[Bug 521672] Re: Startup in Karmic with unclean filesystems leaves system in a wrong state

2010-04-16 Thread Scott James Remnant
From the bug description, this sounds like an issue with the karmic mountall where it would continue when it shouldn't - this has been fixed in Lucid ** Changed in: mountall (Ubuntu) Status: New = Fix Released -- Startup in Karmic with unclean filesystems leaves system in a wrong state

[Bug 521672] Re: Startup in Karmic with unclean filesystems leaves system in a wrong state

2010-04-12 Thread Martin Rehn
Is this behavior really by design? If so, it is a very bad one. By default, the system should wait until all file systems are available before letting the user log in. Otherwise, the user can suffer data loss as follows: 1) Boot with unmounted file systems. The mount points will look like empty

[Bug 521672] Re: Startup in Karmic with unclean filesystems leaves system in a wrong state

2010-02-17 Thread Sven Boden
If I drop to the shell I can let the fsck finish and start the X environment manually (just as a work around). If I don't do anything I can login via the GUI, but since my home directory is not ready by then I just get an empty desktop and a warning dialog like cannot access home directory,

[Bug 521672] Re: Startup in Karmic with unclean filesystems leaves system in a wrong state

2010-02-16 Thread Gabe Gorelick
Why is dropping to a shell a good solution? Doesn't the fsck eventually finish and then you can access your separate partition? It seems much better to give the user a fast boot and most of their desktop (sans corrupted home directory) than to just give them a shell with no home directory. **