Re: Re: Gallup, fundamentalism and biasing

2002-09-23 Thread David L Gent
Teaching in the Psychological Sciences digest wrote: Various messages of various lengths. Is there a hint of prejudice against Christians here? Assuming that someone who is a strongly believing Christian is ipso facto going to be in some way dishonest is as ridiculous as assuming that

Re: Gallup, fundamentalism and biasing

2002-09-23 Thread Beth Benoit
Mea culpa, David. I don't know where my politically correct mind was when I posted that unnecessary last comment. I think a little bit of hostility against certain rather whacko family members was creeping in. Geez, there's bias everywhere I look! (In the mirror...) Please accept my apology

Re: Gallup, fundamentalism and biasing

2002-09-23 Thread James Guinee
My personal experience has been that fundamentalists feel they are behaving immorally if they fail to do whatever is necessary to promote Christianity. While fundamentalists may believe wholeheartedly in promoting their belief system, they would be ironically behaving immorally in doing

Gallup, fundamentalism and biasing

2002-09-20 Thread Beth Benoit
Title: Gallup, fundamentalism and biasing I was curious about this Annette, so did a little research. George Gallup, of Gallup Poll fame, died in 1984 (he was 83), so that precludes any present personal biasing of results. However... A look at the Gallup Organization's website (www.gallup.com

RE: Gallup, fundamentalism and biasing

2002-09-20 Thread Paul Smith
Beth Benoit wrote: I was curious about this Annette, so did a little research. George Gallup, of Gallup Poll fame, died in 1984 (he was 83), so that precludes any present personal biasing of results. Well, only if you're one of those atheistic, death-is-the-end-of-it-all types.

Re: Gallup, fundamentalism and biasing

2002-09-20 Thread Annette Taylor, Ph. D.
Quoting Beth Benoit [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Does this mean he biases the questions in the Gallup polls? A very good question. Thanks for your time and effort! Wow! I was hoping for an off the top of the head quick answer. Ok, so I guess I was thinking along the lines of sampling--can it be

Re: Gallup, fundamentalism and biasing

2002-09-20 Thread Beth Benoit
Absolutely. DO they? We'd like to think not. But besides the possibility of stratification and clustering biases, it's certainly within the realm of possibility to word a question in a leading manner. I suspect that Gallup is generally better than that, but I haven't made any effort to examine

Re: Gallup, fundamentalism and biasing

2002-09-20 Thread Paul Smith
Beth Benoit wrote: I challenge TIPSters to keep a critical eye on poll questioning (even not from Gallup), and let's see what we can find. A reliable source of bad questions is netscape.com, which has a different poll everyday, each as bad as today's: == Poll: Should