Re: Akkha script (used by Eastern Magar language) in ISO 15924?

2019-07-23 Thread Anshuman Pandey via Unicode
> On Jul 23, 2019, at 12:26 AM, Richard Wordingham via Unicode > wrote: > > On Mon, 22 Jul 2019 17:42:37 -0700 > Anshuman Pandey via Unicode wrote: > >> As I pointed out in L2/11-144, the “Magar Akkha” script is an >> appropriation of Brahmi, renamed to link it to the primordialist >>

Re: Akkha script (used by Eastern Magar language) in ISO 15924?

2019-07-23 Thread Richard Wordingham via Unicode
On Mon, 22 Jul 2019 17:42:37 -0700 Anshuman Pandey via Unicode wrote: > As I pointed out in L2/11-144, the “Magar Akkha” script is an > appropriation of Brahmi, renamed to link it to the primordialist > daydreams of an ethno-linguistic community in Nepal. I have never > seen actual usage of the

Re: Akkha script (used by Eastern Magar language) in ISO 15924?

2019-07-22 Thread Philippe Verdy via Unicode
So can I conclude that what The Ethnologue displays (using a private-use ISO 15924 "Qabl") is wrong ? And that translations classified under "mgp-Brah" are fine (while "mgp-Qabl" would be unusable for interchange) ? Le mar. 23 juil. 2019 à 02:42, Anshuman Pandey a écrit : > As I pointed out in

Re: Akkha script (used by Eastern Magar language) in ISO 15924?

2019-07-22 Thread Anshuman Pandey via Unicode
As I pointed out in L2/11-144, the “Magar Akkha” script is an appropriation of Brahmi, renamed to link it to the primordialist daydreams of an ethno-linguistic community in Nepal. I have never seen actual usage of the script by Magars. If things have changed since 2011, I would very much

Re: Akkha script (used by Eastern Magar language) in ISO 15924?

2019-07-22 Thread Philippe Verdy via Unicode
Also we can note that "mgp" (Eastern Magari) is severely endangered according to multiple sources include Ethnologue and the Linguist List. This is still not the case for Western Magari (mostly on Nepal, not in Sikkim India), where evidence is probably easier to find (where the encoding of a new

Re: Akkha script (used by Eastern Magar language) in ISO 15924?

2019-07-22 Thread Philippe Verdy via Unicode
Le lun. 22 juil. 2019 à 18:43, Ken Whistler a écrit : > See the entry for "Magar Akkha" on: > > http://linguistics.berkeley.edu/sei/scripts-not-encoded.html > > Anshuman Pandey did preliminary research on this in 2011. > That's what I said: 8 years ago already. >

Re: Akkha script (used by Eastern Magar language) in ISO 15924?

2019-07-22 Thread Lorna Evans via Unicode
Also: https://scriptsource.org/scr/Qabl On Mon, Jul 22, 2019, 12:47 PM Ken Whistler via Unicode wrote: > See the entry for "Magar Akkha" on: > > http://linguistics.berkeley.edu/sei/scripts-not-encoded.html > > Anshuman Pandey did preliminary research on this in 2011. > >

Re: Akkha script (used by Eastern Magar language) in ISO 15924?

2019-07-22 Thread Ken Whistler via Unicode
See the entry for "Magar Akkha" on: http://linguistics.berkeley.edu/sei/scripts-not-encoded.html Anshuman Pandey did preliminary research on this in 2011. http://www.unicode.org/L2/L2011/11144-magar-akkha.pdf It would be premature to assign an ISO 15924 script code, pending the research to

Akkha script (used by Eastern Magar language) in ISO 15924?

2019-07-22 Thread Philippe Verdy via Unicode
According to Ethnolog, the Eastern Magar language (mgp) is written in two scripts: Devanagari and "Akkha". But the "Akkha" script does not seem to have any ISO 15924 code. The Ethnologue currently assigns a private use code (Qabl) for this script. Was the addition delayed due to lack of