Re: Release process guide checklist, was Fwd: [VOTE] Release SDO Java 1.0-incubating

2007-07-25 Thread Venkata Krishnan
Hi, I'd like the release guide if the steps we follow are a bit different than what is normally done or if there are some variations to how we perform some steps. But if we were just about going to rephrase all of what has already been said somewhere else I'd prefer just about having a pointer

Re: Release process guide checklist, was Fwd: [VOTE] Release SDO Java 1.0-incubating

2007-07-25 Thread ant elder
As an example of how much simpler things could be if we got our maven builds set up so maven automated everything see: http://incubator.apache.org/cxf/building.html#Building-Performingarelease But, I still think a RM should understand whats going on so mvn shouldn't be a substitute for having

Re: Release process guide checklist, was Fwd: [VOTE] Release SDO Java 1.0-incubating

2007-07-25 Thread Luciano Resende
Let me come up with some initial document over the weekend, and we could start providing feedback on top of that, also we could check if there is going to be any value on that or not. On 7/25/07, ant elder [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: As an example of how much simpler things could be if we got our

Re: Release process guide checklist, was Fwd: [VOTE] Release SDO Java 1.0-incubating

2007-07-24 Thread Mike Edwards
Luciano Resende wrote: Should we start thinking on a formal release guide, merging together couple documents we already have as of today, and also creating a checklist as it looks like couple release candidates are having the same issues ? +1 - yes, most definitely. Yours, Mike.

Re: Release process guide checklist, was Fwd: [VOTE] Release SDO Java 1.0-incubating

2007-07-24 Thread ant elder
I agree we could do things to improve our releases. Most ASF releases end up having several RCs, its a natural part of the process, I'm not sure it indicates any failing somewhere. We've been restructuring our builds and distributions recently, with changes like that going on there will be

Re: Release process guide checklist, was Fwd: [VOTE] Release SDO Java 1.0-incubating

2007-07-24 Thread Simon Laws
snip.. There's already lots of doc about doing releases in the ASF - on the ASF main dev pages and within the Incubator site etc. The problem with there being lots of docs is that there are, ahem, lots of docs. Where is the definitive set of guides that provide the detail required to

Re: Release process guide checklist, was Fwd: [VOTE] Release SDO Java 1.0-incubating

2007-07-24 Thread Robert Burrell Donkin
On 7/24/07, ant elder [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I agree we could do things to improve our releases. Most ASF releases end up having several RCs, its a natural part of the process, I'm not sure it indicates any failing somewhere. IMHO when you use the RC method, having multiple RCs does not

Re: Release process guide checklist, was Fwd: [VOTE] Release SDO Java 1.0-incubating

2007-07-24 Thread Robert Burrell Donkin
On 7/24/07, ant elder [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: snip - change builds to use the maven release plugin to avoid most of the manual steps when creating a release - use maven to as much as possible automate the adding of dependency information to the LICENSE and NOTICE files - update the RAT tool

Release process guide checklist, was Fwd: [VOTE] Release SDO Java 1.0-incubating

2007-07-23 Thread Luciano Resende
Should we start thinking on a formal release guide, merging together couple documents we already have as of today, and also creating a checklist as it looks like couple release candidates are having the same issues ? -- Forwarded message -- From: ant elder [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: