila Kinali
On Sun, 23 Aug 2015 19:29:29 -0700 Hal Murray hmur...@megapathdsl.net wrote: What's magic about a crystal as compared to an osc? Is it really easier to get an odd-ball frequency in a crystal vs an osc? As Bob already mentioned, there are more frequencies/types to pick from when going for

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-29 Thread Bob Camp
On Aug 29, 2015, at 9:48 AM, Attila Kinali att...@kinali.ch wrote: On Sun, 23 Aug 2015 19:29:29 -0700 Hal Murray hmur...@megapathdsl.net wrote: What's magic about a crystal as compared to an osc? Is it really easier to get an odd-ball frequency in a crystal vs an osc? As Bob

[time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-25 Thread Mark Sims
Real time nuts use Comet Cleanser to raise their xtal frequency and a graphite pencil to lower it. Only crystal cretins would use toothpaste ;-) All my FT-243's are more acc'rit than those new-fangled silly slezium and rubitinium oscillators and masery thingamabobs. Geeze, them youngin's

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-24 Thread Don Latham
Gee whatever happened to slipping it out of the ol' FT holder and rubbing with a little toothpaste? g Don Bob Camp Hi On Aug 23, 2015, at 10:29 PM, Hal Murray hmur...@megapathdsl.net wrote: kb...@n1k.org said: There is not a lot to an un-compensated crystal oscillator. Tuning it on

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-24 Thread David
, 23 Aug 2015 08:33:59 -0400 From: Bob Camp kb...@n1k.org To: gandal...@aol.com, Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement time-nuts@febo.com Subject: Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator Message-ID: 86abcf10-fc65-4713-b286-bdc3e33fe...@n1k.org Content-Type

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-24 Thread Gary Woods
On Mon, 24 Aug 2015 18:18:14 -0400, you wrote: If you do drop one into a “modern” circuit, it’s worth noting that the crystal in an FT style holder has another capacitor in it when compared to the model of a modern (plated electrode) crystal. The air gap is the source of the element. Net result

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-23 Thread GandalfG8--- via time-nuts
H I think I'm convinced, I had my doubts to start with and now have enough more to ensure I follow a different route:-) Regards Nigel GM8PZR Hi If they are indeed grabbing anything in that package and re-labeling it, I would be very careful. True TCXO’s (full compensation

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-23 Thread Bob Camp
Hi I think the lead length on the parts argues against them being pulls from boards. It does *not* eliminate the possibility. I’ve seen low cost manufacture that never did any lead trim. I would not put it at the top of my list for “fancy oscillator of the year”. The price is high enough that

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-23 Thread GandalfG8--- via time-nuts
Hi Tim, Thanks for your comments and I did wonder about the plating, in the photo for the auction number I gave I couldn't decide if the bottom of the can was corroded or just badly plated. Regards Nigel GM8PZR Mainstream TCXO's moved entirely to surface-mount many years ago. These

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-23 Thread Pete Lancashire
From the way the descriptions read, there must be a audiofool in there somewhere On Sun, Aug 23, 2015 at 5:16 AM, Tim Shoppa tsho...@gmail.com wrote: Mainstream TCXO's moved entirely to surface-mount many years ago. These Vanguard DIP units have to be washed/replated RFE parts. It's a shame

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-23 Thread GandalfG8--- via time-nuts
Hi Bob, Just the sort of things I was wondering and lot's of questions indeed, that's why I asked, I didn't want to be the guinea pig:-) Regards Nigel GM8PZR Hi A few things I would wonder about: 1) Is it 0.1 ppm over 0 to 50C (or some other range)? If not, what is the

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-23 Thread Tim Shoppa
Mainstream TCXO's moved entirely to surface-mount many years ago. These Vanguard DIP units have to be washed/replated RFE parts. It's a shame they are so completely relabeled because the original manufacturer/part number is nowhere to be found, and I'm sure this lost info would be interesting to

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-23 Thread Bob Camp
Hi A few things I would wonder about: 1) Is it 0.1 ppm over 0 to 50C (or some other range)? If not, what is the temperature stability? 2) Does it run at 3.3V -or- at 5V (pick one) or do they run equally well at either voltage? 3) Since there is no EFC, is 0.1 ppm the set tolerance? If it’s

[time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-23 Thread GandalfG8--- via time-nuts
The Vanguard ultra precision Golden TCXO, their description not mine:-), has been listed on Ebay for a while now at various frequencies, and the 0.1 ppm spec caught my eye as a possible replacement for the around 6 or 7 ppm oscillator in a DDS function generator I've been using. One

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-23 Thread Bob Camp
Hi If they are indeed grabbing anything in that package and re-labeling it, I would be very careful. True TCXO’s (full compensation network) in that package are relatively rare compared to the enormous number of “precision XO’s” made in the same package. The XO’s had no real compensation.

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-23 Thread Bill Byrom
I can't imagine that anyone would trust some 0.1 ppm specification just because an unknown party stamped that on the case. There are many sellers of very similarly marked oscillators. They all are selling in single quantities for about the same price. The market seems to be hobbyists, especially

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-23 Thread Bob Camp
Hi I just spent some “quality time” looking at what Mouser offers in the way of crystal oscillators. None of this work was NIST certified. Others could do the same thing. You have a number of candidates in the “dip clock” stability category both in traditional (leaded) and modern (SMT)

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-23 Thread David
Subject: Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator Message-ID: 86abcf10-fc65-4713-b286-bdc3e33fe...@n1k.org Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8 Hi A few things I would wonder about: 1) Is it 0.1 ppm over 0 to 50C (or some other range)? If not, what is the temperature

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-23 Thread Gary Woods
On Sun, 23 Aug 2015 12:13:47 -0400, you wrote: Thanks for your comments and I did wonder about the plating, This looks like the same package the Chinese are selling for the Kenwood TS-590 to upgrade the already good internal timebase. The reports on them are pretty good, though few have an

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-23 Thread Bob Camp
and frequency measurement time-nuts@febo.com Subject: Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator Message-ID: 86abcf10-fc65-4713-b286-bdc3e33fe...@n1k.org Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8 Hi A few things I would wonder about: 1) Is it 0.1 ppm over 0 to 50C

Re: [time-nuts] Vanguard Ultra precision Golden Oscillator

2015-08-23 Thread Hal Murray
kb...@n1k.org said: There is not a lot to an un-compensated crystal oscillator. Tuning it on frequency is fairly simple. Even for odd frequencies Mouser will happily sell you a crystal for next to nothing. Toss in a handful of parts and you have a very respectable oscillator. For a basement