I don't see any evidence in here that this is a bug in mpg123 and I see
a Fix Released both upstream and in ubuntu for dir2ogg, so I will mark
the mpg123 task as Invalid. If this is a bug in mpg123, please re-open
the bug. Thanks!
** Changed in: mpg123 (Ubuntu)
Status: New = Invalid
--
David Futcher wrote:
I don't see any evidence in here that this is a bug in mpg123 and I
see a Fix Released both upstream and in ubuntu for dir2ogg,
so I will mark the mpg123 task as Invalid
The fix in dir2ogg should really be considered a work around. It is just
passing the sample rate of the
The fix in dir2ogg should really be considered a work around. It is
just passing the sample rate of the MP3 to mpg123 via the -R
option. mpg321does not require this.
OK, -R is passed to oggenc. mpg123 outputs streams with the same sample rate as
the input, whereas the other decoders use
** Branch linked: lp:debian/squeeze/dir2ogg
--
dir2ogg produces sped-up OGG output
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/272341
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
--
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com
** Branch linked: lp:ubuntu/karmic/dir2ogg
--
dir2ogg produces sped-up OGG output
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/272341
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
--
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com
This bug was fixed in the package dir2ogg - 0.11.7-1
---
dir2ogg (0.11.7-1) unstable; urgency=low
* New bugfix release:
- Fix problems with mpg123 and files not using 44100Hz (LP: #272341)
- Make --preserve-wav work when using mplayer (Closes: #513566)
- Fix problem
revno: 63
committer: Julian Andres Klode j...@jak-linux.org
branch nick: dir2ogg
timestamp: Sun 2009-05-03 15:34:09 +0200
message:
* Fix problems with mpg123 and files not using 44100Hz (LP: #272341)
** Changed in: dir2ogg
dir2ogg (0.11.7) RELEASED; urgency=low
* Recognize the track number in mp3 files
* Fix problems with mpg123 and files not using 44100Hz (LP: #272341)
* Make --preserve-wav work when using mplayer (Closes: #513566)
* Fix problem where tags from one file appear in other files (LP: #276037)
I have studied attached mp3 and, i think, have found in what a problem.
It is similar to about what I wrote, but instead of number of channels
here it is a question of frequency of digitization.
The file is coded with frequency of 22050 Hz, with such frequency mpg123
plays it, but oggenc
This bug can not be fixed, because it's no real bug in dir2ogg. It's
more or less a problem in mpg123.
So, what next, Julian? Should someone reassign this bug report to mpg123
or is Alexey right and this is actually a dir2ogg problem?
--
dir2ogg produces sped-up OGG output
** Attachment removed: The troublesome mp3 file
http://launchpadlibrarian.net/17772111/young_marble_giants_-_final_day.mp3
--
dir2ogg produces sped-up OGG output
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/272341
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is
1) you added the code to the smart mp3 function. Therefore, it's only enabled
when --smart-mp3 is activated.
2) you did the following: mode in ('STEREO', 'JOINTSTEREO', 'DUALCHANNEL')
This is wrong. STEREO, etc. are variables of mutagen.mp3 and represent an
integer value.
3) the
I think this bug may happen because dir2ogg not care about number of
channels in input mp3 - when decoding mono input through stdin oggenc
not supplied with -C 1 parameter. This leads to encode mono stream as
stereo. Now I try to fix this and will send patch there, if succeed.
Sorry for my bad
I add setting parameter -C to oggenc based on mp3info.info.mode from
mutagen. My changes applies only to converting mp3 through stdin/stdout,
also I add info line with number of detected channels. Please review my
changes. I tested it on my mono/stereo mp3's and all be allright.
It's my first
Thank you for reporting this bug. In order to solve your problems,
you need to use a different decoder for the file.
Use one of
--mp3-decoder=lame
--mp3-decoder=mplayer
to create a correct output file. (Use --help to see which decoders are
available).
BTW, do you have any permission to
I tried the different decoders. Lame doesn't seem to be available;
mplayer results in a correct file; and mpg123 (the other option) results
in a similarly sped-up OGG file.
BTW, do you have any permission to distribute the MP3 file? If not,
please remove it.
Obviously I don't. But I have no
The attached patch checks the length and prints warnings if lengths
differ by a at least 1 second.
In your case, it prints:
Warning: Length changed (-51 sec). If the file does not work, try a different
decoder.
Is this solution acceptable for you?
** Attachment added: warn-length.diff
BTW; it does not abort if the length changed, it only displays a
warning.
--
dir2ogg produces sped-up OGG output
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/272341
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
--
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
Is this solution acceptable for you?
It's *better*, absolutely. If a bugfix which stops the speedup is not on
offer, I'll settle for a warning or error.
BTW; it does not abort if the length changed, it only displays a
warning.
Hm. Is there any circumstance in which changing the length (and
2008/9/21 gwern [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Is this solution acceptable for you?
It's *better*, absolutely. If a bugfix which stops the speedup is not on
offer, I'll settle for a warning or error.
This bug can not be fixed, because it's no real bug in dir2ogg. It's
more or less a problem in mpg123.
Is this solution acceptable for you?
It's *better*, absolutely. If a bugfix which stops the speedup is not on
offer, I'll settle for a warning or error.
This bug can not be fixed, because it's no real bug in dir2ogg. It's
more or less a problem in mpg123.
Hm. Is there any circumstance in
** Attachment added: The troublesome mp3 file
http://launchpadlibrarian.net/17772111/young_marble_giants_-_final_day.mp3
--
dir2ogg produces sped-up OGG output
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/272341
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is
22 matches
Mail list logo
