Re: Question regarding mental illness rates and gender

2005-04-01 Thread Allen Esterson
Scott wrote: Some good high-profile examples (although there are some differences in some studies, which may be moderated by age of the samples in some cases) of disorders showing few or minimal sex differences in most epidemiological studies are schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and

Re: Question regarding mental illness rates and gender

2005-04-01 Thread Scott Lilienfeld
Yes, and interestingly, I believe there's some good data indicating that the hoarding subtype of OCD is marked by male predominance. Interesting ...Scott Allen Esterson wrote: Scott wrote: Some good high-profile examples (although there are some differences in some studies,

Postcard Secrets

2005-04-01 Thread Todd Nelson
TIPSters, This morning I heard about this fascinating project in art/psychology: an artist created a bunch of blank postcards on which people were invited to write a secret they have never told anyone, and then anonymously mail it to the artist. The range of secrets reveal an incredible panorama

Re: Postcard Secrets

2005-04-01 Thread Don Allen
Well it may be art but I don't see what it has to do with psychology. It looks like just another cheap appeal to people's prurient interests. How do you see this as relating to the psychological literature? -Don. Todd Nelson said: TIPSters, This morning I heard about this fascinating

Re: Postcard Secrets

2005-04-01 Thread Beth Benoit
I didn't think it appealed just to prurient interest. I can see two psychological applications very easily: 1) the desire to feel that your behavior is normal, and 2) deindividuation. Thus it might be useful in an abnormal psych. class or in social psych. When studying deindividuation, my

Re: Postcard Secrets

2005-04-01 Thread Marie Helweg-Larsen
Like Todd I think the post cards are fascinating and provides a wealth of interesting discussion points. What types of secrets do people reveal? Are they big secrets or small secrets to us? To the person? What roles do secrets play in people's lives? (lots of implications for mental health

RE: Postcard Secrets

2005-04-01 Thread DeVolder Carol L
When I was a TA in grad school, we were instructed to do something similar as an activity. We were to instruct the intro psych students to take a 3X5 card and write down what they would do if nobody else would ever find out. I told them their responses would remain anonymous but would be read

Re: Postcard Secrets

2005-04-01 Thread Beth Benoit
I have had a couple of disturbing offerings in the past and just chose not to read those aloud in class. But I try not to be too censorious, since part of the purpose of the exercise is to show how human behavior might be much different if it weren't for the controls that society places on it.

Re: Postcard Secrets

2005-04-01 Thread Beth Benoit
Oh, and are you sure it was a young man? The divulger might have been female - or old!! (Okay, that's my 3 for the day, and the first in a long time.) Beth Benoit University System of New Hampshire - Original Message - From: DeVolder Carol L [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Teaching in the

Re: Postcard Secrets

2005-04-01 Thread Marie Helweg-Larsen
Oh that is a funny story. I use that exercise in class too although the point I make is that most people chose selfish or self-serving actions when offered to do anything. The modal response of my students want to listen in on other people's conversations to find out what they really think.

postcard psych

2005-04-01 Thread Gerald Peterson
Now aren't they precious! Of course any such ideas can be fodder for psych study. We might discuss the way some surveys/questionnaires could be designed when asking about hot or sensitive topics--illegal behaviors, etc., and the response biases likely with the postcards? How do social

Re: Postcard Secrets

2005-04-01 Thread Ken Steele
Beth Benoit wrote: Interestingly, despite the reported norm of having the confessions be most likely to be sexual, my students always lean heavily toward I would rob a bank. Perhaps for my students, money is more appealing than illicit sex. Money is less readily available ;-) Ken

The Schiavo Case and Death by Starvation

2005-04-01 Thread jim clark
Hi One of the dubious claims around this issue concerned how painful death by starvation is supposed to be. Everything I have found so far (e.g., hospice studies, holocaust victims, hunger strikers, ...) suggests exactly the opposite; that is, people die in a relatively quiet and peaceful

Re: The Schiavo Case and Death by Starvation

2005-04-01 Thread Stuart Mckelvie
Dear Tipsters, http://users.bigpond.net.au/icry/chapter_32.htm This link contains a description of what happens to people like Bobby Sands, who starved himself to death. Stuart Date sent: Fri, 1 Apr 2005 15:11:12 -0600 (CST) From: jim clark [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: The Schiavo Case and Death by Starvation

2005-04-01 Thread jim clark
Hi On Fri, 1 Apr 2005, Stuart Mckelvie wrote: http://users.bigpond.net.au/icry/chapter_32.htm This link contains a description of what happens to people like Bobby Sands, who starved himself to death. Here is the relevant passage with respect to death by starvation:

Re: The Schiavo Case and Death by Starvation

2005-04-01 Thread Stuart Mckelvie
Dear Jim, Your contribution is thought-provoking. Could the context play a role in what a starving person experiences? It could certainly play a role in the way that the death is reported. Stuart Date sent: Fri, 1 Apr 2005 16:03:05 -0600 (CST) From: jim clark

RE: The Schiavo Case and Death by Starvation

2005-04-01 Thread Shearon, Tim
All of what I'm about to write is personally uncomfortable to me but it seems to need to be said (to me anyway). It seems to me that the description mentioned re Mr. Sands is rather politically motivated in its description (not on the part of the poster but in its origins). I.e., it is partly to

Re: The Schiavo Case and Death by Starvation

2005-04-01 Thread Paul Smith
jim clark wrote: On a side note (and a somewhat political one at that), if there is any case that should give thoughtful people really serious concern about George W Bush's so-called faith-based initiatives, this would be it! True, but at the same time, her death could as easily be read as the

Re: The Schiavo Case and Death by Starvation

2005-04-01 Thread Chuck Huff
But, folks, it was not starvation. It was dehydration. Removing the feeding tube meant both food and water were removed. Death by dehydration is much faster (not on the order of 30-40 days). -Chuck jim clark wrote: On a side note (and a somewhat political one at that), if there is any case

Death by Starvation

2005-04-01 Thread sblack
On Fri, 1 Apr 2005, Stuart Mckelvie wrote: http://users.bigpond.net.au/icry/chapter_32.htm This link contains a description of what happens to people like Bobby Sands, who starved himself to death. and Jim Clark countered: The above description really differs markedly from

Re: The Schiavo Case and Death by Starvation

2005-04-01 Thread Bill Scott
You might turn to the description of starvation by Charles Bukowski, supposedly based on actual experience in a note on starvation http://www.smog.net/writers/bukowski/vault/poem1977-10-15-a_note_upon_starvation.jpg Bill Scott --- You are currently subscribed to tips as: archive@jab.org To

Barbara De Angelis John Gray

2005-04-01 Thread Allen Shoemaker
it seems to me that at some time tipsters mentioned that Barbara deAngelis has her phd from the same mail order university as John Gray. Does anyone have any specific details on this? Here's the info, from http://www.wayneandtamara.com/johngray.htm : John Gray's first wife,Barbara De

RE: Death by Starvation

2005-04-01 Thread Rick Adams
Actually, I've seen death by voluntary starvation before (in Vietnam and in India) both times involving Buddhist monks engaged in a protest of war. Contrary to many of the claims I've read, it need be neither gruesome or painful. In both cases I observed (and others I've heard of from very

Re: Concerning Terri Schiavo's Mental State

2005-04-01 Thread sblack
I have one more comment on this matter before I fall silent as Wittgenstein recommends. And in deference to Claudia Stanny and despite the header of this thread, my comments are intended generally rather than specifically directed at Terri Schiavo's sad case now at last concluded. Michael