RE: [4.1.23] Deprecating mod_webapp

2003-03-21 Thread George Sexton
PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, March 20, 2003 2:22 AM To: Tomcat Developers List Subject: Re: [4.1.23] Deprecating mod_webapp On Wed, 19 Mar 2003, George Sexton wrote: | From a purely practical standpoint, that would be terribly complicated. | Mod_webapp would have to read and fully understand

RE: [4.1.23] Deprecating mod_webapp

2003-03-21 Thread Costin Manolache
George Sexton wrote: Before anyone writes this kind of thing they should examine a representative number of web applications and find out how many would actually benefit. I.E. how many web applications have significant It is a bit late - the code for this kind of thing is already written and

Re: [4.1.23] Deprecating mod_webapp

2003-03-20 Thread Henri Gomez
George Sexton wrote: From a purely practical standpoint, that would be terribly complicated. Mod_webapp would have to read and fully understand the web.xml and all of the servlet mappings. This is made even more impossible by the addition of filters to the Servlet API. How can mod_webapp even

Re: [4.1.23] Deprecating mod_webapp

2003-03-20 Thread Endre Stølsvik
On Wed, 19 Mar 2003, George Sexton wrote: | From a purely practical standpoint, that would be terribly complicated. | Mod_webapp would have to read and fully understand the web.xml and all of | the servlet mappings. This is made even more impossible by the addition of | filters to the Servlet

Re: [4.1.23] Deprecating mod_webapp

2003-03-20 Thread jean-frederic clere
Remy Maucherat wrote: Hi, I'd like to officially deprecate mod_webapp in Tomcat 4.1.23. +1 :-(( I am using jk2 in 2 FSC products so I prefer that the energies go to one connector instead beeing spread in severals. It is no longer maintained, and will not work with Tomcat 5.0 (at least it won't

Re: [4.1.23] Deprecating mod_webapp

2003-03-19 Thread Endre Stølsvik
On Mon, 17 Mar 2003, George Sexton wrote: | It's also horribly broken and not compliant with the servlet API. | Specifically, it doesn't forward all requests within the context to the | servlet engine, but attempts to let Apache fulfill static requests. Isn't that one of the good reasons for

RE: [4.1.23] Deprecating mod_webapp

2003-03-19 Thread George Sexton
] Deprecating mod_webapp On Mon, 17 Mar 2003, George Sexton wrote: | It's also horribly broken and not compliant with the servlet API. | Specifically, it doesn't forward all requests within the context to the | servlet engine, but attempts to let Apache fulfill static requests. Isn't that one

[4.1.23] Deprecating mod_webapp

2003-03-17 Thread Remy Maucherat
Hi, I'd like to officially deprecate mod_webapp in Tomcat 4.1.23. It is no longer maintained, and will not work with Tomcat 5.0 (at least it won't unless people contribute stuff). Remy - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL

Re: [4.1.23] Deprecating mod_webapp

2003-03-17 Thread Glenn Nielsen
+1 Remy Maucherat wrote: Hi, I'd like to officially deprecate mod_webapp in Tomcat 4.1.23. It is no longer maintained, and will not work with Tomcat 5.0 (at least it won't unless people contribute stuff). Remy - To

RE: [4.1.23] Deprecating mod_webapp

2003-03-17 Thread George Sexton
, March 17, 2003 2:34 AM To: Tomcat Developers List Subject: [4.1.23] Deprecating mod_webapp Hi, I'd like to officially deprecate mod_webapp in Tomcat 4.1.23. It is no longer maintained, and will not work with Tomcat 5.0 (at least it won't unless people contribute stuff). Remy